Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Winter 1977

Changing Destiny: The Principle of Shukumei Tenkan

Buddhist Philosophy

NSA Quarterly, Winter 1977, pp. 102–112. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

“There’s more to life than meets the eye.” This age-old platitude becomes a statement of broad and profound implications when viewed in the light of true Buddhism. Even when compared to modern-day psychology, Buddhism explores even deeper regions of human consciousness and ultimately reveals the process by which each person can change his destiny.

Destiny: East vs. West

Shukumei Tenkan, or the concept of changing destiny, is perhaps one of the deepest principles at the heart of true Buddhism. To understand this principle and the radical departure it takes from traditional western thinking, perhaps it would be wisest to examine two ancient allegories — the stories of Oedipus and King Ajase. These two tales impart a sense of how many centuries various concepts have been ingrained in our culture depicting a very clear difference between eastern and western ideas of fate or destiny.

The story of Oedipus is a classic in western literature. Dramatized almost 2,500 years ago by Sophocles, it tells the story of a tragic figure caught up in his own fate. Oedipus is the son of King Laius of Thebes and his wife, Jocasta. King Laius, fearful because he believes the prediction of a prophet that he will die at the hand of his son, abandons the infant Oedipus in a forest; the baby is rescued and raised by King Polybus of Corinth.

As a young man, Oedipus pays a visit to the Oracle at Delphi who tells him he is destined to kill his father and marry his mother.

[The story of Oedipus, shown here being performed by the traditional Greek chorus, is one of the oldest in Western literature and is in marked contrast — in terms of explaining motivation and destiny — to Eastern classics of the same time period.]

Distraught by this prophecy, Oedipus vows never to return to Corinth and his supposed family and begins to travel. In the course of his wanderings he has a quarrel with a stranger and kills him. Eventually, Oedipus ends up in Thebes where he rids the city of the Sphinx and wins the throne, together with the hand of a widowed Queen, Jocasta.

Years go by and a plague strikes the city. Having been told that it is caused by the fact that the murderer of the old King Laius is still at large, Oedipus sends for a blind seer named Teiresias to root out the murderer. At this point, one revelation after another unfolds as Oedipus discovers that the stranger he killed years ago was in fact Laius, his true father, and that he has indeed married his mother.

Distraught by these shocking discoveries, Jocasta kills herself, while Oedipus himself gouges out his own eyes and goes into exile. This tragic story of patricide, maternal incest and ultimate suffering is a classic example of the Greek tradition of man’s subordination to his destiny and, in modern times, has come to underlie a basic Freudian theme of repressed love, hostility and guilt known as the Oedipus complex.

The story of King Ajase (Skt. Ajatasatru), a classic of Buddhist literature, was also written about three thousand years ago (it is difficult to ascertain the exact date) and appears in the Nehan Sutra. It tells the tale of a king named Bimbashara (Skt. Bimbisara) who desperately wants a son to succeed him. He visits a prophet and is told that there is a hermit wizard in the mountains who, in his next incarnation, will be born again as Bimbashara’s son. Impatient for an heir, King Bimbashara sees to it that the hermit is killed by depriving him of his food supply. At the moment of the hermit’s death, Bimbashara’s wife becomes pregnant. Then the prophet tells Bimbashara that his new son will bear a grudge against him because of the murder of the hermit. The prophet goes on to say that because of this grudge, Bimbashara’s son will eventually harm him.

Bimbashara names his son Mi Sho’on, meaning “grudge not yet born.” Terrified by the predictions of the prophet, he tries to kill the baby by dropping him from a tree. However, the child only breaks a finger. Despite this incident, Mi Sho’on, although unwanted, grows up to become strong and healthy. The grudge against his father, very strong as an infant, gradually submerges with the experiences of maturation; yet, it still exists beneath the surface. One day Mi Sho’on meets Daibadatta, the arch-enemy of Sakyamuni. Because Daibadatta wants to gain power and influence with Mi Sho’on, now known as Ajase, he tells the youth about his entire background — the predictions of the prophet and the actions of his parents. With this news, the negative impulses in Ajase are stimulated. In a fit of indignation and rage, he has his father thrown in prison. Once in prison, Ajase refuses to let his mother bring food to Bimbashara — an ironic repetition of the circumstances in which Bimbashara once starved the old hermit.

Finally, Bimbashara dies, and Ajase eventually feels great regret. In his subconscious there is a conflict between his conscience and the reality of what he has done. This deep struggle in his psyche becomes more and more severe until it wracks Ajase with emotional anguish and even affects his body with the contraction of leprosy. Ajase goes to a doctor named Giba for a cure, but Giba can do nothing. It appears that it is his destiny to die. Giba suggests however, that Ajase go to see the Buddha, Sakyamuni. At the same time, his father’s voice seems to come to Ajase saying, “Go to see Sakyamuni, go to see Sakyamuni.”

At this point in the story of King Ajase, the differences between his tale and that of Oedipus begin to crystallize. Ajase’s actions are born out of grudges that exist at birth — an indication of the belief in rebirth and continuing karma — and differ considerably from the actions of Oedipus which seemingly have their basis in some kind of uncontrollable destiny — a fate to which no real cause is ascribed. In addition, the voice of his father urging him to go see Sakyamuni, as well as the reactivated grudge stimulated by Daibadatta, are both internal calls to action — subconscious motivations that ultimately become action. Oedipus, on the other hand, seems to act out scenes in a play already written by the mysterious — and detached — hand of fate.

When Ajase hears the voice of his father, his underlying motivations become conscious. He is awakened to go see Sakyamuni. The story continues with the Buddha taking Ajase somewhere to meditate with him. Together with Sakyamuni in the moonlight, Ajase finds that his mind, for the first time, becomes peaceful and clear while his leprosy is cured. The moonlight is a metaphor for the light of the Buddha’s wisdom which illuminates the dark recesses of Ajase’s life.

The Fate Within

[Even the smallest child, no matter how innocent his appearance or unwitting his behavior, contains karma or destiny of his own creation from previous lifetimes.]

Here are two stories of patricide — one of the most heinous of crimes — which have very different conclusions. At the crux of the contrast lie the differing attitudes toward destiny expressed by the tales of Oedipus and Ajase. The principle which allows Ajase to change his behavior and somehow come to a happy end is Shukumei Tenkan — a concept unique to Eastern literature and a cornerstone of the philosophy of Buddhism. Perhaps now, by occasionally referring back to our two parables, we can delve into the process of Shukumei Tenkan a little more deeply.

Buddhism teaches that within every human being is a life of Buddha, or enlightenment. The tendency however is for this enlightened state to be masked by earthly or blind desires, known as Don’ai, and to be thrown into the shadows of the darkness of ignorance, known as Mumyo. Don’ai and Mumyo comprise the negative impulses known as Bon’no. The positive, dynamic energy of our Buddha’s life, when submerged by the twin forces of Don’ai and Mumyo, tends to wane, leaving us with very little life-force and extremely susceptible to external influence — such as that exerted on Ajase by Daibadatta. Ultimately, this condition affects both conduct and appearance.

Buddhism teaches the eternity of life, and the idea of rebirth is implicit in this teaching. Buddhism also makes very clear the fact that our destiny, or fate, is a matter of our own creation — the effect of causes we ourselves make that are also known as karma. Taking the concepts of rebirth and karma together, we naturally come to the conclusion that even a newborn baby brings into this life effects or karma of previous existences. In this sense, the apparent innocence and purity of an infant may be only a superficial aspect of its life — at deeper levels there exist sources of pain, anguish, or even hostility that continue from a previous life, e.g. the grudge held by Ajase.

Other philosophies might call this original sin and hold that it is a cause for lifelong guilt. Buddhism, on the other hand, states that karma is a natural outcome of the eternity of life and can always be changed. Indeed, as the baby grows up, immediate situations and experiences tend to submerge any pre-natal grudges at even deeper levels. Nevertheless, at some point, an external stimulus resonates with the forces of Bon’no still harbored within the human life. At any time during the life-cycle, the negative influences carried at birth may be called into play, as they were when Ajase met Daibadatta.

In his Ongi Kuden, Nichiren Daishonin said that King Ajase was symbolic of people in Mappo — in other words, us. Just as Ajase for most of his life was subject to the torments of his inner grudge due to Bon’no, people in Mappo are like the children of Mumyo (the father) and Don’ai (the mother). In other words, all of us are at the mercy of the fundamental darkness and blind desires that are so deeply rooted in our lives due to our karma. Ajase’s murder of his father was an act motivated by his underlying ignorance and greed; we too are susceptible to making such grave errors.

This may seem rather irrelevant, because it is hard to think in terms of many of us wanting to kill our fathers, however it really means that any human being is potentially capable of evil. This potential may be dormant most of our lives. Depending on our karma, however, it can be activated by some stimulus at any time. “Unthinkable!” we might shout and yet how many of us at times have honestly felt almost uncontrollably violent impulses? How many of us have met people for whom we have a bad feeling for seemingly no reason? These experiences are evidence in themselves that there is much going on deep inside of which we have little awareness.

Much of this topic deals with motivation and inner awareness, and here the paths of the Buddhist philosophy and modern-day psychology begin to converge. Buddhism holds that motivation can be explained by experience and is elicited by stimulus. Lest this resemble behaviorism, we should remember that experience has much broader connotations in Buddhism. It includes karma and Bon’no in addition to our day-to-day existence.

The tale of Oedipus ends tragically, with no real attempt to explain his motivation. Ajase meets a different end as he wins over his fate after meeting with the Buddha. The story of King Ajase offers a prime example of the theories known as Bon’no soku Bodai (Desires lead to Buddhahood) and Mumyo soku Hossho (Darkness leads to enlightenment). This does not mean that a person’s enlightenment directly stems from darkness or desire within his life. In dealing with these deep-seated negative natures, a Buddhist seeks the noblest, and really the strongest positive forces that lie at the core of our existence. Nichiren Daishonin said that he and his believers are all like King Ajase, holding the sword of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, while slaying the forces of darkness and ignorance in order to find their enlightenment.

Thus far the reader may have had the impression that the negative forces in life are so deep-seated that they have no antidote. In a sense this is true, but the main point of the discussion so far was to underscore just how profound the effects of Bon’no are. Now we see that the principles of Bon’no soku Bodai and Mumyo soku Hosshin are rationale for the existence of the darkness and desire within our lives and provide the active process for changing our destiny.

Graphic illustrations will aid in continuing this explanation. There is a distinct correlation between true Buddhist theory and modern-day Jungian psychology. We make this comparison for two reasons: one is that the terms we draw upon will have more relevance for today’s readers; the other is that the overlap between Buddhism and the modern science of the mind becomes all the more impressive when one realizes that the former is several thousand years older.

Sense and Consciousness

The key to understanding or controlling our destiny lies in comprehending the different levels of human consciousness. In the story of Oedipus, as mentioned before, no attempt was made to ascribe anything that happened to motivation forming out of consciousness. Things were simple: what happened, happened; what was perceived was acted upon; and what was predicted came true — as if by magic, or the will of the gods. Ajase however, was driven by a number of things — totally obscure memory-traces from a previous life, subconscious feelings of hostility toward his father and, ultimately, overriding sensations of guilt that drove him toward Sakyamuni together with other subconscious cues (i.e. the inner voice of his father).

Buddhism explains human consciousness in terms of the eight senses (See Figure A) and the nine senses. Karl Jung talks about human awareness in terms of four levels of consciousness (See Figure B). Strangely, Sigmund Freud used the story of Oedipus as a classic example of subconscious influences. However, the interpretation of motivation was pretty much his own, with Sophocles only providing a convenient story line. Nevertheless, the framework of consciousness expounded by Karl Jung comes closer to matching the Buddhist concept of the eight senses (araya-shiki). The correlation is as follows:

Buddhist Sense — Jungian Consciousness
1. Sight, 2. Hearing, 3. Smell, 4. Taste, 5. Touch — 1. Ego/Interaction
6. Consciousness — 2. Ego/Awareness
7. Subconscious — 3. Personal Unconscious
8. Karma storage — 4. Collective Unconscious

The actions and behaviors that make up our daily life and are played out through the first five senses find their motivation in the sixth and seventh sensory levels. The sixth level is comprised of the awareness, perception and memory which we tend to conceive of as our conscious identity, i.e., Jung’s ego. This, in turn, is influenced by the input from our seventh sense, which is subconscious; we lose awareness of our lives and motivations at this point.

It is at the sixth and seventh senses that our lives experience the heavy influence of Bon’no. This influence first pollutes our seventh sensory level and then is carried up to the sixth with little or no awareness on our part that anything is amiss. In reality, however, by the time we start acting on our motivations, we have already been greatly swayed by these forces.

These forces of Bon’no originate in the eighth sense, similar to what Jung terms the collective unconscious. Jung defines the collective unconscious as ... “the storehouse of latent memory traces inherited from man’s ancestral past, a past that includes not only the racial history of man as a separate species, but his prehuman or animal ancestry as well. The collective unconscious is the psychic residue of man’s evolutionary development, a residue that accumulates as a consequence of repeated experiences over many generations. It is almost entirely detached from anything personal in the life of the individual and is seemingly universal. All human beings have more or less the same collective unconscious.”

Our Eternal Storehouse

There is a distinction though, between the collective unconscious and the eighth sense. Although the ideas are similar, it is important to realize that they are not identical. Jung’s theory is used because it is the only school of psychology that matches the depths, but not necessarily the contents, of Buddhist philosophy. For Jung, the broad universality of the collective unconscious comes from the biological similarity in the structure of the brain in all races of men which, in turn, stems from a common evolution.

Buddhism states that the infinite and universal aspects of the eighth sense stem from the eternity of life and the fact that the eighth sense serves as a storehouse for the first seven senses; the eighth sense is also capable of playing back effects through all of the senses at any time.

The eighth sense is the common ground with the seeds for all life activities. These seeds are planted through the input of the first seven senses (note the arrows in the illustration) and are nurtured through the sixth level, finally blossoming into the actions of life expressed by the first five senses.

All of this is meant to convey how vast the eighth sense is. Jung’s collective unconscious seems to have certain species or evolutional boundaries, while the eighth sense is as infinite as life itself. That is to say that every experience we have — no matter how big or how small, no matter how significant or how meaningless, whether it be getting married or blowing our nose — is registered in the eighth sense and is available at some time to have an effect on our life. This refers not only to the experiences of this life, within recent memory, but goes back to infancy and even before, to previous lifetimes. Ajase’s eighth sense registered the murder of the hermit (his previous incarnation) by his father, although he — both consciously and subconsciously — had no realization of it. The eighth sense is the way we have registered why we wear glasses, have some inexplicable disease, have no money, have lots of success with the opposite sex or any one of the other innumerable effects we have in our lives for which we seemingly have no explanation. Nichiren Daishonin stresses the fact that the eighth sense is a storehouse for all three existences of life — past, present and future. Nothing is forgotten, erased or missed. Everything in our existence is eternally inscribed at the deepest levels of our lives.

The eighth sense is like our karma, or more accurately, like the repository of our karma. Many times Nichiren Shoshu believers refer to the turmoil in their lives as “karma attacks.” Looking at the Figure A it is easy to imagine that an earthquake at the eighth sense (an upsurge of effects are being released from storage) can really shake up the first seven senses, wreaking havoc with our subconscious, our motivations and the way we perceive and interact with things.

In the case of King Ajase, the fact that his motivation in imprisoning his father stemmed from darkness and desire at the eighth sense is congruent with the effects on his body by the same negative forces; specifically, his contraction of leprosy. Many doctors agree that some of the most difficult diseases are those defects that accompany birth. The Buddhist explanation for such karma at birth, known as Gobyo, is that it is caused by the immediate appearance of the Bon’no and Mumyo stored in the eighth sense and carried over from the previous life. It is strange, and highly relevant, that some diseases are easy to treat while some remain impossible. Moreover, two people with identical symptoms may react in totally different ways to treatment. This too is because of karma and the content of the eighth sense.

Up until now we have been speaking of the purpose and contents of the eighth sense as though they are generally negative. This is not entirely true, and such examples have been used only to draw clear examples of the eighth sense and the origins of destiny. All human beings are born with seeds of Bon’no at the eighth level, and some people are heavily influenced by them. However, positive forces as a result of past action reside in the eighth sense as well. What creates a genius at birth or a child with an aptitude for music? These seeds, eventually blossoming beautifully at the conscious levels, must also be harvested from the soil of the eighth sense.

Illumination at the Deepest Level

Having taken a look at the Buddhist view of consciousness from the standpoint of the eight senses, we arrive at a point where it seems we should go further. After all, if the eighth sense is capable of only feeding back effects transmitted through the first seven senses, it would seem that the causes being made would continue to stem from a balance of positive forces together with the forces of Bon’no at the eighth level. This would lead to a cycle of both good and bad events in the life of the human being which, although varying in content, would seem very close to the sort of inescapable and unchangeable destiny that confronted Oedipus.

The concept of the ninth sense demonstrates the profundity of Buddhism. This teaching goes beyond any philosophy or any school of psychology. In uncovering the ninth sense, Buddhism gives us the key to Shukumei Tenkan — the change of destiny. The ninth sense is referred to as Kuchiki Shin’no or Kompon Joshiki. Kompon means fundamental, jo means pure and shiki means “sense.”

The fundamental pure sense is the original purifying force that constitutes the essence of our lives. That fountain of mercy and wisdom was what Ajase sensed welling up within himself when he met with Sakyamuni. He glimpsed this power by coming temporarily into contact with the deepest level of his senses. In meeting Sakyamuni, Ajase was able to penetrate the cloud of Bon’no on the eighth level. This might seem to be contradictory to what we said previously — that nothing is ever erased at the eighth level. This is true, but Bon’no comprises the fundamental darkness inherent in one’s life; this darkness in Ajase was totally illuminated by the light of the ninth sense — the light of the Buddha which we know as Nam-myoho-renge-kyo.

The light of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo is not an external illumination; it was not a pure shining beam that emanated from Sakyamuni onto Ajase. It was the pure inner wisdom of Buddhahood that existed within Ajase and exists within each of us. It is the essence of life, the law of the universe that dwells within each human being. In doing battle with his Bon’no, Ajase discovered, with Sakyamuni’s help, the life of Buddha within himself. This light dispelled the darkness in his psyche and allowed him to change his karma.

This is exactly what happens when we apply Nam-myoho-renge-kyo to our own lives. The brilliance of this light, combined with the wisdom and mercy of the Gohonzon, illuminates the terrible aspect of our karma and allows for a transformation of destiny. The practice of true Buddhism becomes the source for Shukumei Tenkan. No matter how deeply karma may be rooted in the eighth level, it can be exposed and changed through Nam-myoho-renge-kyo. The ninth sense forms the ultimate point of origin for all other senses.

By clarifying the eight senses, Buddhism explains destiny and the accumulation of karma through cause and effect — operating sometimes on conscious levels, but often on levels of motivation and the subconscious which we can barely, if ever, perceive. However, Buddhism also expounds the theory of the ninth sense and the process through which we can create a fresh, new life utilizing the dormant power of Buddha within our life.

Nichiren Daishonin actually established a practical method for tapping the life of Buddha that underlies everything. In doing this, he provided the key to changing destiny and thus went several steps beyond other schools of philosophy or psychology. His accomplishment is remarkable. We not only can come to understand ourselves, to cope with our nature — we can change ourselves and reach the highest imaginable level of existence. The difference between Buddhist practice and a theoretical philosophy is like the difference between knowing mining and actually striking it rich. No longer need we worry about the problems of our ego as it plays out motivations and agonizes over turmoil taking place at the sixth, seventh and eighth levels. We can realize the ego of the Buddha, founded on the ninth sense.

As President Ikeda said in his 1974 address at U.C.L.A., “This highest ego is the fundamental principle of the universe. It is also the same law which controls the expression of the self within each individual . . . Pursuing this true ego does not imply giving up a lesser or more superficial one. The fact is that the highest ego gives new direction to the lesser one . . . This ego (manifest from the first eight senses) is only meaningful when based on the loftier one . . . I feel very strongly that civilization will be able to make meaningful progress only if we understand this point.”

[The joy and confidence that stems from knowing one is in control of his life — he has mastered the process of changing his destiny — is evident on these faces.]