Viewing Law as an Aspect of Chudo in Society
Symposium
NSA Quarterly, Spring 1977, pp. 49–58. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
The old rhyme lists “doctors, lawyers, and Indian chiefs.” Most of us could define the former and the latter, but could we say what it is that the one in the middle does — and why? We know, vaguely, that lawyers function as the makers and speakers of laws, but what that entails is largely myth and mystery to most of us. The Quarterly recently talked with six NSA members who are involved in the legal profession in an attempt to shed some light on the complex world of law.
Participants:
Linda Johnson, a third-year law student at the University of Southern California, from North Hollywood Headquarters.
John Heaney, a corporate attorney, from Santa Monica Headquarters.
Tom McCoy, a recent graduate now clerking for a Federal judge, from Santa Monica Headquarters.
Steve Rensch, a litigation attorney, from Santa Monica Headquarters.
Harold Rubenfeld, a personal injury attorney, from North Hollywood Headquarters.
Terry Steinhart, a civil attorney in the entertainment field, from Santa Monica Headquarters.
QUARTERLY: Lawyers, like doctors, are frequently looked upon by their clients almost as parent figures. Is this useful or detrimental?
RUBENFELD: I think on the whole, it’s detrimental. Parents get their authority from some kind of moral responsibility to their children. Parents have more experience in life than their children on which to make moral judgments. But lawyers don’t have that authority. Lawyers are viewed today almost like Plato’s philosopher-kings, as reservoirs of wisdom, people who know every way to manipulate the world and get things done. Lawyers play that role, but : unfortunately they don’t serve any moral purpose as a rule. I think the reason why more don’t is because people go to a lawyer generally with the idea of ‘How can I get the most for myself; how can I do the other guy in?’ People don’t expect a truly parent-like reaction from a lawyer. They don’t expect a moral response. A parent sits down and explains how to take the other person’s rights into consideration, but most lawyers are not supposed to think of the other side. I find myself many times saying on the outside, “Yeah, let’s get that guy,” but inside I’m saying, “No, you’re really wrong.” My job, though, is really to accentuate the strong parts of my client’s side and to ignore the rights of the other side. That type of function doesn’t lend itself to being a parent. Hopefully, parents don’t advise their children the same way lawyers advise their clients.
STEINHART: There are various types of clients depending on the type of case involved, who view the lawyer differently. First of all, perhaps twenty percent at most of a lawyer’s man-hours are spent in litigation, going to court. Many lawyers never go to court at all. They advise clients, draft contracts, negotiate. Most attorneys spend their time representing businessmen in business deals. In those cases, you are dealing with people who are executives or are running their own companies. They don’t look at a lawyer as a father figure; they look at him almost like a plumber — someone who is hired to give a service. The rest of a lawyer’s clients, those who are engaged in personal injury cases or have been busted on some light criminal offense, might tend to look upon that lawyer as a parental figure, But, that’s the minority of cases. It’s helpful if a client treats the lawyer with a certain respect so that he listens to what the lawyer has to say, because he’s supposed to be the expert. But I think it’s largely irrelevant how a client looks upon his attorney.
QUARTERLY: It seems there is a great deal of ritual in the legal system. Is this necessary? Is there a movement to break away from ritual?
HEANEY: There’s a great deal of ritual, most of it’s necessary, and once a month some legal or semi-legal periodical comes across my desk proposing a revamp of certain provisions to make them more understandable. Every time somebody drafts a statute, somebody else within one day to three years figures out a clever way to get around it. So they revise the statute to close the loophole. Or someone finds that that statute works a gross inequity on someone not intended by that statute to be so affected, so they have to amend the statute to add an exception clause. Then others figure out how they can qualify under the exception, even though it was not intended for them. That’s how the long, complicated laws and procedures get developed.
The real rituals that people are concerned with are all the procedural forms and hassling with filing — all the little things you have to do. However, I’ve had occasion to become involved in lawsuits in other jurisdictions: one in Nevada, one in Utah, and a whole series in Florida. In some of those jurisdictions, they don’t follow those rituals, and it can be terrifying. People can write letters to — t { the judge, making a very strong and persuasive argument which no one else js able to counter, because they were not required by law to send copies of that letter to the opposing side. You might not find out about a request that some fellow’s been making until it’s been made and the judge has issued an order based on a letter you did not know of. You can go back and get it undone, of course, but that just makes things more expensive and time-consuming, Consequently, each side can play all sorts of games with the other side. So, the rituals do have a purpose. Although things take longer, these are safeguards. And, eventually, those which have no purpose are gotten rid of.
STEINHART: It’s hard for me to judge ritual, because I do it every day, so it doesn’t seem to me to be ritual. There’s a certain kind of language used by lawyers that’s ritualistic like “Grantor hereby grants, sells, conveys, transfers and sets over unto Grantee. . ,” Attorneys are afraid, to some extent, to break away attorney and every judge knows what from certain pat phrases because every they mean. If you use a phrase that is more simplistic and less redundant, you’re afraid that everybody might not give that phrase the same meaning they give to the time-tested phrases.
There are certain rituals or procedures that are in use in the courtroom, like rising when the judge comes in, standing when you address the judge, not talking directly to the Opposing counsel when court’s in session but directing any remarks you may have to the judge, addressing only the judge, asking the judge’s permission to approach a witness or to have a document marked as an exhibit. These are all ritualistic procedures but they’re good in that they give a feeling or aura of respect for the court which is run by the judge and of solemnity for the proceedings. People are tf coming here with grievances that - engender possible anger or hatred, but because of the system of courtroom Procedure, they come in +> have their dispute resolved peacefully. They will abide by the decision of a human being in accordance with the rules of law that have been laid down by human beings.
You are subverting anger and hostility and disputes that people would otherwise have to settle by fighting or killing or stealing. It’s just like learning the reasons why NSA does things the Way it does, because of the time-tested reasons behind the procedure.
McCOY: In a way there is somewhat of a move to break away from ritual. By that, I mean the movement to. take certain kinds of controversies out of the courtroom, setting up neighborhood tribunals where people can decide different controversies without all the trappings of the courtroom. Certain disputes are conducive to that, but otherwise, ritual is here to stay.
Ritual creates an environment that makes people play out roles. One of the major benefactors of the ritual is the judge. Judges are ordinary human beings whom we look at as something apart from us, invested with the mind, the authority, the wisdom we don’t have. But they are just people — with preconceived prejudices, previous experiences which color their thinking, varying levels of intelligence and education — very human. What’s strange is how well the system functions. The judge puts on his robe, mounts the bench, and people believe in him — and he believes in himself. He puts on his robe and he is not himself — he’s a “judge.” People continue to believe in the system because judges, regardless of UNIVERSITY CLUB PERSPEC past experiences or prejudices, by and large do a good job. They are treated with respect — respect for the office. The attorneys try to give the judge everything he needs to know to judge that case. Because of the ritual involved, you have ordinary people behaving extraordinarily, in the interests of justice and not in their own interest, necessarily. Each ritual must be justified by logic and necessity or else it becomes costly and harmful. Nobody wants this and so unnecessary rituals get dumped, cleaned out.
QUARTERLY: Is the adversary system of law (as practiced in the U.S.) inhumane?
STEINHART: When you think of the adversary system, you usually think of the litigation arena. That was a choice that was made long ago in setting up the legal system from common law back in England. The idea was that when you are trying to reach the truth — that is what are the true facts and based on these facts, what are the legal consequences of these facts according to the rules of law that govern society — then the adversary system is the best way to do that. One side saying that “A” is the truth and the other side saying that “Not A’ is the truth, and an impartial judge or jury listening to each side presenting its case to the extreme — that would hopefully bring out both sides of the story as clearly as possible. Then the impartial listener, with both sides of the story laid out, can decide which side is correct or more probably correct. In a criminal case, the prosecution has to prove its side of the story beyond a reasonable doubt and to a moral STIVES a. certainty, whereas in a civil case, a suit, you just have to tip the balance scale somewhat to your side.
RENSCH: I can’t really say that I’ve seen a whole lot of evidence that it actually works. Theoretically, it makes sense — that that is the way you get the most facts out in the open, having people on opposite sides who really have an interest in getting all their facts out. Then you have a third party who can view these facts objectively. It seems to me, though, that there is just too much disparity in talent. In the year I clerked for a judge, I saw an awful lot of mismatches. I’d see people come in with cause of action suits which may have been truly valid, but you never knew because either the lawyer didn’t care enough or was unable to get them expressed. The adversary system doesn’t have any way of accounting for that. The client doesn’t know enough about law or lawyers to find someone to properly express his case. The only check you have, really, is the judge, himself. A good one can recognize incompetency and at least try to compensate for it, but there is little he can do. He gets into problems when he tries to do that, because he’s then not really being impartial. When you have relatively competent attorneys on both sides, then the adversary system is at its best.
QUARTERLY: Should you inject your own personal values into the client-attorney relationship?
STEINHART: I think an attorney should inject his personal values, because your job is to counsel the client. I always explain to the client that this is my personal point of view in advising him to take one course of action or another. The client wants me to do that. He has a more impassioned viewpoint because he is directly involved, and you have a more $$$ objective viewpoint and have more experience in resolving the type of problem that this person has. The client expects you to give him advice and some of that advice really calls for personal values. In a child custody case, the issue there is what’s best for the child. You’re dealing with human problems. As long as you make a full disclosure to the client, explain to him why you are saying what you’re saying, explain the other alternatives, that it’s ultimately his decision, you have done your job.
You can’t be a saint in life. You have to try for chudo. You can’t always be perfectly honest. The literal truth is not always the truth. The truth is really that which creates value. You might even have to support a lie on behalf of your client, a lie based on the literal truth, if you feel that he’s really in the right, but doesn’t have the evidence to back it up. Itsounds like a dishonest thing to do, but in certain circumstances you have to tell lies — to save people’s feelings or sometimes, to save time, to avoid having to lengthily explain the literal truth about things, or to create value in trying for the relative truth as opposed to the absolute truth. So, definitely I think you’ve got to develop your own personal values and utilize them.
QUARTERLY: There is a small but glowing wave among doctors toward w-called preventative medicine. Do you ee anything like this happening in your profession?
JOHNSON: Definitely. Lawyers have always had a problem with not being able to advertise. The Bar has always viewed advertising as degrading to the profession. If you were to open up the profession to advertising with no restrictions, you’d have a lot of problems, too, like leaving yourself open for all kinds of —OE—————————— a malpractice suits. At the Same time, you need to be able to make the public aware of lawyers’ different kinds of services, The public needs to know that there are all kinds of legal services available to them beyond the Perry Mason courtroom style. Lawyers can help people learn about the law as they go along, so they don’t have to go to court at the end when there’s a big dispute. There are stages along the way where that can be avoided, if people know more about how the legal process works. So, there’s a movement to allow certain limited advertising. And also legal insurance of a type where twenty-four hours a day, you can call an attorney and ask questions, covered by a flat, insurance-type fee, as opposed to only seeing a lawyer when you’re really in trouble. Also, when there are a lot of lawyers having to talk to the public on that twenty-four hour basis, the legal language will have to become much more like common, everyday language, so that the public can understand. There is a movement right now to start getting away from the ritualized documents we use and the ritualized language. That’s hard for lawyers to understand, so it’s got to be impossible for a layman to understand. One of these days, we’ll see contracts that everybody can read and know what’s going on.
RUBENFELD: I think no-fault insurance is an example of something preventative. If you are more aware of the system, if you face less of a gamble in the courts, then you can deal more rationally with a problem. No-fault insurance is trying to do that. Also, with that, it’s less difficult to do discovery, to discover documents in possession of your opponent. Less difficult and therefore less expensive, and more and more trials are prevented this way, with more out-of-court settlements. But I think that lawyers’ individual values have to change before we can have preventative law. Preventative law is to prevent conflict between individuals. I think that when lawyers realize how important their function is as mediators, as arbitrators, as grievance-solvers, rather than as grievance-creators, then there will be more preventative law. A lot of law can be taken out of the context of the courtroom and become really humane. I think a lawyer’s mission is to prevent or peacefully solve conflict, but right now many lawyers create conflict to help their clients in avoiding their obligations. In most law schools the idea of preventative law is never even mentioned. The whole point is to find the “cause of action” in each case. The prime point is “issue spotting,” where you can find the conflict, not how to solve that conflict.
QUARTERLY: The traditional means for changing society have always been either revolution, war, religion, or time itself. Nowadays, we see more effort directed at using law and the courts as a means of bringing about social change (desegregation, ERA, etc.) What do you think of this method?
McCOY: It’s a complicated question. Suddenly, everybody in the country has seemingly become very “litigious”
everybody’s suing everybody. One of the causes of that is ey simply the economy.
When the economy goes bad, people get in more disputes, people default in more contracts, they’re worried about money. When the economy is fat, you’ll let things slide that you won’t in leaner years. The Depression was an extremely litigious period. Apart from the economy, we are going through a real shake-up in values right now, what with Vietnam, the women’s movement, Watergate, the decline of traditional religions, and minorities’ activities. Everything is changing very fast, a lot of disagreement, a lot of confusion. It’s at times like these that you look for somebody to decide who gets what. Traditionally, Congress has decided these issues. Our representatives, duly elected, take care of problems like this. The trouble is that Congress can only do so much. The problems are large and complex and the wheels of government are heavier and turn more slowly. So, a lot of people just won’t wait for the legislators to move. The wheels of justice don’t move very fast either, but perhaps a little faster than Congress at this time.
However, we have to differentiate between questions decided upon the authority of the Constitution, be it state or federal, or cases decided under the authority of either legislative enactments or common law. A good example of common law would be the law of torts — personal injury law. That law has been developed by the courts themselves, over a period of time, out of necessity. In either case, legislative law or common law, if you later decide you don’t like it, you can get the legislature to move on that law and change it. But, on a law made on the authority of the Constitution, you can’t do this. The Constitution is held to be above the legislature. And so the courts, most notably the Supreme Court, find themselves dealing with issues that are politically untouchable, for one reason or another, by the whole Congress.
Desegregation is a good example. For a long, long time, I’m sure Congres SS PS te ES wished to move on forced desegregation in schools. The trouble was that that issue was politically untouchable. So came the 1954 Supreme Court decision. In those kinds of situations, there is no recourse but to turn to the courts. Judges are insulated from the waves of politics. On the other hand, the Supreme Court has no real power. The other arms of government are supposed to carry out the decisions of the Supreme Court, but it has no way of forcing them to do so. The Court’s decisions are binding under the law, but as James Madison, one of the architects of the Constitution, wrote in his Federalist Papers, “The Supreme Court has neither sword nor purse.” That is the great check on the Court. The Court is there to describe the law, but it cannot carry it out. The executive and legislative branches are required by law to carry out Supreme Court decisions, but who’s to make them do Ite should they not wish to? Only, really, their own desire to do what’s right.
RENSCH: The legislatures have really immobilized themselves and the executives began to fill the gap in the sixties and began to abuse that power, at all levels: city, state, and federal. So the executives ended by limiting their own effectiveness, and that leaves the courts. The courts are sacred in the eyes of a lot of people. People don’t understand them or the workings of the legal procedure, but they have a great respect for them. People are awed, humbled by the court, Which gives it a great deal of power. Judges are human and few of them are immune to that power. It’s not really a self-aware choice, to become the agent j of social change, it just sort of happens. = n A judge is in that position of power and ie ~~ he _has the Opportunity to do it, so he e€ does it. Should that happen? As a € lawyer, I’m inclined to think it should e not, because of the three branches of © government, the judiciary is the least n democratic. It may be the most S responsible, but it does not have to f answer to the people at all. Federal t judges, as an example, are appointed for t life. You can’t move them, unless they obviously abuse their positions.
In this country, change is supposed to be the will of the people. I believe things work out best that way, in the long run. Those who are governed by laws should be making the choices, through their elected agents. Beyond that, however, there is another problem that lawyers are acutely aware of. That is that no society can function very well without its harmonizers, the people who will stand there with at least the appearance of objectivity. Those people then become the advocates of society. They cannot be simply arbitrators. This is the danger as the courts become the spokesmen for social change. The Supreme Court is supposed to be the protector of the Constitution, but a creative mind can get out of the Constitution almost anything it wants to.
HEANEY: The courts, in recent years, have sort of taken on a legislative approach to things. One of the most startling decisions in my view of the last thirty years of the Supreme Court’s action was the Brown vs. Board of Education case, in terms of legal precedent. If you look at the way the United States is set up, the Constitution is the basic or supreme law. Every country has a supreme law, and ours is the Constitution. For a long time, that in itself was in dispute. People argued as to whether or not the U.S. Constitution existed at the permission of the states’ constitutions, but now, basically, it is considered the primary law, just as the Magna Carta is in England. It’s a written document and anybody with a fourth-grade education can read it. It read exactly the same in 1955 when Brown vs. Board of Education was decided as it did one hundred years earlier. This was the decision that said if you have a public school system, you must admit children of all minorities to that school system. The prior law or understanding was that “separate but equal” was good enough. The Brown case was a sociological-legislative decision in that it did not do what judges in theory are supposed to do which is look at the Constitution, look at the statutes, look at what the legislature has done, look at what the legislator’s intent was, look to prior court decisions for guidelines and interpret all of these. It did none of these things. If anything, the case for “separate but equal” was very strong in that there were several preceding decisions backing it up and that the Constitution did not even really mention it. So, what the Supreme Court did was to not look at any of those things. It looked at reports of sociologists, educators, teachers and religious leaders and tried to sense a feeling from the society as a whole that it was time to make a change. They then had to go back and say that the Constitution really says this instead of what we said it stated before. Those types of decisions are supposed to be made by legislators who are voted into office. The legislators wouldn’t do it, so the Supreme Court did.
The problem is that nine men who are appointed for life have this much power and we have little or no control over them. They can be overruled, with great 56 NSA QUARTERLY -CTIVES difficulty, as in the New Deal-Roosevelt era when the Supreme Court ruled all kinds of New Deal legislation unconstitutional. Great political pressure was brought to bear, and the next time around the Supreme Court decided that all those laws were constitutional after all. We have a checks-and-balances system and part of it is not only a division of powers but also a division of chores. Legislating is not one of the chores of the Supreme Court. What’s frightening is the political decisions which go into picking who sits on the Supreme Court — for life. What we need is a Congress that is a little more responsive to the public at large and not just each legislator’s own particular constituency. On the other hand, although the Congress may move slowly, it does move. Abortion, for example, was legalized in Italy, not by the courts, but by the legislature, in response to the people’s will. It took them a long time, but when it happened the majority of the people wanted it. As long as we are going to be a democracy, we don’t want a king or a dictator, even if it’s a benevolent dictator, even if that dictator makes decisions we like, that are good for us.
QUARTERLY: Does law school prepare you for practicing law?
JOHNSON: No. In order to be a good lawyer, you need excellent oratorical skills and writing skills, and because these skills are not mandatory prior to law school, they should be mandatory _in law school. Right now the idea is for a person to just jump in the water to learn how to swim. But if he doesn’t have any guidance, he’s going to probably drown. aS.
You have to be able to think very fast on your feet, not just in the courtroom situation. Your work is usually going to where you have to be able to argue persuasively to bargain or reach any kind of a compromise, Obviously, you have to be able to write. You have to write letters, documents, briefs, and numerous times, your case will be won or lost on the basis of the writing of the brief that is submitted to the court. Law school should prepare a student by developing those skills, Of course, experience out in the real world will develop those skills, but then clients are subjected to your lack of training. Some law students go into a kind of apprenticeship with a large law firm, but not all law firms can afford either the money or the time to do that. But that’s the school’s job, anyway. The only exposure to research in a law library you get is briefly in your first year, as a rule. Then, you are given one memorandum to do and one brief, Considering that when you get out to practice law you will be constantly writing memos and briefs, you need practice beforehand to improve your skills, to get feedback.
RUBENFELD: One of the problems is that many of the professors have never practiced law privately, or at best, very briefly. So, what you get is a lot of young instructors who are into changing the system, having never really seen from the inside how that system works. So, they turn out lots of people with misconceptions about what law is. They : think it’s a lot more glorious and glamorous and idealistic than it really is. There are more clinical programs \ showing up that actually do train people in the practice of law in the real world. Formerly, though, it’s been just reading a lot of books that tell you how terrible eh ee n things are and how badly good idealistic m lawyers are needed. And the classroom 0 in a law school is so divorced from what *, a real law office is. In a law office, e you have constant interruptions, Y constant breaks in your train of thought, u constant bombardment of problems and o unanticipated crises. That’s what it’s 1 really like and the only Way you can be 1 trained for that is to spend some time in > a real law office. Law school trains you ’ to read law books but not to deal with / people — and dealing with people and , their problems is practicing law.
QUARTERLY: Why do we need lawyers? Laws?
HEANEY: If you don’t have laws, the society very quickly degenerates into who is the strongest man, and even the strongest man sleeps. If you have a situation where there is a limited number of a certain kind of goods, you will have people vying for them, so you have to have some sort of rule of distribution. Once you have a rule, you have a law. You have to have organization. The bigger the organization gets, the more formal or organized it has to get. If you have a hundred people trying to get somewhere, you have to form a line, and somebody has to help people form the lines so that everybody gets a fair chance. If you don’t have organization and people who are used to living in an organized fashion and who realize the benefits of cooperating, you have disaster. We are very, very lucky in the United States because we are used to an orderly society.
RENSCH: When I read President Ikeda’s thirty-ninth General Meeting Speech, was really struck by the concept of me to explain why we need lawyers, laws, and courts. This is paraphrasing, but in societal terms, there is harmony or whatever it is that holds things together, and the progressive force which could be likened to science, perhaps, and then there is chutai, the prime point or essence of everything. To me, this explained the need for lawyers in society. They play an important function, in that they supply, or are supposed to supply, the harmony. Even in an ideal world, there will be disputes and misunderstandings. There has to be some way to deal with these. Lawyers will always be needed to be the harmonizers.
QUARTERLY: President Ikeda has stated: “The only organization capable of suppressing or invalidating man’s basic human rights is the state. Even in this case, in free nations, action must be taken in accordance with laws that are established, even if in an indirect way, by the will of the people. The attainment of such freedom is one of mankind’s greatest advances.” Please comment on this.
JOHNSON: To me, this explains how the world is now beginning to treasure human life, at least in some instances, above all else. That has to be the supreme law — that human life is of utmost importance. Society is progressing beyond the dictator-ruler stage, where the people have no say about their own lives. People are now able, in a democracy, to express the way that they feel. This gives man a chance to put human life first, to strive, to have a say in the goals and movement of the world. When you have a government, a ruling body that is answerable to the people ruled, it’s a big step toward respecting the dignity of the individual. The individual now can feel that he has some power to effect change. Because he now has at least some power, he no longer needs to be only reactionary, he can be a 58 NSA QUARTERLY >ECTIVES oo EES catalyst.
McCOY: The state exerts its power to restrict people’s activities and also to guarantee people’s activities only through guidelines set by the will of the people, themselves, through the exercise of their franchise — voting in legislators to represent them. It is truly one of mankind’s greatest advances in that it allows for the greatest good for the greatest number of people. By giving aid to sixty people, as an example, even though forty people are hurt in the process, the whole advances. Also, even the forty people who are hurt are willing to be hurt because they had the freedom to make their input, to have their side heard and weighed in the balance. The great thing is that all the people are able to have their voices heard; all the people have a chance. At the same time, it’s an incredible challenge. Democracies are very fragile institutions. We are very fortunate in this country to have had the pioneer experience at one time. What does it take to run a democracy if not the responsibility of the people, all the people? The pioneer experience forced the people who began this country to be responsible, to take responsibility for their actions and for their lives. One problem we have today is the growing unresponsiveness of the government, the agent of the people’s will. As the government gets larger and heavier, people are shouting but their government isn’t hearing. The agent is not responding, or is responding more slowly, to the will of the people. But it’s not the agent’s fault. You don’t get good government, if you are uninformed and not taking your share of the responsibility. Apathy is the mortal wound to democracy. We have to work at it. We have to pay. You don’t get anything for free — including freedom. □
