Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Winter 1976

Speaking Out on Medicine

NSA Quarterly, Winter 1976, pp. 92–97. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

By Lynne Murray San Francisco Headquarters trying to stop sickness before it starts. Even this stop-gap emergency care is a Herculean task,as any physician or even a hospital aide can testify. But could some energy, diverted into fighting illness at its root (if that indeed could be divined) create what some physicians idealize as a ‘“‘high-level wellness’ beyond the mere absence of overt Symptoms of sickness?

George Bernard Shaw blasted the traditional approach to illness in his usual outrageous but refreshing manner in his preface to the play The Doctor’s Dilemma, ‘Until the medical profession becomes a body of men trained and paid by the country to keep the country in health, it will remain what it is at present: a conspiracy to exploit popular credulity and suffering.”

Such an ideal seems as distant and Utopian today as it did when written over sixty years ago, but it does throw light on the negative emphasis of medicine’s approach to human health. The ill-researched fanfares each ‘‘miracle cure’’ elicits in the popular press is evidence that formal medicine is as the-counter patent medicines. In an age of quick panaceas, the ‘‘result’’ the physician is selling is a ‘‘cure,’’ not ‘protection,’ which is a rather vague concept, except perhaps in the field of family planning. Having firmly handed over to institutions many of those people-care problems which the more resourceful, multi-generational extended family used to handle with its wealth of involved, unskilled labor and still does handle in many other countries, the already fragile modern family finds itself dealing with bureaucracies and institutions to arrange care for its members. Worse yet, the technological skill or at least training in technical procedures that the health care profession now demands puts a further barrier between patient and physician.

Dr. John C. Whitehorn views this as limiting the medical effectiveness of the physician. In his essay, ‘‘The Doctor’s Image of Man,”’ he writes:

. any experience of illness may be volve many complex threats and uncertainties for them. Our cultural expectations put upon the physician a responsibility for leadership in crisis, as well as for technical knowledge and skill. It is one of the major tasks of the medical profession to possess and to utilize concepts and modes of understanding and of therapeutic action appropriate and adequate to the problems of personalistic medicine. Yet, in recent times, the medical profession has largely ignored personal factors in health and disease, while remaining preoccupied with impersonal factors. “This neglect has contributed, I

Suspect, to the current paradoxical decline in public esteem for medical men, at the very time when, technically, they are showing greater efficiency in curing disease and postponing death. I label this paradoxical because it seems logical that public esteem for physicians should run parallel with their demonstrated effectiveness in curing disease — but I doubt that historical study would show such a parallelism, The “‘lack of logic’? shown by the public is perhaps a very shrewd instinct indeed, drawn as it is from their own experiences. Soka Gakkai International President Daisaku Ikeda characterized the mood of most people in his recent address to medical professionals. He referred to this era, saying, ‘‘People today are worried about their health... the spectre of physical and mental illness haunts almost everyone. . .”’

The response of the medical community to the very real dangers that threaten modern human health is,in most cases, an ever-increasing technical absorption rather than an intensification of social consciousness or empathy. (Although, as many authorities testify, empathy is an almost unaffordable luxury for the working physician who, from his first hospital experiences onward is drenched in a sensibility-numbing tide of human suffering, most of which he or she is powerless to abate and which has the unavoidable although seemingly somewhat necessary effect of callousing him or her and innoculating the newcomer with the needed amount of ‘“‘professional detachment’’). A retreat into technology when human interaction is simply too much trouble, however, puts roadblocks in the patient’s path to recovery that are unnecessary and quite often cruel. In The Making of a Surgeon, Dr. William Nolan describes this syndrome in action:

“One problem that often occurs in big hospitals is a lack of communication. The superspecialists on the staff are each interested in only one part of the patient’s anatomy; there’s no doctor who is concerned with the patient in his entirety — and with the patient as a human being — and so the patient can’t find any doctor to whom he can talk and from whom he can get any practical information.

“This is extremely frustrating for the patient...”

Frustrating to say the least. Doctors carry on their technological absorption in the midst of an age when machines of all kinds, by replacing human workers, are literally uprooting their life-patterns, when technologically created health hazards (from factory pollution to unsafe automobile design) are often maintained at the expense of human life and limb because of ‘‘prohibitive cost factors’’ or convenient ignorance. The more vehement critics look backward to the fear and complacency which muzzled German physicians during the early years of the Nazi atrocities, when a united opposition by men of. science might have been effective, while none-too-trusting townspeople often feel that physicians are leaders of the community only in terms of income and social amusement. In his essay on ‘‘The Healing Tradition’? Dr. Jurgen Ruesch remarks, “Attitudes towards healing in America are essentially outgrowths of technological civilization. American medicine is characterized by impersonal relations, procedures unfamiliar to the layman, passive roles of patient and relatives, hospital care, control of the situation by professional healers, and high cost, These characteristics, along with the civilization to subscribe to full employment, high standards of living, care for the aged, and concern for the sick and infirm, result in the creation of organizations to serve these goals. Consequently, as Jaspers says, ‘A gigantic enterprise of medical practice is arising, in the form of institutions, bureaucracies, a codified system of material achievement.’ It is likely that, if this path is followed to its logical conclusion, the thoroughly trained and humane physicians who genuinely assume responsibility will die out.”’

This ‘‘assumption of responsibility” is exactly the characteristic which made the “‘Old Family General Practitioner’’ a beloved institution. The graduation, currently scheduled, of an_ increasing number of general practitioners as opposed to specialists, will provide no relief if these ‘‘generalists’’ prove equally unwilling to take on that crushing responsibility. The degree of technical skill or knowledge any physician may possess differs from his ability to successfully apply it.

Another danger lurks for anyone who would, as President Ikeda puts it, “‘regard his throne as the true master of civilization.’’ Such power can be dangerously corrupting, and anyone in a position to abuse it must ‘‘struggle relentlessly against the personal egoism which enslaves him in the pursuit of power.”’ One of the fallacies of a technological approach to problem-solving is that while one is manipulating instruments or tools ‘‘out there in the environment,”’ it is easy to fall into the delusion that they are in no significant way connected to one’s own existence “‘in here.”’ This is simply not the case. When the individual wielding the technological skill becomes identified with it, the halo effect can create a dangerously unreal illusion. Jurgen Ruesch describes how this halo effect puts the physician quite often ina position of unwarranted influence over others, influence which he must often strive quite mightily to use for positive rather than complacently self-serving purposes.

‘At the dawn of civilization, the influence that certain persons exerted upon others was identified with magic. Among those influences was the physician’s ability to heal, which gave him unprecedented power. But the element of magic that lay people frequently connect with the doctor’s ability to remove vital threats ceases to have supernatural characteristics when considered in the light of modern cybernetics. It is well known that in electronics a specific signal can set off events which, in terms of energy, are billions of times more powerful than. the trigger signal. The pressing of a button. . . can set off a hydrogen bomb at some far distant spot. When natives first heard and Saw a cannon, and when people first witnessed the devastating effects of an A-bomb, the makers and users of these elicited admiration, fear, and hatred. ‘‘Whenever a person sets off a signal or engages in an action that has powerful effects, he becomes something special. This fact is made use of in both physical medicine and mental healing. Once a physician has been successful at surgically remov-lieving unbearable pain, he acquires a halo and is considered to have godlike qualities. The skill with which an individual can handle these attributed features determines his relationship to Other individuals. The psychotherapist is specially trained in this art, which consists, essentially, of two components: first to select proper trigger signals which fit into the expectations of the patient, in order to effectuate significant reactions: second, not to react himself unwisely to the attributed power. Every physician has to learn to act in emergencies, to accept the attributed features, to use his power wisely and to guide people when their values fail.”’ President Ikeda stresses the incredible value such a responsibility can create, if the physician is enough to shoulder it.

“‘T urge you. . and cure the underlying causes of human sickness, but to diagnose the cause of sickness in society and in the times themselves and perform the major surgery needed to remove it...’ The physician is uniquely qualified to awaken his patients to the value of life, and quite often if he or she does not. as President Ikeda urges, ‘*. . . make them realize how important ‘treasure of the spirit’ is in recovering their physical health — this means the power of sound mental health, the will to live, hope, courage, and the feeling that life js worthwhile.”’

Although these thoughts seem aimed at health care professionals specifically and selectively, the health of society, like the health of an individual is based on the harmonious healthy functioning of all of its parts. And the truth is that the overall health quality of Americans is declining despite vast sums poured into medical research and_ sophisticated technological equipment. The aggressive approach toward health preservation that President Ikeda designates ‘‘aggressive medicine’ based upon a profound understanding of the preciousness of life, is not simply a matter for doctors to solve on their own. The unwillingness to come to grips with problems has its roots in the frequent failure when it has been attempted in the past. It is difficult for most people to understand how strongly the urge to explore and confront reality has been dampened in modern man. The spectre of failure makes failures of many through their early surrender. In Dehumanization and _ the Institutional Career, Dr. David J. Vail postulates:

‘*As a Christian-ethic culture we are punishment-oriented. Operant conditioning studies on animals and people show that behavior can be most quickly modified by tangible and consistent rewards given immediately and desired behavior is learned. It may be generations before this concept is translated into our mores, our child-rearing or our social institutions. It is normal in our culture for employers to be quick to blame or criticize, while they must make an effort, or be reminded, to praise the worker for a job well done. Just as parents may have to make no effort to scold a child when he is naughty, they will forget to reward him when he does something right.”

This punishment orientation, while not an efficient way of situation improvement, at least has the rather dubious advantage of reinforcing the person who is doing the punishment and his ‘‘hopeless’’ diagnosis of whomever he is trying to punish into changing. Past philosophies have failed so abysmally at giving useful insight into the dynamics of daily life and how to maximize positive and harmonious results that, while mouthing slogans of brotherhood, most people today live by the most instinctive, if impractical (in the long run) code — jungle ethics. If a person has not true control over his selfish nature, he will find himself, no matter what theories he espouses, stepping on others to survive, turning away from others’ ill fortune

Lynne Murray is a recent graduate in psychology from San Francisco State College. because he lacks the means to cope with it and secretly fears it might somehow be ““catching”’ and turning his back on problems in the mistaken belief that they will somehow dwindle or go away altogether if he can only ignore them long enough.

Considerable courage and stamina is necessary to foster hope and an attitude of spiritual challenge of destiny in even one other person. But when one sees another person begin to gain control over his life through the practice of Buddhism, just as when one recovers from an illness or from pain, there is a sudden clarity of understanding of how very precious it is to function as a healthy human being. Suddenly the most strenuous efforts to reach that balanced state become quite worthwhile indeed. Through helping other people, one feels the pain of the disease of selfishness easing.

The health of a person who helps others is contagious. In order to spread health and to enjoy a healing society, NSA members of not merely the medical but all professions must pursue their own health, not for selfish or narcissistic reasons, but to maximize their effectiveness in all facets of life and to make the struggle for world peace truly a pursuit of happiness. O tener a

Captions and notes

linked to the consumer market as overa terrifying emotional experience to those concerned in it, and may in-

as logic seems to demand.”’ en

ing a life-endangering tumor or at re-devices strong

. not only to ferret out

unequivocally as soon as the new and TONS ERE hehe mere wert thee a geh-e-cesrasnece +e -_