The Ten Worlds
Section I: Perceiving the Transient Nature of Phenomena
NSA Quarterly, Spring 1977, pp. 6–20. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
An In-Depth Explanation and Analysis of Application. Based on a feature originally appearing in the November, 1974 Daibyakurenge.
Section I: Perceiving the Transient Nature of Phenomena
The Shisei and the Rokudo
We call Buddhism a philosophy of life. The first step toward understanding this philosophy — indeed, life itself — is grasping the theory known as the ten worlds. This theory holds that life has a range of expression, depending on the time, environment, or a multitude of other circumstances. Our emotions and actions fall into ten distinct patterns.
From moment to moment, our state of life, both feeling and behavior, fits any one of ten categories: jigoku (hell), gaki (hunger), chikusho (animality), shura (anger), nin (tranquility), ten (rapture), shomon (learning), engaku (absorption), bosatsu (Bodhisattva), and butsu (Buddhahood).
The concept of the ten worlds has not always been properly clarified. For instance, they have sometimes been thought of as a theory relevant only to the Buddhist philosophy, or they have been simplified to cartoon caricatures of human emotion.
Our purpose here is not only to rectify previous misconceptions. This discussion of the ten worlds will begin from the premise that the reader already has a basic understanding of Buddhism. For this reason, we will stick basically to the Japanese word for each of the ten worlds.
The idea of ten worlds really expounds ten totally different conditions of life. There is a very essential difference between the first six worlds known as rokudo (the lower six paths) and the last four known as shisei (the upper four worlds). Understanding the differences will allow us to apply the theory to the realities of living.
Each of the ten worlds has its own unique character and flavor. However, depending on the viewpoint, there are two distinctions that can be made about all of them. The first is to divide the lower nine from the tenth world. This division must be defined as a distinction, not as an exclusion. The world of Buddhahood is something that incorporates and yet exists within each of the lower nine worlds. That may seem like a paradox. However, the only way to understand Buddhahood is to realize that it both transcends and yet permeates the first nine worlds. It is different, but not separate. The terms used to describe these concepts are bukkai soku kyukai (Buddhahood equals the nine worlds) and kyukai soku bukkai (the nine worlds equal Buddhahood).
The other distinction that we make, as mentioned before, is the separation between the rokudo and the shisei. A passage from the “Kanjin-no Honzon Sho” deals with the ten worlds when divided in this manner:
When you look at people, they sometimes are enjoying themselves, sometimes are angry, sometimes are tranquil. At other times they are hungry, still at others are foolish, and at others appear twisted or warped. To experience unreasoning The Ten Worlds anger is to be in jigoku; to be hungry is to be in gaki; to be foolish is chikusho; to be warped or twisted is shura; to enjoy oneself is ten; to be tranquil is nin. All of these six worlds are inherent in people. However, a close examination reveals that the four supreme life-conditions, although usually dormant, are still within their lives.
In the continuation of this Gosho passage, the Daishonin dealt with the three worlds of shomon, engaku, and bosatsu, while expounding the fact that Buddhahood is the rarest condition. He said:
The idea of the inherent rokudo may not be immediately clear; however, if explained in this way [previous passage] it seems that we ourselves possess these six paths; why, however, can we not perceive the four supreme life-conditions within ourselves? To answer — you at first doubted that people (in the world of nin) possess the lower six paths, but since I explained it to you by citing an actual example to correspond to each life-condition, you have come to basically understand it. For these reasons, I try to explain things reasonably. When you look at the world, you immediately notice that everything changes from moment to moment. Doesn’t the fact that you perceive this transience mean that the life-conditions of the two vehicles (shomon and engaku) are within the world of nin? Even the most wicked man who never empathizes with others still loves his wife and children. This indicates that even he possesses the life-condition of Bodhisattva. Only Buddhahood is hard to manifest, but don’t doubt that you possess it as long as you have the other nine worlds. The Lotus Sutra refers to the world of nin in the phrase “The Buddha makes his advent in this world to help people to tap the wisdom of Buddhahood.” The Nirvana Sutra reads, “The physical eyes of those who study Mahayana Buddhism are named the eyes of the Buddha.” The reason why people are born as human beings in Mappo and are able to believe in the Lotus Sutra is that Buddhahood is inherently possessed in the world of nin.
In this way, the Daishonin explained the six lower paths which manifest themselves in daily life and the four supreme worlds which, for the most part, remain dormant. Nevertheless, he was pointing out that close examination of people who exist on the lower six levels will reveal they still can experience the upper four.
As this quotation indicates, in the ten worlds there is a fundamental difference between the lower six paths and the upper four worlds. Furthermore, the worlds of shomon, engaku, and bosatsu are markedly different from the final world of Buddhahood.
The philosophy of the ten worlds was not completely revealed until the Lotus Sutra, which explained them in the Hiyu chapter with the parable of the burning mansion. While not going into this parable in detail, the burning mansion can be likened to our daily lives or, specifically, the lower six paths in which we pursue the majority of our daily activities. The children in the parable, who play without noticing the fire, symbolize ignorant and passive tendencies that lead to repetitious suffering in the cycles of the rokudo. They are never aware of their basic problem.
The father in the story offers three vehicles to the children to carry them away from the fire; these carts are led by a sheep, a deer, and an ox, signifying the three worlds of shomon, engaku, and bosatsu. However, only when the father gives the children a daibyakugosha — cart led by a great white ox symbolizing Buddhahood — will they leave the scene of the fire. This whole parable implies that the purpose of the Buddha is to give his children — people everywhere — enlightenment.
Questions involving the difference between the rokudo and the shisei also apply to the distinction between the lower nine worlds and Buddhahood. From the standpoint of Buddhahood, all of the nine worlds, including shomon, engaku, and bosatsu, are dark and unenlightened conditions of life. Nevertheless, there must be some meaningful reason for classifying the ten worlds into the rokudo and the shisei. It’s easy to see why the four lower worlds, also known as the four evil paths, are not the final goal in life. However, the reasons for denying the worlds of nin and ten as final goals are vague. Nevertheless, Buddhism vigorously condemns these as final goals.
Basically, the rokudo are passive emotional states. They are reactions, not the product of an individual’s own efforts. For instance, look at the world of nin. We feel tranquil only when surrounded by love or when guaranteed the protection of a secure environment. Let that environment change suddenly, and our life plummets into the lower four worlds. We have no control.
We may experience rapture when our desires are fulfilled or when others praise us. However, this life-condition too is totally dependent on our environment. Simply stated: The essential character of the lower six worlds is marked by dependence on the environment.
Freeing Ourselves from the Rokudo
Why does dependence on the environment automatically imply ignorance or lack of enlightenment? The answer lies in the constant state of flux in our environment. The world is wholly unstable, and if our emotions and actions are at the whim of changing phenomena, then our life itself must be considered transient and passive.
Adherence to transient phenomena, or dependence on them for our happiness, is the cause of all suffering. Money, political power, or fame are not permanent. They can perish at the slightest quirk of luck. Even if you manage to hold on to riches or position, they are not absolute because death takes all. As long as we are unable to grapple with death, any external source of happiness is transient.
Buddhism encourages us to look at the changing realities of life and the world we live in. It exhorts us to seek out a source of indestructible happiness within our own lives. The previous quotation from the “Kanjin-no Honzon Sho” deals in part with the “transient phenomena in front of your eyes.” It is a lesson to develop eyes with which we can perceive the law operating behind continually fluctuating phenomena. That law never changes, even though the phenomena do.
Once we are immune to fluctuation in the environment, we don’t waste time with the transient aspects of reality. We become free to deal with things objectively. Such insight frees us from the rokudo. This is the first step from dependence toward human revolution.
Even the conditions of nijo, the two vehicles of shomon and engaku, are only a first step toward Buddhahood, and, in themselves, are not ultimate goals. They are voluntary states, so it can be said that they free one from the darkness of the rokudo. Nevertheless, the Buddha denounced them severely as ends in themselves. He even went so far as to say that shomon and engaku are inferior to the worlds of jigoku, gaki, and chikusho. This is because of the inclination for conceit in these worlds. Anyone who is proud of what he knows is silly and conceited. Nobody knows everything, so it is an exercise in selfishness to revel in your own awareness.
In other words, awareness of the transience of worldly phenomena does not in itself produce a constructive attitude. Awareness draws its own limited frame of reference and rarely The Ten Worlds serves as a springboard to enlightenment.
The ability to perceive something changeless and eternal in the changing phenomena of reality is vital to overcome the inherent shortcomings of the nijo. So, it is apparent why it is necessary to tap the world of Bodhisattva within.
Bodhisattva is the function of life whereby one embraces the Buddha’s teaching, puts it into action and proceeds to lead others to happiness. In Buddhism, a Bodhisattva is defined as one who serves as a messenger of the Buddha. The essence of Buddhism is the inner life of the Bodhisattva, for it serves as a steppingstone to the condition of Buddhahood.
We have no choice but to thrust ourselves in among those who exist in the rokudo, We cannot impart happiness to people if we harbor feelings of superiority. Therefore, a strong and vital life force is essential if we are to avoid being trapped in the rokudo ourselves.
The question then becomes one of maintaining a strong life force while in the rokudo. We must, therefore, tap the Buddhahood within ourselves. Buddhism teaches us never to separate ourselves from the transience of the six lower paths. It only instructs us to free ourselves from adherence to that transience. As a matter of fact, the sole reason for the discussion of transience in Buddhism is so that we can learn to judge the reality or true aspect of those phenomena.
Buddhism propounds a changeless and permanent law which underlies the transient world. It is a law which controls and unifies all changing phenomena. Awareness of this law can thwart the nihilistic tendencies of the nijo.
Being a Bodhisattva means to encompass the transient phenomena but also to understand the law of the universe. Then an individual is the ultimate reflection of the shisei. Therefore, the shisei are not distinct or above the rokudo. The rokudo are, in fact, the ¢ reality of our daily life. The question then becomes whether or not we are in control of the rokudo. This is determined by our ability to establish the shisei from within.
Simply put — there can be no real distinctions. The six paths are not always the six paths; the four supreme life-conditions are not always the four supreme life-conditions. The true value of shisei manifests itself in the rokudo.
The key is this: Nam-myoho-renge-kyo is the law of the universe. By chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, we acquire the strength to elevate our life-condition. Leading a life based on wisdom and courage, we become able to enjoy our daily lives in the realm of individuals finding true happiness.
Section II: The Modern Meaning of Nijo: Shomon and Engaku
The History of the Two Vehicles
Nijo, as discussed in the previous section, comprises the worlds of shomon and engaku. It is no exaggeration to say that much of the history of Buddhism has developed through efforts to interpret and understand these two worlds. The ideas involved are best exemplified in the distinction between Hinayana and Mahayana Buddhism.
Mahayana Buddhism criticizes Hinayana Buddhism as the teaching of the nijo. Mahayana is considered to be a teaching of the world of bosatsu, whereas Hinayana stems from the worlds of shomon and engaku. Actually, the evolution of Mahayana from Hinayana can be traced to a growing criticism of the nijo. This means that nijo played a profound role in describing the meaning of enlightenment and prescribing the way of life for Buddhism. Ultimately, such description and prescription could not stand the test of time as men delved deeper into the true meaning of Buddhism.
Let’s examine the worlds of shomon and engaku. Shomon literally means people who become enlightened by hearing the teachings of the Buddha. Originally, shomon were considered to be disciples of Sakyamuni.
Engaku refers to people who enlighten themselves through perception in relation to their environment. Such people are called dokkaku (self-realized sages). Specifically, there are two kinds of engaku. The first go one step beyond the shomon who listen to the teachings of the Buddha and accept these as truth. They use these same teachings as a catalyst for their own self-awareness and attain enlightenment. They are called bugyo dokkaku.
The second kind of engaku become enlightened through perceiving their environment in a world where the Buddha does not exist. They are called rinyu dokkaku.
The concepts of shomon and engaku evolved as answers to the problem of how to transmit the teachings of Sakyamuni’s enlightenment. Sakyamuni himself was said to have attained enlightenment by perceiving the law of cause and effect while meditating under a bodhi (fig) tree. His enlightenment was considered to be a process of engaku.
After his enlightenment, Sakyamuni considered his perception of the law of cause and effect to be something too difficult for the average person to comprehend. At that point in time, he decided not to teach the general population his enlightened teachings.
The story then goes that the Buddhist god Bonten appeared to Sakyamuni and said, “If you don’t teach the law, the people will never be saved from the depths of their misery, even though the Buddha’s teachings may be too difficult for them to understand. They may, however, be able to understand if taught in the proper manner. Please teach people the law.” Sakyamuni decided to reveal his insights and began the lecturing that was to continue the rest of his life.
Nijo, as mentioned previously, implies awakening to one’s subjective identity, recognizing the root causes of one’s suffering, i.e. adherence to the rokudo, and taking steps toward overcoming that suffering. That is the rationale for dividing the ten worlds into the two segments of the rokudo and the shisei.
In any event, shomon and engaku were first taught as the two paths for attaining enlightenment. They were considered examples of the proper way to live. In this sense, nijo were meant purely as a first step toward the awakening of oneself, Sakyamuni himself later went on to refute them and propound the way of the Bodhisattva. This seems quite natural when we reexamine the anecdote of Sakyamuni’s own enlightenment.
In this anecdote, the Buddhist god Bonten might be viewed as a function of social consciousness. Therefore the fact that Bonten talked Sakyamuni_ into revealing his enlightenment symbolized Sakyamuni’s awakening to obligations and responsibilities to his fellow man. Remaining with the worlds of nijo, which provided him merely with the source of his enlightenment, would have been both foolish and selfish. To that end, Sakyamuni was very severe in his The Ten Worlds later denunciation of nijo. At times he told people of nijo that it would be next to impossible for them to attain enlightenment and often proclaimed they could never reach it.
The distinction between the worlds of nijo and that of Bodhisattva lies in the motivation involved. Nijo is a condition which essentially pursues enlightenment out of self-interest, while Bodhisattva pursues it from a spirit of selflessness and altruism. Naturally, the nijo have very definite positive aspects. These, however, are not enough. Basically, in nijo, doing good for others is limited to transmitting one’s own ideas to someone else. On the other hand, the world of Bodhisattva is concerned with teaching others a way in which they, as unique individuals, can benefit themselves. By definition, to a Bodhisattva, there can be no self-realization without the effort to help others.
The Refutation of Nijo
The differences between nijo and Bodhisattva are further manifest in their respective practice. The practice of nijo is far more introspective and meditative, while the practice of Bodhisattva is rooted in social activities. The two approaches lead us to question whether or not the human being is considered a social being.
Buddhism adheres to the view of the human as a social being. The refutation of nijo signifies Buddhism’s steadfast stand against a limited concept of self and toward a reawakening social awareness and responsibility. The world of Bodhisattva is an important assumption that shapes the methods and goals of Buddhist practice.
The Buddhist refutation of nijo presents many lessons for modern society. Modern people in those worlds have been variously categorized as scholars or artists or men of letters. On one hand, it has become socially fashionable to denounce men who live in ivory towers. Some learned men do indeed expound the notion that their study is life’s ultimate objective or that their art is the manifestation of life’s highest goals. On the other hand, many are very involved with and very concerned about the mainstream of life_
The solution lies in a balance between the two approaches. It is obvious that a human being is both a subjective entity and a social animal. This can not be denied. Subjectivity is essential in the world of art, education, or any number of creative fields. People derive great satisfaction through their achievements in their chosen fields. However, if such people do not become awakened to themselves as social beings, their ultimate achievements — indeed, their enlightenment — cannot be attained.
Pieces of art or scholarly works in and of themselves may have a certain degree of value. However, this value is of little use if those who created it cannot themselves find happiness in their everyday lives, families, or society.
Buddhism ultimately exists for the individual’s happiness, and if a human being has an understanding of himself as a social entity, then that person should realize that his own happiness is tied to that of others. Therefore, our own salvation together with that of others has equal significance. Herein lies the importance of Buddhism as a means of bringing happiness to all people. As long as the ultimate goal of Buddhism is framed in terms of bringing salvation to each individual, the true value of activities carried out in the fields of art and education lies in the development of the individuals carrying out those activities, not in the activities themselves. Achievements which contribute to the development of human character are those which have true meaning.
Currently, how do we tend to evaluate philosophers? The standards for evaluating thinkers like Kant or Hegel ultimately stem from the record of their achievements. If a man’s accomplishments in the field of study are considered superior, he is evaluated as a man of great character, and his name goes down in history. The development of his own character and happiness is not taken into consideration at all.
Buddhism, on the other hand, takes a totally different standpoint. The teachings of Sakyamuni have not been evaluated merely from the standpoint of their superiority over other religions. They are evaluated from the standpoint of Sakyamuni’s personality as well.
This is a very significant point in the practice of Buddhism. In recent years, attempts have been made to evaluate the teachings of Sakyamuni through a strictly rational method. However, these teachings do not lend themselves to evaluation based only on theoretical superiority or uniqueness. The same holds true for the study of Nichiren Daishonin’s Buddhism.
If we read the Gosho with an eye toward theory only, we will never understand true Buddhism. Instead, we have to sense the personality and life-condition of the Daishonin as he framed the words of the Gosho. The words are symbols for his heart and mind. We should grasp his life-condition and practice from this understanding.
True Buddhism is great because the teachings were materialized in the Daishonin’s personality. For us, Buddhism can only take on meaning through individual human revolution. The total revolution of our character and personality cannot be discussed without the realization that we are all related to one another as constituents of society.
The refutation of nijo becomes a criticism of rationalism and knowledge as ends in themselves. That alone should give Buddhism some credence in modern society.
In order for us to grasp the different conditions or worlds, it is necessary to view them all from the highest level as described in the Lotus Sutra. This is the world of Buddhahood.
Let’s take a look at the world of the Buddha as a creative entity. The ultimate goal of Buddhism as a philosophy is complete self-awareness. The subjective self which develops through the worlds of nijo and the social self which manifests itself in the life of the Bodhisattva are still not sufficient.
In order to establish true values within human life, the existence of the Buddha as a creative entity is essential. Buddhahood can be a compass and a map to the subjective and social worlds of shomon, engaku, and bosatsu. This is the real meaning of the world of Buddha. With this creative force of the Buddha as their basis, people of nijo can be productive. A person can then confront reality, deal with problems and crises, and constructively undertake a reformation of both his thought and action.
When this spirit of constructive and creative criticism takes the forefront of society, we will see the dawn of what President Ikeda calls the “total revolution.” The power of nijo can be so great as to expose the mistakes of those who would pursue the worlds of shomon and engaku as final ends — arrogant intellectuals, artists, people of tremendous creative ability who would, through conceit and arrogance, misdirect their talents and demean their fellow man. Herein lies the modern meaning of nijo. Those who would guide shomon and engaku by the creative source of the Buddha have the power to uplift all of civilization; those who would pursue nijo as an ultimate goal harbor the potential seeds of man’s destruction.
Section III: The Ninth World — Morality in the Buddhist Practice
Challenging Our Ego
It is said that there are four desires (shigu seigan), almost like pledges, common to those in the world of bosatsu. They are:
(1) To give happiness to immeasurable multitudes of people,
(2) To rid themselves of countless earthly desires,
(3) To comprehend the infinite mystery of the universe,
(4) To attain the life-condition of limitless enlightenment.
It is obvious that those in the world of bosatsu have quite a job. It would seem that any one of these four is almost beyond the power of mortals. However, all this serves to prove is that in Buddhism, there are no limits. When we attempt to elevate our life-condition, we find that there is no boundary to our potential. Nevertheless, as ordinary people we often experience what we consider to be a deadlock.
One thing we should understand in examining the four desires of the bosatsu is that they stem from the original teachings of the ancient Bodhisattvas who practiced austerities. Those Bodhisattvas enumerated desires that seemed impossible in order to motivate themselves to carry on a program of rigid self-denial,
Transient Bodhisattvas appear in the first fourteen chapters [shakumon] of the Lotus Sutra, set high goals for themselves, and practice austerities. However, the jiyu-no bosatsu (Bodhisattvas of the Earth), who appear for the first time in the fifteenth chapter [honmon], need only chant Nammyoho-renge-kyo to attain enlightenment. Both methods symbolize the difficulty of reaching enlightenment. However, the practice of chanting is not an austerity. The concept of austerity is of little value in modern times.
The first pledge refers to practice for others. Priority is put on this rather than on practice for ourselves. We find that, to really benefit ourselves, an altruistic practice is a must. It is the fastest way to attain self-perfection. This is referred to as keta.
We find the core of humanism in the four desires of bosatsu. Practicing to help others is the surest way to. attain enlightenment. The effort of really helping others is proof that we are transforming those unenlightened aspects within ourselves.
Does all this seem austere? In one sense it is, because the four desires of the Bodhisattva don’t allow us to be complacent. We never arrive at a point where everything is okay. As soon as we accomplish one thing, we should feel impelled to move on to the next. This is the spirit of hon’nin-myo. Having this spirit determines the speed with which we can accomplish human revolution.
We find more and more people interested in the Buddhist teachings. Perhaps they are becoming aware of the rampant egoism in today’s world and can understand the concept of the world of bosatsu as a solution. Perhaps the ideals of humanism and self-perfection promote unconscious desire for a better human condition.
As jiyu-no bosatsu, we should understand that the four desires of the Bodhisattva are completely different from the desires of the transient Bodhisattvas who followed Sakyamuni. They could never really attain complete enlightenment. Our basic life-condition is totally different. Chanting Nammyoho-renge-kyo is the key to our enlightenment, so there is a special way in which we should consider the four desires. We need to learn to apply them to our daily lives. The transient Bodhisattvas were thinking only of themselves and exploited the four desires as a source of intellectual stimulation and motivation. We need to actualize the four desires as a solid foundation for our lives.
What does this mean to us as individuals? The Gosho reads, “The tenth world of Buddhahood reveals itself in the four desires of bosatsu. Buddhahood is not some far off or fixed goal. It lies in our actions to fulfill the four desires.” Nikkan Shonin said, “Strong faith in the Lotus Sutra means Buddhahood.” Our sincere efforts to realize the four desires will simultaneously strengthen our faith toward the Gohonzon.
In this sense, the commandments which we follow stem from our voluntary spirit to develop a true humanistic morality. This is the only way to understand the concept of commandment. The four desires are not meant to be commandments, but spontaneous inclinations. We can never be forced to pursue them. They are necessary, however, if we are to ever learn how to challenge ourselves. Our practice might well be said to be lacking if we are missing any one of the four desires. However, if we find that these are well harmonized within ourselves, we can be assured of the greatest possible growth and happiness.
Hon’nin-myo Spirit and the Four Desires
Let’s now take a look at the four desires in terms of everyday practice. First, “To give happiness to immeasurable multitudes of people” implies a desire to accomplish kosen-rufu. At the same time, it requires the development of a merciful and selfless personality. The hon’nin-myo determination to do what we can for people is built with our connection to the Gohonzon. Discussion meetings are like fertile soil which nourishes this determination.
This practice of keta is integrally tied in with the second pledge of the Bodhisattva, “To rid themselves of countless earthly desires.” This refers to our determination to conquer each of our earthly desires and wipe away the illusions which confuse us. We do not aim at the annihilation of our desires; we learn how to change and channel desires toward enlightenment. Buddhism calls this concept bon’no soku bodai (desires equal enlightenment).
Our attachments can be classified into two categories. First are the multitudes of illusions in our communication. For instance, in practicing Shakubuku we may feel that we cannot make our feelings understood and tend to get angry. The result might be an argument. We should understand that as jiyu-no bosatsu, we need to live among common people and, as a result, problems arise unexpectedly.
We must not be shaken by environmental circumstances. The Gosho says, “A Bodhisattva is one who, among people of the lower six worlds, slights himself, values others, takes evil unto himself, and gives good to others.” This should be our spirit — to take on other people’s problems so they can be happy. The courage or guts to pursue this kind of attitude is what is meant by the second pledge of the Bodhisattva.
The second category of attachments deals with a challenge to our own egoism. This emerges most easily when we are practicing for others. The central theme inherent in the second pledge is guarding against the fundamental ignorance or darkness [gampon-no mumyo] within our own lives. The reverse side of our determination to give happiness to others is that, after a certain amount of effort, things may seem okay and we The Ten Worlds may feel like we don’t need to practice very hard. In this case, we are blind. These symptoms should serve as a catalyst to redirect us toward the Gohonzon. This is not to say that we can never relax or feel happy about what we have done. It is another way of emphasizing the importance of the hon’nin-myo spirit and the necessity of polishing our wisdom with the Gohonzon in order to consistently perceive through our illusions to the reality of our lives.
If the first pledge is considered a way of developing mercy and the second seen as a way of manifesting wisdom, then the third pledge directs us to seek out all forms of knowledge. This implies the study of true Buddhism and also a growing awareness of politics, economics, science, sociology, and all realms of human affairs.
Knowledge is essential if we are to be able to communicate with all people and also expand our own limited perceptions. The study of true Buddhism, coupled with expanding knowledge in other fields, builds the kind of confidence that will truly attract people to Nichiren Daishonin’s life-philosophy. A wide spectrum of understanding provides a gateway to the future and fundamental insight into the basic illusions of life.
The Buddha has sometimes been defined as “one who knows everything.” Buddhism should not alienate us from society; rather, we should learn how to apply everything we know within society. However, we need to keep firmly in mind that the acquisition of knowledge, in itself, is not the goal. Knowledge is meaningful only when it employs the mercy of the first pledge and the wisdom of the second. We utilize our study to give happiness to others and to demonstrate the wisdom within.
In Hinayana Buddhism, gaining knowledge for its own sake became an ultimate goal. The knowledge was not translated into application nor was it used to change the course of one’s life. We should avoid this Pitfall. Our determination to gain knowledge should only stem from another deeper deter mination to help people and eliminate our earthly, misleading desires.
This brings us to the fourth and final pledge of the Bodhisattva — the endless pursuit of our own human revolution. We are attaining our enlightenment as we accomplish the first three determinations. The fourth desire is a natural outgrowth of the first three. Fulfilling the first three leads to the fourth, while desiring the fourth leads to a stronger fulfillment of the first three. This is the ideal harmony of Buddhist practice. It is the prime point of our day-to-day mission as jiyu-no bosatsu. If we reflect on our daily practice in relation to the four desires of bosatsu, we can move forward with total confidence that Nichiren Daishonin’s true Buddhism does indeed have universal applicability.
Section IV: The World of Buddhahood
Approach from the World of Bodhisattva
First, we will discuss here the basic attitudes of Buddhism toward the world of Buddhahood. Then we will analyze the reasons for viewing the world of Buddhahood from the aspects of Bodhisattva, specifically Bodhisattvas of the Earth. Finally, we will discuss the four virtues of jo, raku, ga, and jo.
President Ikeda writes, “Only by bringing forth the world of Buddhahood is one’s change of destiny or escape from unhappiness possible.” Referring to this sentence, one newspaperman said that it applies to a group of people who understand the fact that their lives and the universe are one. However, this seems to be too loose an interpretation.
The original meaning of “bringing forth Buddhahood” is to bring out the Buddha nature inherent in everyone’s life. However, what practical significance does this have? It is the fundamental question, not only for non-Buddhists, but for Buddhists as well. It is extremely difficult to comprehend the meaning of Buddhahood.
For example, in the sutra, which supposedly teaches us to attain enlightenment, there is nothing at all which describes the state of Buddhahood. In fact, it appears as though the sutra is intentionally avoiding a definition. In the “Sokanmon Sho,” the Daishonin states, “Goodness and evil, pure and impure, common mortals and saints, heaven and earth, big and small, east and west, south and north, up and down: Buddhahood is far beyond the description of these aspects.” Buddhahood is a condition which cannot be verbalized or grasped through meditation. Vasabandhu states in his work, Churon, something like this, when he says, “Buddhahood cannot be explained in words. It is beyond meditation or any other sort of description. This is the true aspect of Buddhahood.”
In other words, it is only possible to perceive the condition of Buddhahood through one’s experience in the Buddhist practice. This is a basic corollary of Buddhism. President Toda’s enlightenment was motivated by the thirty-four negations in the Muryogi Sutra [see article on Chudo], further exemplifying this corollary.
It has been said that the cognitive process begins with intuition and proceeds to perception, judgment, and finally inference. The reverse is also possible. The “Kanjin-no Honzon Sho”
states, “However hard Buddhahood is to realize, you should believe in it from the fact that you possess the nine worlds.” It also states in the “Sokanmon Sho,” “Through words spoken in one’s dreams, the true heart is revealed. Therefore, even though the words spoken in dreams may only be words, they reveal one’s true heart.” This means that through words spoken in the dream of our continuously changing existence, the true meaning of the world of enlightenment is taught. From this premise let’s elaborate on the meaning of Buddhahood.
There are certain principles, such as sanju niso and hachiji shuko (thirty-two aspects and eighty attributes), which serve to explain the character of the Buddha, his ten different names, or his function and personality. Here, however, we will stick with a discussion of Buddhahood through the meaning of the world of Bodhisattva.
The Daishonin’s oral teachings (Ongi Kuden) on “jiga gyu shu so” from the Juryo chapter of the Lotus Sutra state, “Ga means Sakyamuni; gyu means Bodhisattva.” The word gyu generally expresses the idea of connecting one thing to another. In other words, the world of Bodhisattva is a link between the nine worlds and Buddhahood. Therefore, discussing the meaning of Bodhisattva is like tuning in a television through which we can view the landscapes of Buddhahood.
Buddhahood is a world attained through one’s experiences and constitutes the internal objective for those seeking their enlightenment. In other words, the Buddha is one who has attained enlightenment. Those still seeking Buddhahood are not enlightened yet. However, the world of Bodhisattva is the highest condition among those who are not yet enlightened; nevertheless, the Bodhisattva too is seeking enlightenment. Therefore, his attitude, no matter how unselfish, is still geared toward enlightenment.
“To proceed means to return.” This statement echoes a very significant philosophical theme. Let’s imagine a Bodhisattva who is striving for his enlightenment. Suppose this statement flashes in his mind, perhaps paraphrased as “to go means to come.” At the same moment that a Bodhisattva perceives that his life stems from the world of Buddhahood even as he is aiming toward enlightenment, the direction of his attitude reverses. From this we understand that there are two different directions inherent in the world of Bodhisattva.
In other words, the Bodhisattva may be going toward Buddhahood from the nine worlds — known as ju in koga — or he may be heading for the nine worlds drawing upon the life-force that stems from the world of Buddhahood — known as juga ko in. The former is characterized as seeking enlightenment, while the latter has the attributes of sharing enlightenment with others.
The difference between “to go” and “to come” is significant to each Bodhisattva. The latter Bodhisattva, coming from the world of Buddhahood, holds the clue to that world and has been taught by the true Buddha. He is called honge-no bosatsu (original Bodhisattva). The Bodhisattva striving toward enlightenment is called a transient Bodhisattva. Honge-no bosatsu means Bodhisattva of the Earth. The Yujutsu chapter of the Lotus Sutra describes Bodhisattvas of the Earth:
The bodies of these numerous Bodhisattvas are all golden and they have thirty-two appearances and abundant bright lights. . . . Their bodies are huge and they possess mystic powers. Their wisdom is beyond comprehension. Their will is very strong, and they have great perseverance. These are the ones wanted by the people. . . .They are very skillful in debate and are very rare and valued in society as treasures among people.... They will never be spoiled by the impurities of society and, as such, are like the lotus flower in the pond.
The Four Virtues
These virtues of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth are called jo, raku, ga, and jo and are exemplified by the four leaders of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth: Jogyo, Muhengyo, Jogyo (a different Chinese character), and Anryugyo. The Fushoki, a commentary written by T’ien-t’ai’s followers, states, “The four leaders of this sutra signify the four virtues. Jogyo exemplifies ga, Muhengyo exemplifies jo, Jogyo exemplifies jo, and Anryugyo exemplifies raku. The four virtues are possessed by one person.” Jo, raku, ga, and jo are the virtues of the four Bodhisattvas specifically, but they are generally possessed by each of the Bodhisattvas of the Earth. The four attributes form a picture of the ideal human being: the powerful and noble personality which in itself signifies the achievement of Buddhahood.
The lives of Bodhisattvas of the Earth are defined as having come from the world or “earth” of Buddha and are supported by the condition of Buddhahood itself. Buddhahood might well be thought of as an absolute, theoretical, and intangible world. Bodhisattvas of the Earth manifest themselves in the reality of the everyday world in order to lead people to enlightenment. Therefore, the characteristics of the Bodhisattva as exemplified by the four virtues become very important in a discussion of Buddhahood.
In his Ongi Kuden, the Daishonin states, “A flame has the function of burning things. Water has the function of purifying things. Wind has the function of sweeping dust. Earth has the function of fostering trees and grass. The virtues of the four Bodhisattvas function in the same manner.”
The virtue of ga is represented by that great or true ego which replaces the narrow-minded, egoistic self caught up in the mundane problems and attachments of everyday life. Only then does one sense the universal scale of life. Our subjective selves, in conjunction with this great ego, manifest the virtue of ga to the utmost.
Then we can create tremendous value by tapping the creative wellspring within. This is what President Ikeda was talking about in his address at U.C.L.A., when he said, “True Buddhism has clarified this highest ego as true human nature. I feel very strongly that our civilization will be able to make meaningful progress only if we understand this point.”
The virtue of jo refers to the aspect of eternal life which permeates the processes of birth, sickness, aging, and death or, from another angle, birth, maturity, decline, and ku. Eternal life encompasses all results from the past and all causes for the future. Jo shows in a person who has been awakened to the existence of eternal life and who perceives it within himself. This awareness leads to a total positivity which enables one to overcome any hardship and retain an ever youthful spirit. Jo also implies the eventual spread of true Buddhism, the construction of peace, and growth of civilization.
The other virtue of the second jo (different character) is the function of a strong and pure life that is self-cleansing. This is a propensity which is eternally present within our lives and which motivates compassion. It serves to preserve the beauty and purity of life in the lower nine worlds. We often compare this process to the blossoming of a lotus flower in the midst of a muddy swamp. In the same manner, a person who courageously forges ahead to spread true Buddhism, without being affected by the evils of society, is demonstrating this virtue.
The virtue of raku is seen in the conviction that provides a foundation for activity in which everything can be fully enjoyed. It is the source of harmony and power that enables one to overcome any hardship. This also implies leadership and insight to see the reality of life.
So far, we have defined the four virtues. To be sure, these descriptions are not definitive nor are they without overlap. (For instance, both jo and raku imply a kind of strength.) Nevertheless, all the four virtues represent the most favorable aspects of man. They are also encompassed by the two letters of the word jihi (mercy), which is perhaps the raison d’etre of the Bodhisattva. Buddhist mercy means to remove suffering and give pleasure. Jihi means being committed to helping others. The life of the Bodhisattva of the Earth seethes with the energy of mercy. This energy takes the form of the four virtues. A person who possesses these four virtues and exercises this mercy can be said to be a true Bodhisattva of the Earth.
In conclusion, understanding jihi is the key to grasping the characteristics of Buddhahood. It is safe to say that mercy derives from Buddhahood and is ultimately revealed in the actions of the Bodhisattva.
From ancient times, a Buddha has been considered a being above or apart from humans. That concept was expressed in countless statues and paintings. However, the truth is that a valid description of the Buddha is simply a description of the most humanistic kind of person. This is the ultimate principle of Buddhism and yet is so simply revealed in the form of the common man. The realization of Buddhahood — as a condition already within one’s own life — thus becomes available to all people. This is the ultimate revelation and rationale underlying the principle of the ten worlds.
