Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Summer 1973 · Life-philosophy Concepts

Three Proofs

NSA Quarterly, Summer 1973, pp. 30–35. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

It is often asked exactly how Nichiren Shoshu differs from other religions. Specifically, we will examine here the criteria for a true religion and the process by which religion spreads according to the needs and conditions of the people.

Belief is a hard thing to adhere to in our ume. Staggering changes are taking place in the human community and more people are questioning what were, until now, commonly accepted attitudes about life and its values. Change has brought with it a condition called “future shock” in which a generation of youth has come to reconsider its direction. At the same time, all of us continue to live under the spectre of imminent destruction created by the menace of nuclear weapons. No wonder that ours is a time of skepticism and doubt.

Many individuals are now finding in NSA a philosophy which stands up to all doubt and scrutiny. It is a workable philosophy allowing people to challenge and seek answers to all doubts. Not only is this questioning mind essential to the practice of Buddhism, but an) religion that avoids proving its doctrine, theory and practice is opposed to the true questioning nature of man. On the other hand, by evaluating religion according to three proofs, we have an excellent means for exercising this questioning nature. The three proofs offers a standard for gauging the quality of a religion. Here are three levels at which a philosophy can be evaluated. The first concerns the documented ideals of the religion; the second evaluates religious content according to the rational and scientific worth of its theory, and the third actually specifies whether or not the theory can be applied to real life situations.

Literal Proof

Basically, literal proof refers to the kind of literature or writing the philosophy is based upon. Sages of the past, such as Sakyamuni, Christ or Mohammed became enlightened and then started teaching their realizations to others. The legacy of their teachings was passed on through the Buddhist sutras, the Christian Bible or the Islamic Koran. In other words, this is the literal proof of these various philosophers and the religions they expounded. Whether or not such writings exist is one criterion of judgment.

The most certain way to transmit a religion from one person to another is by written language. Documents which are authored by the founder of a religion offer everyone the opportunity to compare it with another faith and determine which religion is superior. Without accurate documentation, there is no basis for comparison. Writings distinguish a teaching of general importance from mere personal philosophy.

Theoretical Proof

In the process of passing ona particular thought, those who transmit it may blur the original ideas with interpretations of their own, thus distorting the entire system of the philosophy. Such errors, compounded over centuries, will result in an extensive change in the basic doctrine.

Teachings which lack proof of their relation to original doctrines tend to become dogmatic.

Nichiren Daishonin’s Gosho — a collection of letters to disciples — is used as the basic written document of the sect. These writings come directly from the Daishonin and as such, represent no misinterpretation on the part of his disciples. It is possible to read his exact words today, the legacy of true Buddhism in its purest form thus assured.

Religion deals with life, which is an entity that cannot be approached strictly by physical or scientific means. A spiritual or mystic approach which lacks a basis in cause and effect reasoning cannot prove the validity of a religion. For centuries, the church in Europe waged a war of persecution against scientists and scholars as a means of defense. Eventually, light was cast upon its illogical views of life and the universe.

The Buddhist teachings state, If there is neither document nor logic, one should not believe. Who could disagree with this rational attitude?

Nichiren Daishonin stated, Buddhism is reason. Reason will win over one’s sovereign. A true religion cannot be influenced by the support or opposition of authority. It does not depend upon fashionable trends or public taste. Its truth is determined by the ability of its doctrine to withstand any criticism and its power to uplift believers to the highest condition of life.

Theoretical proof asks, “Does the doctrine of a religion have a theory which is logical and universal?” Universal means that a religion should be valid in all cases, yielding positive results to all people. Buddhism locates the universal need of man for individual happiness and the peace and harmony of society.

In everything he does man seeks happiness. I homas Jefferson wrote of the “pursuit of happiness” and his observation has proven true because it applies to a universal fact about human nature. Religion should aid man in his universal quest for happiness. 1 PO a Deka I piness. We see in history, however, that religion, in general, has made unreasonable assertions of some extra-human force or heavenly protector. Such unrealistic ideas have eased people away from the difficult realities of living in the world. Today, as always, comforting images do not furnish man with the energy, wisdom and good fortune to fulfill his universal need for creating happiness and building a community of harmony.

Unrealistic religions arose in pre-scientific times when it was possible for man to believe in them. Though established 700 years ago, the philosophy of Nichiren Daishonin is not contradicted by the findings of science. In fact, Buddhism is a science of life probing the entity of life within each person, which exists eternally along with the universe. Physics and chemistry are approaching this supreme truth of human life.

Actual Proof

Actual proof is the last and most important of the three proofs. It refers to observing the outcome of religious belief and comparing religions according to their results. If the result is in line with the theory, then the religion may be considered valid. Something is wrong if religious practice does not yield actual result.

Nichiren Daishonin said, J, Nichiren, conclude from my own experiences in Buddhism, that literal and theoretical proofs are vital factors to judge religions, but actual proof is far superior to both

The righteousness of a religion cannot be limited to a theoretical plane alone. The elements of religious practice and its results deserve more attention. Naturally, the results must substantiate the theory, for if there is no explanation

Science is highly respected because it backs up its logical, theoretical system with experimentation. For a theory to be considered valid, experiments with it must offer the same proof no matter how many times or under what conditions they may be repeated. Natural sciences such as physics and chemistry go to great lengths to produce substantial evidence. If a religion that purports to explain life cannot equal this effort to supply proof in daily usage, It is of no worth.

Almost all religions promise happiness. The validity of their ideas is reflected in the lives of the believers. The obvious happiness of Nichiren Shoshu members is being spread to others the world over, and this, in itself, is proof of the philosophy’s value. Moreover, an observation of the life of each individual reveals a ttemendous revolution of character taking place, in addition to tangibly better living situations. In contrast with traditional religions or some of the hastily formed modern-day creeds, the overwhelming joy of Nichiren Shoshu believers is an undeniable verification of this life-philosophy’s effectiveness in shaping modern life. This joy is the end result of a philosophy that has literal, theoretical and, most important, eee TS 2

Captions and notes

as to how such things occur, a philosophy must stoop to the level of mysticism. actual proof.