What’s With the Weather?
News Views
NSA Quarterly, Spring 1977, pp. 87–94. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
[In recent months, the United States has experienced extremes in weather: bitter cold in the Midwest and East that has endangered lives and literally shut down severely hit cities, and a destructive drought in the Western states that has forced areas to ration water supplies and caused major crop losses. These radical weather conditions affect everyone. In this interview, Joseph Vederman, an enthusiastic and knowledgeable meteorologist in charge of the National Weather Service in the Los Angeles area, explains many of these natural and man-made weather changes.]
QUARTERLY: Is the extreme weather in the East and West a natural phenomenon or is it a result of ecological imbalance?
VEDERMAN: So far as we know, it’s a natural thing. Weather fluctuates from year to year. No two years are alike; no two years are highly correlated. Just because it’s cold this winter doesn’t mean it’s going to be cold next winter, or that the summer will be much different from normal.
QUARTERLY: The severe cold in the East caught many people by surprise. If this was a natural phenomenon, was there any warning system or any way to predict this extreme weather?
VEDERMAN: We put out warnings all the time. Our warnings did give people notice of heavy snow and extreme cold, not only in the East but in the West. Our weather forecasts cover the entire United States. They also cover some of the oceans too. As a matter of fact, we make global forecasts not only in the Northern Hemisphere but in the Southern Hemisphere as well. The usual forecast that you hear on radio or television is for a couple of days — sometimes four or five days — in advance. Those forecasts are pretty good, and people have enough warning to protect themselves — to take emergency action if they have to. However, if you’re talking about forecasts for years or even centuries in advance, there is no way that we now know of that will permit us to make reliable forecasts that far in advance.
QUARTERLY: What are the causes of drought now in the western United States?
VEDERMAN: Air in the upper atmosphere, ten to twenty thousand feet above ground usually moves across the United States from west to east. It comes in from the Pacific across the continent, and flows out over the Atlantic. That’s what normally happens. When that normal picture exists, we have some good weather, some bad weather, dry periods, wet periods, and so on. A few days of one type of weather, a few days of another. Winter is characteristically changeable. That’s what happens under usual conditions.
But this year hasn’t been usual. The air now over the Western United States has been moving way up to the north of us. In the North, it picked up cold air from Canada, the Arctic, and flung it way down to the South. The result is all the snow and bitter cold weather. To put it another way, all the storms which at this time of the year come into the Western United States (California, Southern California) have been moving far to the north up into Alaska, western Canada, and they have been getting our rain. Very little has been falling in Washington, Oregon, Northern California, or, for that matter, Southern California.
QUARTERLY: Is there any way of foretelling how long these drought conditions will last?
VEDERMAN: A few days in advance is the best we can foretell. Our forecasts did predict last week (week of February 7) that there would be a break from the bitter cold to the milder weather. And indeed, it’s been quite mild, remarkably mild all in through Chicago. Even the East Coast has beautiful weather. But that’s right now. Before the week is up, guess what? We’re going to start all over again with another tremendous blast of cold air down into the Central and Eastern United States. * This is characteristic of winter weather. As far as we know, this is a natural cycle in the atmosphere.
QUARTERLY: Recently, the weather throughout the world has been ideal, and crops have been exceptional. Is it fair to expect this ideal weather will continue? Is the milder weather a trend?
VEDERMAN: We have no reason to believe there is a trend. You cannot extrapolate from what’s going on today or last week or last month, those events far into the future. The weather from year to year changes markedly. Some cold winters are followed by warm winters the following years, and vice versa. Sometimes, you get two or three cold winters in a row, and people say, “Oh boy, two or three cold winters in a row. The world is coming to an end!”
[*Ed. Note: This indeed did occur the following week.]
But the records show that cold winters are sometimes followed by a whole series of warm ones (or sometimes warm and cold) — all sorts of combinations.
Put another way, if you look at the weather picture from year to year, the variations seem to be randomly distributed; there is no general pattern. You can’t just look and say it’s been warm for two or three years, and therefore something is going to happen. So far as we know, there is nothing unnatural about the present state of the atmosphere.
QUARTERLY: Is there a pattern or cycle to the weather over the last one hundred years or so?
VEDERMAN: We have a graph chart here in the office showing the rainfall in Los Angeles for the past one hundred years. What does it show? It’s up and down, up and down. People say, “oh, it’s getting wet,” but you just wait a little bit, and it will be dry. If we have two to three dry years, people say, “oh boy, it will never rain again.” But you see, it’s just not so. You say, “Isn’t there a cycle?” No, it fluctuates wildly.
QUARTERLY: Can you predict weather on a long-range basis?
VEDERMAN: The usual weather prediction is about two days in advance. Some of our predictions, less general, are five days in advance. That’s really about aS far as we can go. However, we are experimenting with forecasts about a month in advance. They’re not very specific. They’re not wonderfully good, but they appear to show some skill. If you’re talking about seasons in advance, nobody has demonstrated skill, though some people claim to. If you’re talking about a year in advance, or ten years, there’s just no scientific basis.
QUARTERLY: How do you predict weather? What exactly is involved?
VEDERMAN: To predict the weather, first you have to know what’s going on in the atmosphere right now. For instance, if you’re going to predict what time you’re going to get home tonight, you have to know where you are now, because if you’re at one end of the city, it will take so long, but if you’re in New York, it will take much longer.
We are in the same position. In order to predict what’s going to happen in the future, we have to know what’s going on now. In that connection, we collect observations of the weather from all over the world. That means, not only from the United States and North America, but also from Africa, Asia, Europe, Australia via ships at sea, aircraft and balloons that we send up. All these things are taking place all over this wide, wide world right now, and from that information, we know what’s going on right this minute,
For example, if you are leaving Los Angeles for Hong Kong, the pilot and crew know what the weather is right now in Hong Kong, and they also know what it’s going to be when they get there. There is a global interchange of meteorological information.
As a matter of fact, this is one of the great marvels of this age. In spite of the fact that there is lots of friction between various countries from time to time, and there are wars and all sorts of things going on, weather knows no political boundaries. There is an organization called the World Meteorological Organization which is an arm of the United Nations that coordinates the flow of weather information around the world. We get information from everybody; in turn, we give our weather information to everybody. If the cooperation on the political level were as great as it is on the meteorological level, peace and harmony would reign on this earth right now.
QUARTERLY: How do you predict weather for a specific area, say Los Angeles?
VEDERMAN: The weather in Los Angeles is not manufactured in Los Angeles. Storms move across the Pacific and across the United states, so we have to watch he track of storms. One of he things that enables us to
[Joe Vederman, Meteorologist in Charge, National Weather Service, Los Angeles office]
[“This is a most remarkable picture of a hurricane taken by a satellite,” explained Mr. Vederman. “You can see Baja, California at an angle just to the right of the swirling storm. Not only can you see the circulation of the clouds, if you look into the center, you see the vortex form. The bright white part there indicates clouds of tremendous height, strong winds and heavy rain. But in spite of all that, right in the very middle, nothing is going on. You can look straight down through the storm to the ocean. [The black is the ocean.] The wind is not even blowing there. If you can get out of that, heaven help you! That happens to be a tropical storm, but storms in our latitude have similar characteristics, and we watch them with our satellites as they move across the continent.”]
track storms much more carefully than in the past is satellites.
QUARTERLY: What kind of information do you receive from satellites, and how many are in use?
VEDERMAN: We have about five satellites in use now, rotating around the earth. Every half hour they feed us a picture, almost directly to this office. That enables us to know right now where every cloud in the atmosphere is in our part of the earth. We are not particularly interested in what’s going on in Europe, but the satellite, of course, gives us that information too.
Hurricanes and typhoons, which usually form over the ocean and move across the ocean, occasionally strike land. Before, hurricanes and typhoons would suddenly strike a place and no one would know where it came from. This’ doesn’t happen today. It’s impossible for it to happen today because our satellites watch such things constantly.
You may remember the big storm a year or two ago in Darwin, Australia which wiped out the whole city. Our satellites followed the storm, and we sent messages to the Australians notifying them that it was coming. You may also remember the incident in India years ago when thousands of people drowned in the Bay of Bengal. We sent them warnings of the storm, but the people had no place to go, so the majority of them drowned. Nevertheless, our satellites definitely picked it up and distributed warnings.
QUARTERLY: Are satellites your primary method used in predicting weather?
VEDERMAN: That’s one method. We have at our disposal an amazing array of tools. One of our biggest tools is the communication network, which is remarkable in itself. Computers are another tool, perhaps the most important.
As a matter of fact, you may know that when giant electronic computers were first thought of, the leader in that field was the great Hungarian mathematician, Johan Von Neumann. People asked him at that time, “When you develop this great tool, who on earth will be able to use it?” He answered that the first thing the high-speed computers would be used for might be a solution to weather problems. And indeed, that was one of the first things done. Some of the biggest computers in existence today are our weather computers.
QUARTERLY: How long have satellites been used for weather purposes?
VEDERMAN: Our first satellites were put into orbit about seventeen years ago.
QUARTERLY: In the sixties, nuclear bombs were set off in the atmosphere. Some people claim that these were the cause of atmospheric and weather change. Is this true?
VEDERMAN: Some people will claim anything about anything! You have to remember that these were not the first nuclear explosions. The first ones were 1945, and you might say that was the reason. You might say anything you want! However, if you make a statement, it would seem logical that you would be expected to give the supporting evidence.
Nobody has shown that there is any correlation between the weather and atomic explosions in the atmosphere or in the earth. You have to remember that we had a tremendous blizzard in 1888. They hadn’t heard of atomic energy then. Lots of things happened in strange, unexplainable ways centuries ago. So therefore, it would be difficult to say that the things we are seeing now are due to one thing or ) another.
Lots of things cause the weather to change. Why should you pick on the atom bomb? Why not pick on atmospheric pollution? Why not pick on changes in the ocean? Whatever you pick, you have the obligation to bring forth the supporting evidence. There is no evidence of that kind.
QUARTERLY: Would you say that maybe with the passing of enough time and enough atomic bomb explosions or tests, it might some day be proven there is a direct correlation between the tests and a weather change?
VEDERMAN: It could be, but the point is that lots of things could be. We would have to find out how many atomic bombs you need to change the circulation of the atmosphere, make it cold here and warm there, rain here and not there. The energy in the atmosphere is so tremendous, so much greater than the energy of an atomic bomb (which is plenty great), that a dozen atomic bombs would hardly compare with any of our smaller storms.
QUARTERLY: Is there any truth behind the predictions of another Ice Age?
VEDERMAN: We can be sure that there is going to be another Ice Age. However, you forgot to say when! That’s the key point. We’ve had Ice Ages over the course of millions and millions of years as far as fragmentary records show. There’s no Way we can predict whether next year or the following year will be the beginning of the Ice Age.
A lot of studies and a lot of research are going on in that direction. From the information we have, we know that the earth as a whole passes through periods of warm weather and cold weather, but this doesn’t occur with a frequency or intensity we can predict. We know that they do happen, and judging from the records going back thousands and thousands of years, it is reasonable to expect that we are going to have another Ice Age. It is also reasonable to expect, and I think that this is most important, that we are not going to have it in my lifetime or yours; that is, the probability is extremely low.
QUARTERLY: Would you say that the weather change in larger cities is caused by air pollution? What do you see as the cause for this weather change?
VEDERMAN: Air pollution, that type of man-made local weather change, does not appear to be associated with large global changes in weather, such as the tremendous cold in the Eastern United States or the tremendous dryness in the West. And it seems, at present, that the global changes are not much affected by the local, city changes. They might be in the future. They might be changes for the better; they might be changes for the worse. We don’t know enough to say.
QUARTERLY: Do densely populated areas have a direct effect on the weather?
VEDERMAN: Specifically, they warm the temperature and cause a little more rainfall in the area. The reason is that pollution, with large numbers of people and factories, etc., tends to put out a lot of heat in the first place. The air pollution itself acts like a cover over the city, and doesn’t let the heat escape at night as easily as it might otherwise.
With respect to the increases of rain which have been observed in large cities, this is due to what are called hydroscopic particles. Rain forms around little particles in the atmosphere like dust, salt particles, etc., and the more you have in the atmosphere, the more you increase your chances for rain. That doesn’t mean you get tremendous floods; you get a little more than you would normally in the surrounding area.
It is possible, under some conditions, to put silver iodide into clouds which are not raining and have them rain to the extent that there is some change in the weather. It wasn’t raining before, then we put something in it and it rains. In repeated experiments, we are pretty sure that under certain idealized conditions in certain parts of the world, we have been able to make it rain a little more than normally would have occurred. Isn’t that interesting?
QUARTERLY: Could you explain more about silver iodide?
VEDERMAN: Basically, silver iodide is used because of the nature of its crystals. Silver iodide crystals, under a microscope, look like snow crystals. The atmosphere is fooled by what it thinks are snow crystals, and all the moisture forms around them and it starts to rain.
QUARTERLY: Can silver iodide be used to help with severe drought problems?
VEDERMAN: Well, it can be used in any place except when a severe drought is going on. If there are no clouds, there’s nothing to put something into. Therefore, it won’t work. That’s the problem and, as you can see, it creates limitations.
QUARTERLY: What about aerosal cans and the ozone layer?
VEDERMAN: The best things that our atmospheric scientists have said is that there is a grave risk in aerosols changing the composition of the atmosphere at high levels where the ozone resides. The ozone is a very protective covering in the atmosphere about twenty-five miles up, and we don’t see or feel it directly, but if it weren’t there, we’d be in trouble. The best evidence suggests that we should not do anything upsetting to the ozone layer in the atmosphere.
QUARTERLY: Can some of
the rainfall over the ocean
be moved to land?
1|
VEDERMAN: In order to do r| that, we would have to control the atmosphere. We don’t yet know that much about it to control it at this time. There have been tremendous storms out in the Pacific. If all that rain had fallen here, we would be flooded.
QUARTERLY: Is there such a thing as controlling weather as a weapon of war?
VEDERMAN: Oh, I’m certainly glad you mentioned that. However, I regret that you have phrased the question that way. I would have much preferred to answer a related question, and that is, is it possible to use weather control as a weapon for peace?
Of course we hope that when we understand the atmosphere enough to control it to some degree, we will use it for the good of mankind. Just like electricity - a hundred or two hundred ° years ago, we didn’t know ; much about how or where to < use it, but it is now an J important tool contributing a to a better quality of living it for everybody, tl
I hope and I’m sure you hope that when we understand more about the weather, we won’t use it to go around killing each other. How disgraceful. We’ll use it for the good of ourselves and our fellow man to make the horrible conditions under which many people now live a little better. We hope that peace and harmony and love will dwell on this globe as a result of our efforts.
QUARTERLY: So you would be able to control weather?
VEDERMAN: We hope to control the weather for the good of everybody. We hope, but that’s different from doing it. We didn’t know much about smallpox one hundred years ago. Once you got smallpox, imagine you just died. But after a while, medicine learned how to control and stamp it out. Today, everybody benefits by that. We don’t use our medical knowledge about smallpox for military purposes; we use it for the good of mankind. That’s what science should be about. It’s not always that way, but certainly there is the hope.
QUARTERLY: Is there a lot of research taking place in the area of controlling weather?
VEDERMAN: Yes, but that’s not the first step. The first step is to understand it. If you understand it, you are in a better position to control it. You certainly can’t control things you don’t understand.
QUARTERLY: Thank you very much for your time and invaluable information. Hopefully, all our readers will now have a better understanding of the forces at play in our weather.
[“The satellites that took these pictures are 23,000 miles into the atmosphere. With an exceptional camera, you’d be lucky to see anything four or five miles away,” said the Los Angeles meteorologist. “In a jet aircraft five or six miles above the earth, your pictures show nothing. You would think from a distance of 23,000 miles, you would also see nothing. When you think of how far away that really is, it’s amazing. . . look at the remarkable things you can see [cloud formations, storms, wind currents, a perfect picture of land formations, including snow on the mountains. The satellites last for one to two years. They eventually burn out, and we send new ones up to replace them. They use solar cells for energy.”]
