The Great Departure
NSA Quarterly, Spring 1977, pp. 71–87. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
We come now to the question of the Great Departure, which was to change not only the life of Sakyamuni but the entire spirtual history of the world.
There are various theories as to how old Sakyamuni was when he determined to leave his home and family and enter upon the religious life. Some sources record that he was nineteen when he took this momentous step, others that he was twenty-nine. If we accept the former, this would mean that, having married around the age of sixteen and sired a son, he very soon made up his mind to renounce family life and go out into the world in search of enlightenment. As we shall describe in detail further on, he thereafter studied under two Brahman sages but, dissatisfied with their instruction, left to practice religious austerities on his own. After pursuing austerities until he had reduced himself to emaciation, he became aware that such practices would not lead to emancipation. Finally he seated himself at the foot of a pipal tree in the forest near Bodh Gaya, fell into deep meditation, and there achieved enlightenment. According to most accounts, he was thirty at the time. If we regard him as having renounced his family at the age of nineteen, it would mean that he spent a period of twelve years in his quest for the true Way. The earliest scriptures, however, SPRING 1977 represent Sakyamuni as having said in his own words that he entered upon the religious life at the age of twenty-nine and that he achieved enlightenment seven years later — that is, when he was thirty-five or thirty-six years of age.
We can only surmise which of these two assertions concerning the age at which Sakyamuni entered upon the religious life is correct, though most scholars seem to favor the latter. In helping to determine which is more likely, it would be well at this point to consider some of the motives that might have impelled Sakyamuni to take such a drastic step.
We have touched earlier upon the political situation in northern India at the time, and mentioned that the Sakya state was constantly threatened by more powerful neighbors, particularly the state of Magadha. If one of the considerations that led Sakyamuni to renounce the worldly life was his despair over the waning political fortunes of his own tribe, then it is more likely that he did so around the age of thirty.
I say this because, as mentioned earlier, Magadha was a relative newcomer to the struggle for political supremacy and only reached important status after King Bimbisara came to the throne. King Bimbisara, we are told, became ruler of Magadha at the age of fifteen, and we are also told that he was five years younger than Sakyamuni. Sakyamuni would already have been in his twenties, therefore, when he witnessed the rapid expansion in the power and fortunes of the state of Magadha and came to realize what a threat they posed to the survival of his own people.
In the end, however, we can only guess how old Sakyamuni may have been when he entered upon the religious life. More important, I believe, is to probe more deeply into the motives that impelled him to take such a step, since these are intimately related to the nature of the enlightenment that he achieved and indeed to the very essence of Buddhism as a religion.
Tradition offers the so-called Four Meetings as the reason for Sakyamuni’s departure for the religious life. According to early accounts, Sakyamuni was for the most part confined to the royal palace and was shielded by his father from exposure to any knowledge of worldly woes. On four occasions. however, he succeeded in going outside the palace gates in the company of his charioteer. Emerging from the eastern gate of the palace on what was intended to be a pleasure excursion, Sakyamuni was confronted by the sight of an old man; emerging from the south gate on another occasion, he saw a sick man, and when he left by the west gate, he saw a corpse. Finally, going out by the north gate, he spied a man who had entered the religious life passing by, and, deeply moved, he determined to leave home and take up the same kind of life himself.
Such an anecdote, with its neat symmetry, differs in nature, of course, from what we would call an objective historical account of events, yet it serves to sum up in symbolic form the process by which Sakyamuni was led to renounce the world. It js also important because it focuses attention upon what is the essential starting point of the Buddhist religion — the question of human suffering, Sakyamuni, a sensitive and Philosophical youth, undoubtedly pondered the essence of life and attempted, through his keen and probing intellect. to discover answers to the questions that filled his mind concerning it. And we can justly infer from his later teachings that he was particularly vexed by the problems of birth, ; old age, sickness, and death, sufferings that Were iney ‘itably bound up with the very existence of man. The force that impelled him to take up the religious life, and indeed became the point of departure for the transcend the sufferings that are inherent in human life.
What is man? What is life? These were the questions that Sakyamuni put to himself. And since man and human life are in the end only a part of the mysterious life force that moment by moment pulses through the world, he went on to inquire about the nature of the life force itself. It is because Buddhism addresses itself to such fundamental questions of life and existence that it has been able to continue to flourish over the centuries and to shine with as bright a light as at the time of its inception, Apart from his wish to find a solution to the problem of human suffering, it has been Suggested that Sakyamuni was also strongly influenced by his introspective temperament and by the inauspicious social and political situation faced by the people of the Sakya tribe in his decision to enter the religious life. But although there is no doubt that he agonized over the fate that seemed to lie in store for his people, this does not mean that the only course left open to him was to become a religious ascetic. Since he was the heir apparent to the throne, one logical solution would have been for him to consider raising an army and challenging the power of his neighbors. But this course he did not choose to take. I would like to think that he instinctively rejected it because of his deeply humanitarian nature, The young men of India in Sakyamuni’s time, Particularly those belonging to noble or powerful families, in general dreamed of two ideals. One was to become a Chakravarti-raja, or “Wheel-turning King,” a great leader who would guide his kingdom to a Position of supremacy in the temporal world. The other was to become a Buddha, an enlightened sage who would act as a spiritual teacher to the men of his age. Sakyamuni, we may say, quite consciously chose to pursue the latter ideal.
Though he lived in the luxury of the royal palace, what he saw When he turned his eyes beyond the palace were the daily struggles and sufferings of the ordinary men and women of the Sakya tribe. Those about him did their best to hide such unpleasant sights from him, but the more they tried to shield him from reality, the deeper and keener did this sensitive young man become in his determination to confront it. The legend of the four excursions outside the palace gates conveys in symbolic form how his mind was working at this time.
Because he knew that military force can never bring about a lasting solution to the problem of human suffering, he did not attempt to assist his people by any resort to arms but instead embarked on the road that he hoped in time would lead to sagehood. Rather than become a king who wields political power in the temporal world, he chose to become a philosopher-king in the metaphysical realm. Rather than seek some fleeting moment of glory for his people in the ever changing world of political power, he chose to bestow upon them a joy that is everlasting and changeless, founded upon the essentials of truth.
Although Sakyamuni clearly renounced all claim to kingship in the temporal world, his disciples in later ages, as seen in the scriptures, nevertheless often bestowed upon him the title of Chakravarti-raja, or ideal monarch. The fact that such a title, originally appropriate only for a political or social leader, should have been applied to a leader in the spiritual realm is claimed by some to be an indication that Sakyamuni and his disciples suffered from a kind of political inferiority complex and wished to create an impression of worldly success. This assertion, however, seems to me extremely doubtful. It was very common for the early Buddhists to take over concepts and terms prevalent in Brahmanism and adapt them to their own use. In adopting the term Chakravarti-raja and applying it to the Buddha, their purpose, I believe, was simply to emphasize the universal validity of Sakyamuni’s teachings.
With regard to Sakyamuni’s decision to leave his home and take up the religious life, it should be borne in mind that in ancient India, such a step never implied an attitude of pessimism or despair. Nowadays when one takes up the religious life, he is often thought of as leaving the ordinary world and entering a world apart. But this was not true in ancient India, which had a long and well-established tradition of asceticism and spiritual quest. In Sakyamuni’s time it was quite common for men of intellectual bent to leave their homes, enter the forest, and seek to discover the truth of human existence. Far from being looked upon as eccentric, such a course of action was thought of almost as a normal part of one’s life in this world. The only difference in the case of Sakyamuni is that he entered upon this phase of his life rather early. This, I would say, was because his passion to discover the truth was far stronger than that of other men. He was not merely complying with the custom of the time but obeying forces that sprang from the inner recesses of his being. which one might pursue philosophical concerns and seek to discover the fundamental truths of human existence. In entering upon such a life, a person naturally removed himself from the ordinary framework of society and culture and in a sense repudiated its values. But he did so for purposes of reflection, so that he might discover new ideals and values and then, returning once more to the conventional framework of society, teach and lead the men within it from the standpoint of a new and higher dimension, This is why Buddhism, the religion founded by Sakyamuni, has. never been alienated or removed from the society and age in which it exists. It has always been conscious of the need to discover, : through some unique philosophical approach, a fundamental solution to the problems of the society and the times in which it functions.
The Ascetic and Indian Society Before continuing to examine the course of Sakyamuni’s life. it may be well at this point to consider the role of asceticism in ancient Indian life, for this will shed light upon the spiritual climate that prevailed in Sakyamuni’s time. Just when and under what circumstances, one may ask, did this practice of abandoning one’s family and turning to the life of the religious; ascetic begin in India? The great poet and Philosopher Rabindranath Tagore says somewhere that “Greek civilization was built out of bricks made of clay, but Indian civilization was born in the forest.” I wonder if asceticism in India did not have its genesis in the Indian fascination with the forest and the habit of retiring to the forest to meditate and perfect one’s wisdom and understanding. This custom has long been a part of the Indian tradition, and even today there are dense forests in the Ganges River basin where groups of people who have gone into retirement lead a kind of communal: life devoted to the search for greater Philosophical understanding. It is quite conceivable that, as Tagore has said, Indian civilization and philosophy were in fact born in the forest, There is in early Indian history a period known as the age of the Aranyakas, or “forest treatises.” This occurred slightly before the so-called Upanishad period, or some three hundred years before the time of Sakyamuni. It would appear that, as the writings that give their name to the period indicate, the custom of retiring to the forest. for meditation dates back at least to the time, which would Yr correspond to about the eighth or ninth century B.c. fs By Sakyamuni’s time it had become a convention or custom a among members of the upper class to retire to the forest for such a period of meditation and searching for truth. Members of the upper xe class, which consisted mainly of people belonging to the Brahman; ce class, appear to have divided their life into four distinct periods: (1) : the period of brahmacharin, or studenthood; (2) the period of grihastha, or family life: (3) the period of vanasprastha, or life in the forest; and (4) the period of sannyasin, or seclusion and wandering. The first period, that of studenthood, began at the age of seven or eight and lasted about twelve years, during which time one received instruction from teachers in the doctrines and practices of Brahmanism. Upon completion of these studies, one returned to his family, married, and entered the second phase. This phase, the longest of the four, lasted some thirty years, from the age of twenty to the age of fifty, and during it a man performed sacrifices to his ancestors and carried out other ritual duties, raised a family of his own. and took an active part in society as the head of a family. When he had fulfilled his duties as head of a family and had produced an heir to carry on in his place, he was free to take up residence in the forest and, while reflecting quietly upon the previous fifty years of his life, could seek to share the life of the natural world about him and attain full philosophical maturity. After this period of asceticism and religious practice was completed, he emerged from the forest and spent the last period of life wandering about from place to place in a penniless state, depending upon alms for a livelihood.
This. as will be seen, is a very religiously and philosophically oriented course of life. In the modern world, we can perhaps say that the first phase is equivalent to the period of formal education and the second phase to the years that one devotes to his business or profession before retirement. But there is no exact equivalent to the third and fourth periods of retirement and reflection upon the meaning of life.
Of course, the ancient Brahmans lived in a society that was far less complex than that of today, and there were undoubtedly fewer demands upon their time. Moreover, since they represented the highest class in society and had slaves laboring under them to provide the economic necessities of life, they were free to devote themselves to other concerns. Nevertheless, whatever conditions may have been necessary to make it possible, the fact that the early Brahmans laid out such a four-phased course of life indicates how deeply rooted was the custom of philosophical meditation in Indian life and what great importance the Indians attached to concerns of philosophy and religion. Needless to say, it is highly admirable in any people of any age to find them utilizing the few years that are given to them in this life to examine the realities of human existence and to attempt on the basis of what they discover to formulate some definite personal philosophy. Not only in India, but in ancient China as well, we see the same desire to correlate the periods of a man’s life with some deepening comprehension of the meaning and proper approach to life, as in Confucius’ famous statement, “At thirty I stood on my own, at forty I was free from doubt, at fifty I understood the will of Heaven.” In contrast to the men of ancient times, who appear to have had this sense of advancement and purposeful seeking in their lives, modern man seems merely to be buffeted by endless dizzying waves of change and swamped in a vast deluge of knowledge and information that he is powerless to understand or control.
But to return from such melancholy disgressions to the subject of ancient India, I do not think we can say with any exactitude just when this four-phased concept of life arose in the Brahman class. It seems to have been in existence by the time of the Aranyaka period, however, as previously mentioned.
When we consider Sakyamuni's life in terms of the four traditional phases, we will see that he abandoned his family and entered upon the ascetic life during the second rather than the third phase and quite early in the second phase at that. It has often been asserted that he was merely following the custom of his class and time when he left home. Far from following custom, however, as we have seen, he actually left home at a far earlier age than was prescribed by convention, an indication of how intense was his desire to set out in search of truth. His entry upon the religious life was motivated by much deeper impulses than those that governed the ordinary follower of convention.
The Departure and Wanderings. The scriptures contain various legends of a dramatic nature concerning Sakyamuni’s actual departure from the palace. Setting aside for the moment those of a patently fictional nature, we may note that Sakyamuni, after arriving at his momentous decision, is said to have confided in his father. This is to be expected, since his father had b en worried over Sakyamuni’s sensitivity and strong tendency toward introspection and had taken special pains in his upbringing. And if we accept the account of the scriptures, his father would already have had forebodings of the kind of life that lay in store for his son.
I say this because we are told that after Sakyamuni had been born at the Lumbini Gardens and brought to the palace in Kapilavastu, his father sent for a renowned soothsayer named Asita and asked him to prophesy his son’s future. Asita, after examining the features of the newborn child. replied, “He has signs that indicate that he may become a universal monarch who will rule the world, or that he may become a Buddha who will renour family life and lead the world to salvation. But though he has signs indicating either possibility, I believe that this prince will surely become a Buddha!”
One is tempted to dismiss this legend as merely another manifestation of the process of deification that took place after Sakyamuni’s_ enlightenment. On the other hand. soothsaying, astrology, and other methods of divination were very commonly practiced in the society of Sakyamuni’s time, and there is nothing surprising in Suddhodana’s calling in a diviner to foretell his son’s future. As to the actual content of Asita’s prophecy, I would like to interpret it as a tribute to some perhaps undefinable quality about the infant Sakyamuni that set him apart from ordinary men.
We find this kind of prophecy recorded about many famous historical personages: they had about them even in infancy, we are told, a nobility of expression, an intrepid demeanor, or a winning gentleness that presaged some extraordinary future. Sakyamuni too is described in the scriptures as having lustrous features that held the gaze of the people around him “like the moon,” and limbs that “shone with the radiance of precious gold.” Such descriptions may be no more than the inventions of zealous disciples of later years, yet it is not surprising that the seer Asita should have found something arresting and unusual in the features of the infant Sakyamuni and that his predictions of future Buddhahood should have helped to foster the apprehension that Suddhodana felt concerning his moody
Sakyamuni was undoubtedly fully aware of his father’s fears, and therefore when he finally arrived at his decision to renounce family life, he immediately reported his intentions to his father. Though the news could not have come as a total surprise, Suddhodana was shocked by the gravity of his son’s decision, and he attempted to dissuade him.
As a last resort, he is said to have taken forcible measures to prevent his son’s departure from the city. Legend gives a highly touching and dramatic account of Sakyamuni’s departure from the palace and the way in which he managed to escape from the city, but we need not go into such details here. It is enough to relate that one night, mounted on his beloved steed Kanthaka and accompanied by his attendant Chandaka, he made his way out of the city of Kapilavastu.
He first entered the territory of the Koliyas, and from there journeyed south across the Anouma River. Then he cut off his hair, removed all his jewelry and ornaments, handed them over to Chandaka, and sent the latter back to Kapilavastu with the message that he would not return to the city until he had fulfilled the objective for which he had entered the religious life and attained enlightenment. From that point on he journeyed alone, dressed as a religious mendicant, making his way south through the states of Malla and Vajji in the direction of Magadha.
The distance from Kapilavastu to Rajagaha, the capital of Magadha, was about six hundred kilometers. Since there is reported to have been considerable commercial activity in those times, it is probable that he traveled along the trade route running through the area. We know that in later years, after his enlightenment, he often traveled with trade caravans when he embarked on his proselytizing journeys.
But before describing his activities in Magadha, let us return to two points touched on above. The first is the fact that Sakyamuni cut off his hair when he entered the religious life. Some scholars maintain that the custom of tonsuring was already practiced by some Brahman ascetics before the time of Sakyamuni. After Sakyamuni’s time, however, it came to be regarded as a special mark of members of the Buddhist Order, and records tell us that members of that order were referred to as munda. a word meaning “tonsured one.” Ascetics of other religious groups in the period before Sakyamuni, if they practiced tonsuring at all, must not have done so in anything like the consistent fashion of the Buddhists.
Brahmans, as we know from epithets applied to them. were conspicuous for Wearing their hair tied up or braided, while the followers of Jainism as one of their ascetic Practices pulled out the hairs of their head and beard one by one. I believe it is safe to conclude that, although the practice of tonsuring may have existed before Sakyamuni, after Sakyamuni and his disciples it came to be associated particularly with the followers of Buddhism, The second point requiring some comment is that Sakyamuni adopted the garb of a religious mendicant. In Sakyamuni’s time the custom of mendicancy, or begging for alms, was widely practiced by those who had entered upon the homeless life and was looked upon as a highly commendable form of behavior. The practice probably dates back a number of centuries before Sakyamuni’s time and may be as old as the pursuit of the ascetic life itself. A person who has embarked upon the ascetic life and completed his religious training is called a bhikkhu, a Pali word meaning “one who begs for food.” In ancient India, such people who had completed their training in the ascetic life and who wandered about soliciting alms were looked upon with great respect, and ordinary people were only too happy to give them food. This was because it was believed that by doing so one could acquire a store of good karma, or causes leading to good effects, for oneself. As for the mendicants themselves, far from being obsequious or fawning in their requests, they are said to have walked the streets with an air of great dign y, clad in proper robes rather than the rags of ordinary beggars. When they had received an offering, they quickly took their departure without bothering to thank the almsgiver, and if their presence at the door was unnoticed by the members of the family, they would shake the metal rings that were attached to the tips of their staves to attract attention. Such behavior would seem to indicate that the practice of mendicancy itself was regarded as having deep religious significance. On the other hand, the person receiving alms, if it was a gift of food, was expected to eat it with a sense of gratitude, no matter how simple or even unsavory it might be.
I wonder in this respect if mendicancy, and the attendant sense represent a form of challenge or protest against the taboos of Indian society, By taboos I am referring to the rigid rules governing the class and caste system, under which all people in the country were divided into four major classes: the Brahman or priestly class, the Kshatriya or warrior class, the Vaisyas, who were merchants and landowners, and the Sudras, who were peasants or serfs belonging to the aboriginal population. In a dition to these basic class divisions, various caste divisions grew up in time. Members of associate freely, and one could not even eat food that had been prepared by a person of another caste. Such strictures were observed with particular punctiliousness by the members of the higher castes, who would rather starve to death than eat food that came from the hands of a person of inferior caste and hence was ritually defiled. In this rigidly segregated society of ancient India, the figure of the religious mendicant, wandering about from village to village and eating whatever was given to him, certainly presents something of an anomaly.
As mentioned above, a bhikkhu, or mendicant, was originally a person who had completed his period of training in the ascetic life, and was respected by the population at large for that reason. This concept gradually changed over the centuries, however, until just before Sakyamunis time ascetics appeared who looked upon mendicancy itself as a form of religious practice. This new group of mendicant ascetics included thinkers who refused to recognize the strictures of the traditional Brahmanic social system and who sought deliberately to challenge and break away from the old order. They were able to do this all the more effectively because of the great respect traditionally accorded in India to one who has embarked upon the ascetic life.
I have mentioned already the two ideal types of persons in ancient Indian thought, the universal monarch and the sage or enlightened man. The mendicant ascetic represented a person who had already completed the practices leading to enlightenment, or at least was far advanced in that direction. When one found oneself in the presence of such an embodiment of the ideal, it was only natural to be filled with anticipation and awe and, while gladly presenting offerings of food, to hope that one’s own karmic destiny might be benefited by the meeting. Respect for the man of religion runs very deep in Indian society, as seen by the fact that the highest of the four classes is that of the Brahmans, or priests. Therefore it came to be felt that when one met with a true man of religion, class and caste distinctions could be forgotten in the act of presenting him with one’s wholehearted offering.
The Rise Of A New Culture Sakyamuni traveled south. as we have said, with the state of Magadha as his final destination. Various suggestions have been put forward as to why he chose Magadha rather than one of the other states of the time. The most powerful states in this period were Magadha and Koshala. But the latter, as we have seen, was situated close to Sakyamuni’s native state and dominated it politically. If he had gone to Koshala and it had there been discovered that he, the prince of a dependent state, had entered the religious life, there would undoubtedly have been considerable comment, and it is even possible that he would have been forcibly sent back to Kapilavastu, the city from which he had only managed with great effort to escape. It was probably with this thought in mind that he chose to journey to Magadha, where the danger of enforced repatriation was much less.
Aside from such personal reasons, it is probable that Sakyamuni culture that was coming into being. Indian society was at this time undergoing a Process of radica] change. The members of the Brahman class. who had Previously been looked upon almost as divine beings, were beginning to lose their authority, and the traditional patterns of the society over which they had Presided were likewise changing. Partly this Was the result of Corruption and degeneracy within the ranks of the Brahmans themselves. but it was assisted and hastened by SWeeping social changes that took place as the Aryan invaders, who had entered India from the northwest some centuries earlier, continued to expand their POwer to the east and south. With the growth of commerce and trade, rich merchants of the Vaisya class appeared who, because of their wealth and Power, could challenge the authority of the Brahmans, In addition, as the territorial expansion of the Aryans progressed the members of the Kshatriya class, who fought the battles and acted as politica] leaders of the newly formed states, likewise rose in authority until their power was greater than that of their nominal superiors, the priestly Brahmans.
In the time of Sakyamuni and shortly before, we find the members of the Kshatriya class challenging the Brahmans not only in matters of social power and precedence but in the fields of philosophy and religion as well. The Upanishads, religious writings that date from a period slightly later than that of the Aranyakas, or forest treatises, mentioned earlier. give many evidences of the challenge being posed by the Kshatriyas to the authority of the Brahmans. In one of the Upanishads. for instance, we are told of a king who openly disputed with a Brahman and pointed out fallacies in the Brahmanic religious doctrines. According to the account, the Brahman sage admitted defeat and in turn begged the king to become his teacher. Such anecdotes give evie ence that the Kshatriyas were beginning to surpass the Brahmans in both social and intellectual position. In addition. the entire philosophy underlying the Upanishads, with its skepticism and ceaseless questioning of accepted beliefs. may be said to represent the outlook of this new group rising to power in society.
These new leaders of the Kshatriya class, along with the new class of wealthy merchants known as shreshthin, departed from the patterns of the old tribal society of the Brahmans and worked to build a new kind of social structure headed by a monarch, In Sakyamuni’s time these social changes were taking place with great rapidity, and the center of the new society and culture that were beginning to emerge was the state of Magadha.
History shows that the truly great and epoch-making philosophers, thinkers, and revolutionaries of the world first acquaint themselves with the finest culture and ideology of their time before going on to transcend it and establish their own original system of philosophy. Sakyamuni no doubt chose to go to Magadha because he wished to confront the new culture and thought that “NG were evolving there. It is important to note that it was in Magadha also that he practiced religious austerities, attained enlightenment, and first began to preach the Buddhist religion, and that among his early converts were king Bimbisara of Magadha and many of the shreshthin, or wealthy merchants, of the state. In addition, King Pasenadi of Koshala also respected Sakyamuni and supported his religious activities. Buddhism, it would seem, was able fully to reflect and absorb the tendencies and modes of thought of the new culture and society, and in time became the religion most commonly associated with it. This does not mean, of course, that Buddhism addressed itself only to merchants and members of the ruling class. It was from the beginning a religion that repudiated all class and caste distinctions and appealed to all people alike, regardiess of their position in society, but this is a point that I would like to discuss at greater length a little later.
The assistance that the wealthy merchants gave to the Buddhist Order is often mentioned in the scriptures. One of them donated the Bamboo Grove Monastery in Rajagaha and another a monastery in the city of Savatthi in Koshala. The best known of these wealthy men who lent active support to Sakyamuni and his followers was Sudatta, said to have been the richest man in Koshala. He was known by the name Anathapindada, or “Supplier of the Needy,” because of the generous way in which he shared his wealth with the poor. I would like now to examine a little more closely this new culture that was growing up in Magadha and Koshala. One of its most important and distinctive features was the appearance of thinkers who openly repudiated the Vedic tradition and the authority of the old Brahmanic social order. Their appearance is very important, for it indicates just how radical were the changes taking place in society, with men daring to free themselves entirely from the doctrines of Brahmanism.
These men were known by the term shramana. The word shramana, which means “one who practices religious austerities,” was originally applied to all ascetics in general, that is, to men who, in the four traditional phases of life described above, had embarked upon the third phase and entered the forest to practice austerities and meditation. By Sakyamuni’s time, however, the word had come to mean those ascetics who refused to accept Brahmanism and the social order that it represented.
Magadha seems to have been a kind of gathering place for these shramanas. Sakyamuni later came to be called Gautama Shramana because he was regarded as belonging to this group of reformist thinkers. But although at the outset he undoubtedly explored the new schools of thought that were springing up, the enlightenment that he eventually attained was totally removed from and of a wholly different dimension from anything dreamed of by the other shramanas of the time.
The Six Non-Buddhist Teachers Let us examine some of the doctrines taught by these new thinkers of Sakyamuni’s time. This is no easy task, since these thinkers were far from being in agreement with one another and propounded a great variety of ideas. The Buddhist scriptures, however, mention six men who were leaders among the thinkers of the shramana group. Known as the six heretical or non-Buddhist teachers. they are Makkhali Gosala, Purana and Nigantha Nataputta.
Of these, the most famous is Nigantha Nataputta, who founded the religion know as Jainism. He was a member of the Kshatriya class and a son of the noble and prestigious Licchavi tribe, but he left his family and took up the ascetic life, seeking liberation through rigorous discipline and a strict suppression of all desire. We will have more to say concerning the rigorous austerities practiced by the ascetics of this time when we come to the discussion of Sakyamuni’s own asceticism. Here I would simply add that one of the most important prohibitions placed upon the followers of the Jain religion is that against the taking of life. The injunction is interpreted with extreme rigor, so that one must take elaborate precautions to prevent the inadvertent killing of even a tiny insect.
The injunction against the taking of life and other precepts of the Jains bear a considerable resemblance to the Five Precepts of Buddhism. But Buddhism in spirit rejects the kind of extreme asceticism enjoined by Nigantha Nataputta and his followers. Sakyamuni himself for a time practiced such extreme austerities but abandoned them when he realized that they merely inflicted suffering upon the body and did not lead to enlightenment.
Another thinker who seems to have enjoyed a considerable following among the intellectuals of the time was Ajita Kesakambala, the third of the six non-Buddhist teachers mentioned above. Declaring that everything in the universe is made up of the four basic elements of earth, water, fire, and wind, he taught a doctrine of thoroughgoing materialism. Since the world is made up of matter alone, nothing remains of man when the body dies, and it is therefore of no consequence whether he does good or evil in his lifetime.
The popularity of such amoralistic doctrines reflects the intellectual climate of the age. The religious teachings of Brahmanism, which previously had been looked upon as sacred and inviolable, had been challenged and in some cases openly rejected, and this naturally led to a questioning of the moral concepts taught by Brahmanism as well. This negativistic attitude toward traditional moral standards is a trait shared by all the six non-Buddhist thinkers we are discussing. In one sense, this type of thinking represented a great step forward, since it implied an attempt to free man from his fear of the wrath of the gods and from the merciless restrictions of the social system. On the other hand, one cannot deny that such philosophies had a tendency to degenerate into nihilism and moral decadence. In this respect Sakyamuni, though he was called a shramana, differed greatly from these thinkers, since there was nothing of this antisocial element in his teachings.
Sanjaya Velatthiputta, the fifth of the six non-Buddhist teachers, was noted for his nihilism and skepticism. He questioned the doctrine of the immortality of the atman, or Self, as expounded in the Upanishads, and the eternal principle of Brahman, maintaining that no such eternal and unchanging principle exists.
Among Sanjaya Velatthiputta’s most outstanding disciples were two men named Sariputra and Maudgalyayana, who, growing dissatisfied with the nihilism and negativism of their teacher’s doctrines and being deeply impressed by the pure and holy aspect of one of Sakyamuni's disciples whom they chanced to meet, decided to become followers of Buddhism. When they left Sanjaya and became disciples of Sakyamuni, some two-hundred and fifty of Sanjaya Velatthiputta’s other followers are reported to have joined them. Sariputra and Maudgalyayana in time came to be numbered among the ten great disciples of the Buddha. According to legend, Sanjaya was so distressed at losing two of his most promising disciples that he spat up blood. If he was a true skeptic, however, the incident must have convinced him more than ever of the rightness of his views.
The same questioning of traditional moral values is found in the teachings of the first of the six non-Buddhist thinkers, Makkhali Gosala, who expounded an extreme form of fatalism. Since everything in the world, according to him, appears and perishes in accordance with the ineluctable laws of karma, or causality, no amount of devotional effort or practice of religious austerities by man can have any effect upon the stricly fated course of events. He therefore counseled men to accept the doctrine of samsara, or transmigration, as it is expounded in the Upanishads, and indeed maintained that they had no alternative. His would seem to be the prototype of the kind of philosophy of total resignation that is popularly referred to nowadays by the phrase che sara sara, “what will be will be.”
In direct contradiction of Makkhali Gosala’s views, Purana Kassapa, the second of the six thinkers, denied the existence of any law of karma and put forward the view that all phenomena are totally without significance. This nihilistic view in the end led him to deny the social nature of man as well, and to reject all concepts of morality and of man’s proper role in society.
Among these generally nihilistic doctrines, the teaching of Pakudha Kaccayana, the fourth of the six teachers, stand out as something of an exception. To the four material elements expounded by Ajita Kesakambala, earth, water, fire, and wind, he added such spiritual elements as suffering, pleasure, and the soul, and he also expounded the doctine of the immortality and changeless nature of the soul. In his view of life. duty is to ensure the peace and stability of his soul, These new thinkers Carried out religious Practices based on their various philosophies. and since their doctines were often extremist in nature and represented a deliberate repudiation of tradition and past history, their religious practices were similarly drastic and unconventional. including, we are told, sitting naked in the burning heat of the sun. daubing the body all over with mud, eating only the wild grasses that Srew in the forest, and in genera] endeavoring to live the most primitive kind of life. In terms of ideological atmosphere, their age was in some Ways quite like our Own, and their ways of reacting to the times had much in common with those of the hippies of today. In modern parlance, they were dropouts from traditional Brahmanic society who banded together to live a communal life based on Patterns and values of their own. Underlying their behavior was the desire for some new and more satisfying Philosophy of life. while their behavior itself often flouted the accepted norms of convention and common sense. In all these respects, they resembled the hippies of Our time. Conversely, the hippies often seem to be very drawn to yoga, Zen, and other facets of Indian and Far Eastern Philosophy, which further suggests that there is some kind of underlying emotional affinity between the time of Sakyamuni and the six non-Buddhist thinkers and our own age. And the fact that the doctrines of the six thinkers, with their strongly materialistic and amoral elements and their nihilistic cast, were able to enjoy considerable popularity is another point that calls for comparison of that period with modern times
The six thinkers, as has been stated before, lived at a time when a New social class was coming to the fore and profound changes were taking place. It is only natural, therefore, that men’s sense of values should have undergone changes as well, In this period of rapidly changing values. the six t ers in my view acted as standard-bearers for the new forces that were seeking to demolish the rigid system of values created earlier by Brahmanism. The markedly nihilistic and negativistic tendencies in their thought were probably no more than reflections of the general Philosophical temper of the times. But with a negativistic Philosophy alone one cannot foster the kind of spirit that will create a new society. This was the limitation inherent in their thought. It was only Buddhism, the Philosophy of Sakyamuni, that in My opinion was able to transcend this negativistic philosophy and Provide a final dialectical] resolution of the problems raised by the opposition between traditional Brahmanism and the forces seeking to overthrow it.
Because of the parallels that exist between the age of Sakyamuni and our own, we should not regard the appearance of the teachers and the Philosophy of Sakyamuni simply as events that took place long ago in India. For modern man, living in a society strongly colored by currents of epicureanism, nihilism, and decadence, these events have an important historical message.
As pointed out by the German philosopher Karl Jaspers, Sakyamuni was born at almost the same time that Socrates appeared in Greece, Confucius in China, and the Deutero-Isaiah, whose thought exerted such an important influence on Christianity, in the Judaic world. The almost simultaneous appearance of these great men, in Jasper’s view, marks this as the dawn of the spiritual civilization of mankind. In terms of the human spirit, it may be called the first great pivotal era, when the various philosophies propounded by these men made their appearance in response to the changes that ancient society had undergone and the material culture it had produced.
Until the nineteenth century, human history continued to unfold on the basis of the spiritual principles evolved at the time of this first pivotal era. But with the twentieth century, the material civilization that man has created for himself has suddenly begun to change and advance with a wholly unexpected rapidity. What is needed at this point, in Jaspers’s opinion, is a new philosophy, a new religion that can cope with the phenomenal growth of science and technology and introduce a second pivotal age. I agree completely with his view.
Thus when we turn our attention to a study of the time of Sakyamuni, it is not simply because we wish to know about the events of the distant past but because we are concerned for the needs of the present. For when we delve deeply and with true earnestness into the past, who knows what fresh springs of spiritual nourishment may be brought to light? The great interest in Buddhism evident among intellectuals today is fostered, I believe, by hopes of such a discovery.
But to return to the subject of the six non-Buddhist teachers, the noted Buddhist scholar Fumio Masutani has suggested that the relationship between the six teachers and Sakyamuni resembled that which existed between the Sophists and Socrates. Socrates’ teachings in some ways paralleled or drew upon the teachings of the various Sophist philosophers, but at the same time Socrates far surpassed the Sophists dialectically. In the same way, the teachings of Sakyamuni paralleled but far transcended those of the six non-Buddhist teachers. Moreover, just as Greek political and cultural life in Socrates’ time centered on the city-states of Athens, Sparta, and others, so the life of northern India in Sakyamuni’s time was dominated by the city-states of Rajagaha in Magadha, Savatthi in Koshala, and others. It would appear that the social and political backgrounds out of which the great philosophies and religions of the world are born are almost bound to have elements in common. Out of a condition of intellectual ferment and turmoil in one part of the world came the philosophy of Sakyamuni, which provided a dialectical resolution of the conflicting doctines of the six teachers and the ninety-five Brahmanic sects, while out of a similar turmoil in another part of the world came the philosophy of Socrates.
Captions and notes
entire Buddhist religion, was an ardent desire to find some Way to
The ascetic life, as we have seen, was regarded as a means by
SPRING 1977 75 ons ane*
obligation to eat whatever food was offered to one, did not in some
different castes were forbidden to intermarry, eat together, or
TEE i Nn "eraser chose to go to Magadha because he saw it as the center of a new
