Heart Transplant
Q&A with President Ikeda
NSA Quarterly, Winter 1974 (Vol. 2, No. 1), p. 139. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
QUESTION: Dr. Christian Barnard, renowned in the field of heart-transplant, says that man’s failing organs should be replaced since they are only parts of the body. How should we regard the issue of organ-transplant from the standpoint of Buddhism?
ANSWER: It is a mistake to compare man’s body or any organism in general to a machine. Buddhism views the totality of life as an integral, single substance; therefore, the problem is not solved by replacing the organ of one person with that of another.
As is already recognized common sense in the medical world, the body is provided with its own life force and defenses which automatically cure disease. When that force is strong and functions normally, it can kill germs or heal a malfunctioning organ. What medical science should do is create the conditions which would give the body a chance to cure itself. I believe this to be the purpose of medicine.
It is clear when you look at the process by which an organism is formed that it is not at all like a machine. Originally, the parts of a machine are made separately and then put together, whereas the beginning of any Organism starts with just a single cell. Then cell division takes place and all the parts are formed according to the blueprint of the genes. Therefore, the organism is not a collection of parts but is self-formed.
All cells in all portions of the human body are unique to each individual. It is said that the human body consists of some 60 trillion cells. Each cell has genes unique to each person.
For this reason, any portion of the body should not be replaced by that of another person. The adverse reaction often caused by organ transplant is a normal characteristic of life. In other words, when anything foreign enters the body, it will be rejected.
The issue of organ transplant also involves the morality of using another person’s organ. Many questions have been raised regarding heart-transplant. Some of them are: “Might there have been a mistake in the announcement of death of one who offered his heart?” “Was it really necessary to perform a transplant operation?” These questions will always be asked as long as the organ transplant is performed.
The heart must be alive if it is intended to be used for transplant. Even if the pulsation has stopped, it still must be fresh so that it will function again when an outer stimulus is applied. However, looking into the past, there are many cases where those who have fallen into a state of pseudo death have returned to life. I do not believe it is right to surgically remove the heart from a body which still has the potential to live.
Those who perform transplant operations rationalize to themselves with, “One life instead of two deaths.” However, both patients might die anyway, when either one of them might have been able to live. At any rate, it is also a fact that a mood of experimentation rather than the pure intention of saving life underlies this type of medical treatment.
I do not oppose all organ-transplants. I want to suggest that it should be re-evaluated with a correct comprehension and recognition of life.
