Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Winter 1976

News Views

NSA Quarterly, Winter 1976, pp. 138–140. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

“A person may cause evil to others not only by his actions but by his inaction, and in either case he is justly accountable to them for the injury.” (John Stuart Mill: On Liberty, 1859) Where do the roots of violence lie? If people are to win out over violence, they might first ask themselves this question.

Violence may well turn out to be as American as apple pie and motherhood. At least that’s what some recent trends seem to indicate. Among these are:

• A Louis Harris poll showing some 47 per cent of all U.S. households, a total of 17 million, to be “armed to the teeth with guns” in self-defense against a violence they fear may strike at any time.

• Two attempts on President Gerald Ford’s life within a month, and the same Harris poll quoted above showing 74 per cent of the American population safe against a determined assassin.

• An indictment by author Richard Maxwell Brown in his book, Strain of Violence — Historical Studies of American Violence and Vigilantism, that the U.S. has always been a country ready to live by bullets rather than plowshares.

• A statement by the U.S. Attorney General, Edward H. Levi, that “. . . it’s shocking. We have a country which is very tolerant and has been willing to take a degree of lawlessness that’s rather surprising.”

Feeling Powerless

Underlying these observations and sentiments seems to be a feeling, shared by the general public, of powerlessness against violence. In short, people no longer feel safe either in the streets or at home, and, worse, they fear that they can’t trust the country’s leaders to remedy the situation.

Politicians, lawyers, psychologists, sociologists and social critics of every breed have for years debated the causes and cures for the country’s ever-growing violence. Two camps have emerged.

One recurring line of reasoning centers on the idea of crime prevention through swift, sure and severe justice. Another focuses on the nation’s social ills, blaming them for people’s outbursts of violence and saying that the best cure is the improvement of society itself.

This second viewpoint seemed to hold sway throughout the decade of the sixties. Yet, as the Great Society began to take shape — with its war on poverty, on sickness, on inequality, on crime and on many other problem areas — the crime rate and the net destructiveness of violence of all sorts grew even worse.

Tolerance of Violence

This brought about an @qual and opposite reaction, with many of the same liberal thinkers of the sixties shifting their stand and saying that beefing up the court System, bringing more Criminals to trial, and imposing swifter, surer sentences would do the trick. Alas, the waves of violence continued to swell, finally prompting Attorney General Levi to decry the American public’s “tolerance of violence.” Blame for violence had come full circle — back to the victims themselves.

Throughout the ages, perhaps ever since the famed Code of Hammurabi (ruler of Babylon in the 18th century B.C.), man has viewed crime, especially violent crime, as a wrong to be punished. Yet, recent psychological studies have revealed that violence is only one of many possible forms of social conduct, neither right nor wrong in itself, but one which arises in certain individuals who never fully adjust to society’s pressures and demands.

In his work, Violent Men, criminal psychologist Hans H. Toch classifies two types of violent men: “. . . one of these is that of the person who sees other people as tools designed to serve his needs; the second is that of the individual who feels vulnerable to manipulation.”

Dr. Toch says that the use of violence serves these men because it works — it gets the results they want in situations where nothing else ever seemed to work. It gives them a feeling of importance, of manhood, of social recognition, and it resolves the doubts gnawing at their minds.

The common denominator of violent men, he says, is their low self-esteem. Violence is the one method which seems capable of raising their image not only of themselves but before their fellow men as well.

Dr. Toch, a Princeton graduate, scoffs at the idea that imprisoning people like these can ever reform their violent-prone natures. He says:

“Violence feeds on low self-esteem and self-doubt, and prison unmans and dehumanizes; violence rests on exploitation and exploitiveness, and prison is a power-centered jungle. It is true that we try to teach inmates that the use of force can only produce more difficulty for them, but we make the lesson far from convincing. If a man harms others in a prison, where else can he go? What extremity of discouragement can we furnish him? Many of our interviewees (all inmates) preceded their discussions of particularly vicious acts with the declaration, ‘What the hell, I had nothing to lose!’ ”

Violence is Short-sighted

A violent man values his actions only in terms of their effects on his ego, not in terms of his future well-being. In other words, violence is short-sighted. By putting violent men in prison, we are only further degrading them and damning their role in society, Dr. Toch claims. Rather, he says, we should approach them with respect for their manhood and then teach them how to play society’s “games” the way everyone else plays them, according to non-violent rules.

Of course, Dr. Toch’s analysis does little to help the underlying causes of violence; it deals with people who have already displayed their violence. In truth, there is a little violence in everyone, but few of us ever go to great extremes. We are content with merely raising our voices, or making threats, or venting our violence through other means. Yet, taken as a whole, this “little violence in everyone” adds up to commonplace, ugly things like racial hatred and war.

As American as Apple Pie

So, in a discussion of violence, everyone is right and everyone is wrong. Violence may be as American as apple pie and motherhood, but it is also as Russian as caviar and vodka, as Japanese as chopsticks and sukiyaki. It’s common to all of us; in fact, it’s a part of the human personality that we alternately shudder at or take delight in.

Though people seem more and more worried about the rising waves of violence in America, society as a whole appears to be moving away from the barbaric concept of “an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth,” and toward a definition of violence which may ultimately lead to concrete solutions. This may not satisfy the 17 million garrisoned households, but at least it paves the way for a lasting era of peace and universal harmony.

[The Code of Hammurabi, engraved in limestone relief, is one of the first codifications of law still in existence. Times have changed since then, however, as man moves toward a more humanistic definition of justice aimed at helping people turn their aggressive instincts toward more normal and constructive social pursuits.]