Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Winter 1977

Is There a Freedom of the Press?

News Views

NSA Quarterly, Winter 1977, pp. 61–81. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

Since February Daniel Schorr has been the subject of controversy, for in that month the CBS newsman took upon himself the responsibility for the publication of the Pike Report, the House of Representatives investigation into CIA, FBI and other undercover operations.

Appearing in the Village Voice, the full text revealed nothing new, but the controversy that arose polarized members of the press, as well as Congress. The issue of First Amendment freedoms was obscured by Daniel Schorr’s own personality, his methods, and Congress’s gathering mood of secrecy. The revelation of the Pike Report leak came at a time when the Ford Administration was urging stricter reforms; one would lock up government secrets forever, making it a crime for any member of government, past or present, to provide or reveal secret documents, whether or not they had been appropriately designated.

Most accounts of Schorr’s involvement have it that Daniel Schorr came into possession of the Pike Report a few days before it was scheduled for release. He used material from it in several reports over the CBS Network. The New York Times also published stories based on the report. Separately, or together, the leaks caused such a furor that the House voted on January 29 not to release the report. However, as Jack Anderson later revealed, 2,293 copies of the report had already been circulated. Schorr found himself the only person outside of government in possession of a copy.

[Former CBS Correspondent Daniel Schorr appeared before the House Ethics Committee on September 15, 1976. Under oath, he refused to disclose the source of the confidential government intelligence report which he leaked to ‘The Village Voice’ — citing First Amendment rights and professional standards as the reasons.]

In deciding to release it, Daniel Schorr maintained that he made “an inescapable decision of journalistic conscience,” adding, “If a body of Congress can forbid publication of information that has already escaped its control, then what can it not forbid?”

But the New York Times, in an editorial entitled, “Selling Secrets,” raised serious doubts about Schorr’s true intent. Apparently, his first intention had been to have the Pike Report reproduced as a paperback, with introduction to be written by him. A precedent of sorts had already been set with the Pentagon Papers, published both by the Washington Post and the New York Times. Both editions, presumably, were making money for the respective newspapers.

Schorr approached the Reporters’ Committee for Freedom of the Press, an organization that provides financial and legal support for First Amendment court battles. The idea was that the Committee would receive the profits from publication of the report. It is generally agreed that the Committee’s lawyer, Peter Tufo, became the intermediary between Schorr and Clay Felker, the publisher of the Village Voice. However, the Committee later claimed it had not made any arrangement for financial contributions or payments and that negotiations with Schorr ended when the Pike Report could not find a paperback publisher.

Even Daniel Schorr seemed swept up by the proceedings. He is quoted as saying, “Once you start down a certain line, the steps by which one thing leads to another come very swiftly, and suddenly you’re totally wrapped up in it.... In the end you’re amazed at how far you’ve come from what you originally wanted to do.”

After publication of the report, Daniel Schorr actually denied that he had anything to do with it; in fact, he even hinted that someone else had stolen the story out from under him. Two days later, at the height of the uproar, he did admit that he had provided the report to the Village Voice. But he steadfastly refused to reveal his source, in accordance with the general concensus among newspeople of a constitutional right of protection for confidential news sources.

When the House voted 269-115 to investigate the matter, setting up a $150,000 investigative arm of the House Ethics Committee, it became apparent that Schorr was staring down a possible Contempt of Congress citation.

• • •

From the beginning, the First Amendment aroused controversy. Because seven states came to the federal government with free speech and press provisions, many framers of the Constitution, among them Alexander Hamilton, felt there would be no need for federal guidelines on the subject. But previous experience with Britain’s licensing act, in effect in the American colonies as long as 24 years after it had lapsed in England, made specific federal delineation a groundswell issue. And because six states had no constitution nor bill of rights, the first amendment dealing with freedom of speech and press was ordered.

[James Madison]

James Madison, who authored the first amendment, did not exactly follow the directives of the Constitutional Convention. He worded his restraint to refer only to the Congress of the United States. Since the conflict of the day rested between state and federal powers, his concern was in giving the true enforcement of these basic freedoms back to the states.

Only ten years later, the tenets of the First Amendment were challenged by the Sedition Act passed by the Federalist Party, which provided that false, scandalous and malicious statements against the government of the United States constituted a crime.

The Sedition Act was seen as a move to restrain the out-of-power Republican party from aligning the United States in the impending French and British conflict. Hamilton, a Federalist, had always viewed the First Amendment in a narrow manner. He subscribed to the views of Sir William Blackstone, who saw it as providing freedom from previous restraint, but not from prosecution after the fact of publication.

Two states, Virginia and Kentucky, passed resolutions against the Sedition Act, since they considered it an abridgement of states’ rights. But the Sedition Act was allowed to die a natural death, and became the precedent for attacks on First Amendment protections throughout the next 200 years.

• • •

Through the years, this amendment has provided the arena for healthy debates detailing the expanding concepts of freedom of information. As the use of film and broadcasting created the need for new interpretations, the Supreme Court continued to uphold its general tenets.

Gradually, members of the press have been pressing for a so-called newsman’s privilege, allowing newspeople, under certain circumstances, to save their sources from the overriding power of subpoena, charging that to reveal sources will dry them up, thus abridging the public’s right to know. The most detailed example has been the case of Earl Caldwell, a New York Times correspondent who became a confidant of the Black Panthers in 1968-69.

When the Oakland Grand Jury began investigations into written and other alleged advocations of violence against the United States, Earl Caldwell was subpoenaed to tell what he knew of Black Panther activities. He refused the subpoena, declaring that if he testified, he would sever his delicate liaison with the Panthers, thus preventing the public from learning more about the group.

He was upheld by the decisions of two lower courts who agreed with the prevailing theory, described in the New York Times brief defending Caldwell, that three criteria must be met in order to subpoena a newsperson or his materials. As compiled by Alexander Bickel of the Yale Law School, they are:

1. The government must clearly show that there is probable cause to believe that the reporter possesses information which is specifically relevant to a specific violation of law.

2. The government must show that the information it seeks cannot be obtained by alternative means, which is to say, from sources other than the reporter.

3. The government must clearly demonstrate a compelling and overriding interest in the information.

The criteria were supported by guidelines addressed to the Justice Department by then Attorney General John Mitchell in 1970. The introduction reads in part, “... In determining whether to request issuance of a subpoena to the press, the approach in every case must be to weigh that limiting effect against the public interest to be served in the fair administration of justice.”

• • •

Support for a newsman’s privilege can also be found in the interpretation of the First Amendment in numerous court cases equating the privilege sought to the right of the public to receive information. The New York Times brief states most eloquently, “The First Amendment weds the public interest in the flow of news to the reporter’s professional interest, and it is this public interest, not the reporter’s, that overrides what might in private relationships seem like the dictates of fairness and equity. The professional interest is, in an apposite phrase of Madison ‘a centinel over the public rights.’ ”

Finally, the mood created by the prevailing seventeen states’ “shield” statutes generated a feeling that creation of a true newsman’s privilege resulting from modern interpretations of the constitutional amendment was at hand. But the Judicial Department, contesting the lower court decisions, brought the case to the Supreme Court. On June 29, 1972, the High Court ruled by a five to four vote that reporters have no constitutional privileges to refuse to testify. The function of grand juries, as well as the age old states’ rights issue, were deciding factors in the majority opinion. The majority also stated, “... the task of judges, like other officials outside the legislative branch, is not to make the law, but to uphold it in accordance with their oaths.”

And the ball was thrown back to Congress. Although it was a devastating decision for those advocating newsman’s privilege, the flurry of proposed legislation that came into being raised hopes anew. Unfortunately, the controversy surrounding issues of national security, extent of immunity and other variables prevented even one of the proposed measures from leaving committee.

In the year following the Supreme Court decision, about twenty subpoenas were served on reporters. In many cases, grand juries sought to learn the identity of persons giving government information to them. The issue became even more delicate, since reporters made themselves arbiters of the decision between governmental security and the public’s right to know.

In such a charged atmosphere of pros and cons, Daniel Schorr responded to the House Ethics Committee’s subpoena in September. In spite of the dubious origins of the Pike Report’s publication, Schorr received a belated vote of solidarity. One petition in his favor was signed by 5,510 Newspaper Guild members, and another by thirty-six congressmen.

When asked to reveal his source, Schorr replied, “I consider it a matter of professional conscience as well as constitutional right not to assist you in discovering the source.” Finishing his statement with an historical ring, he said, “To betray a confidential source would mean to dry up many future sources for many future reporters. The ultimate losers would be the American people and their free institutions. But beyond all that, to betray a source would be to betray myself, my career, and my life. To say that I refuse to do it is not quite saying it right. I cannot do it.”

The investigating committee decided not to cite Schorr for Contempt of Congress, and the incident was considered a triumph of First Amendment freedoms. However, a broad based statement of a newsman’s privilege remains to be delineated.

As the Georgetown Law Journal’s 1973 examination best put it, “Presently, the only alternative available to a newsman once a court has directed him to testify is to refuse and be held in contempt. This has often been the case, and for the most part, newsmen have borne the burden silently.... However, one may seriously question whether a society should entrust the protection of a strong constitutional interest on the fact that individuals are willing to go to jail to preserve that interest.”