Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Winter 1974 · Features

Q&A with President Ikeda

NSA Quarterly, Winter 1974 (Vol. 2, No. 1), pp. 137–139. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

President Ikeda

Life After Death

QUESTION: I am curious about life after death. Dengyo the Great said, “The two laws of life and death are the mystic work of Ichinen.” Does that which is called self or individuality continue to exist even after death?

ANSWER: The late second president, Josei Toda, used to say, “By death, the self permeating life melts into the life of the universe, yet without doubt continues to exist.” Some cause inherent in each life enables “self,” which merges with the universe through death to manifest itself again in accordance with its karma.

President Toda said at another time, “The relation between past and present life can be aptly compared to the time before sleeping and that after waking.” Mind or consciousness does not function during sleep, but this does not mean that it has disappeared. It resumes its work the moment you are shaken awake. Asleep — awake — asleep; likewise, life — death — life, eternally. Another example: joy is felt at one moment, and sorrow may well be the next. The phenomenon of rising and fading emotions is a proper illustration of the eternal repetition of life and death.

Here we have to notice that the self viewed from the standpoint of connection to a social environment is different from the self which is eternal and which we should call the true self. The self as it is dealt with by psychology or sociology has to do with the individual’s level of responsibility or social status. In other words, the self we think most about on a daily basis refers to such qualifications as, “I am an artist . . . She is a bank clerk . . . They are students, etc.”

Such selfhood is naturally subject to change if there is change in the environment which supports its identity. And, of course, death extinguishes self as it is so defined. A passage from the Gosho states, The utmost position of royalty or wealth is as nothing. This is well illustrated by the tale which depicts people being stripped by a demon of all they have when they cross the river Styx (symbolizing death). Our social self is not of the essential nature of self which penetrates the three existences of life. The social self is not unlike a robe which ornaments oneself in society.

True self underlies the stark reality of existence. It is what remains as one’s life after title, power and all else is taken away. What counts at this basic level is a pure heart of justice, dauntless spirit, wisdom and sound health. Most important, that which enables a rich and staunch self is the faith and practice of true Buddhism.

The utmost unhappiness in modern times results from mistaking a social role for one’s true self. People lack awareness of their true self and of its priority, so external fashion is overly catered to. Overcome by the glitter of a social role, we lose sight of ourselves.

If we stop to consider the entity of our life which exists in a permanent cycle of life and death, it may well be understood that superficial estimation of oneself and others is cause for an increasing hollowness within our lives. The true self is not that which comes to nothing by death, but an identity (Ga) which repeats an eternal cycle of life and death.

All we have to recognize is that the true self can be built not through a compulsive social rat race, but through persistent human revolution carried out amid the bustle of social activities. We should not be active for the sake of glory, promotion or fame. Rather, we should be active with the faith and practice of true Buddhism as a basis; Buddhism is of itself the basis of life. I would say no other way of life as a human being is more sublime than the dedication of self to the rhythm of the universe and the creation of harmony in this presently mixed-up world.

Doubt-free Faith

QUESTION: We hear that the practice of religion should be based upon doubt-free faith (Mugi Wasshin), but how can we differentiate between doubting and merely contemplating or pondering?

ANSWER: To ponder or to contemplate and to doubt are essentially different in meaning. This can be attributed to the negative connotation attached to doubting.

Rene Descartes, the 17th-century French scientist and philosopher, said: “Cogito ergo sum.” But this can be translated in two ways: “I think, therefore I am,” and “I doubt, therefore I am.”

For Descartes, doubting meant first to doubt and then to discard all preconceptions in the process of finding the prime point of belief. Finally, he discovered the immobile prime point of reasoning that to him was beyond doubt.

Our daily use of the phrase, to doubt, does not have the same meaning as Descartes’ use of it. Instead, ours is shaded with nihilism which rejects distinctions in moral value and is of the doctrine that nothing is truly believable. Descartes, on the other hand, took the positive role of considering phenomena afresh after doubt had cleared the shortsighted view of things.

In this sense, it does not seem right to translate Descartes’ statement as, “I doubt, therefore I am.” That is to say, thinking with reason and merely doubting for the sake of doubting are entirely different matters.

Buddhism clarifies that “faith” is another name for a doubt-free condition. This does not mean, however, that Buddhism prohibits one from thinking and pondering. “Why is Buddhism great?” “What is the life-philosophy of Buddhism?” It is natural that those who practice this Buddhism should seriously ponder and seek answers to such questions.

Mugi Wasshin, or doubt-free faith, means the immovable faith which is attained finally as a result of breaking through many doubts. It also means that only a great religion can stand upon such an ultimate degree of faith, free from doubt and bewilderment.

Faith in Buddhism does not negate reason, because the principles of its philosophy are permeated with scientific positivism and profound logic. Buddhism is compatible with reason. It is far removed from other religions which have had repeated, intense confrontations with reason and scientific laws.

Buddhism is not a coercive or authoritarian religion. People may understand it from the bottom of their hearts and believe in it not because of outside pressures, but because of an innermost motivation. True faith must be able to cope with intellectual criticism and pondering. A faith which avoids intellectual criticism and motivates people with mysticism and bureaucracy is only a blind faith.

Blind faith collapses easily when a person encounters difficulty, even though such a faith looks pure and ideal in the beginning. Even in Hinayana Buddhism, the sixth type of practice for a Bodhisattva was the practice of wisdom. Intellectual judgment and pondering are thus a very important prerequisite to the study of Buddhism. Nichiren Daishonin wrote: Exert yourself in the two ways of practice and study. Without these two, there can be no Buddhism. In another Gosho, he also said: I would never follow any other teaching unless my own principles were shattered by a wiser philosopher. His confidence seems to indicate Buddhism can defy any intellectual criticism.

He often praised the nobility of those seeking persons who earnestly asked profound questions about Buddhism. This is also actual proof of the importance Buddhism places on reasoning. Not criticism for the sake of criticism nor doubt for the sake of doubt, but thought and contemplation to establish and deepen faith are requisite conditions for the practice of Buddhism.