Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Spring 1976

Questions and Answers

NSA Quarterly, Spring 1976, pp. 117–125. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

Q: Following a particularly vigorous chapter meeting, a new member stood apart from the buzzing members who were encouraging the guests to join. She had a puzzled look on her face, and the chapter chief, seeing that something was on her mind, introduced himself and asked her what was the matter.

“I’m glad you said something,” the young woman replied, “because there is something puzzling me. It’s all this emphasis on getting new people to join. I don’t like it, and I don’t want to do it. Do I have to in order to be a member of NSA? I just want to chant. I have only been practicing about a month and I’m already receiving benefits. Can’t I practice my way?”

A: This is a good question and one that is common among new members. The young woman went on to say that the reason she didn’t like to do Shakubuku, particularly with people she didn’t know, was that it made her feel just like religious proselytizers she had always avoided.

New members should understand that there are many distinct differences between doing Shakubuku and traditional religious proselytizing in America. The first is that NSA is not saying that anyone is “damned” or “doomed” unless he is chanting. The point is that everyone is already trying his best to improve his life, and that by chanting he can do just that with incredible speed, advancing far beyond his wildest dreams. Traditional proselytizing for the most part seems to imply that others are not as “good” as the members or the group.

Shakubuku might then be compared to discovering a restaurant with wonderful food at amazingly low prices. What would most people do if they found such a place? They would probably tell their closest friends immediately of their amazing “find.”

While Shakubuku may not always be easy, the important thing to remember is that anyone who does Shakubuku gains tremendous benefits from it. People have only to try this to see if it is true. Time and time again, a member will complain about a problem only to have his leader say, “Do Shakubuku!” Though this may seem unrelated to the problem, the person willing to follow such a suggestion will discover quickly why the leader told him that. Shakubuku makes people confident and happy, and such people are winners able to overcome problems in life, instead of giving in to them.

“I understand that,” the young woman said, “and that makes me feel better about Shakubuku, but how can I tell my friends about Buddhism when I know so little myself?”

Someone who is practicing and getting benefits in fact knows the one vital thing about Buddhism — that it has a powerful, positive effect. Extensive knowledge about the history of this life-philosophy, what is written on the Gohonzon or what Nam-myoho-renge-kyo means is supplemental to this essential knowledge. In fact, all that will be of little or no interest to most people who have never even attended a discussion meeting. What they would like to know is why it would be worth their time to come to a meeting. This is a reasonable question, and every member, new or old, knows the answer.

Should they want to know more and you don’t know the answer, that is even more reason why they should come to the meeting — to find out the answer. In this case, someone’s lack of knowledge about Buddhism can be beneficial in doing Shakubuku!

By now, the young member was laughing. “Okay,” she said, “I can see all that, but I can’t do Shakubuku like these other people. I want to do it my way, if I do it at all.”

Western Territory Executive Director Mike Wilson once explained that Shakubuku is the reason everyone joins NSA in the first place. In response to the puzzled looks on peoples’ faces, he said that Shakubuku means getting benefits in daily life, overcoming problems and showing others the power of the practice. “Isn’t that why everyone here joined — to get benefits?” he asked the men he was speaking to. They roared their approval.

In one important sense, the young woman was absolutely right — she should do Shakubuku her way. There are no specific guidelines set up on how to do Shakubuku. The important thing is that each person sincerely invite people to the meeting in his own words and his own way. But the important thing is that the member do Shakubuku.

Q: As a group chief, what is the best method to use in getting the junior group chiefs and members in the group to unite?

A: That is the question asked by every junior leader at one time or another. Group chief is the first position in which one seriously begins to assume the role of a central figure in the organization. For that reason, it is an important time in one’s practice, as it will serve as the foundation for a future where many people can follow that individual in faith.

When a person is first appointed to the position of group chief, he generally feels delighted to finally have responsible members to help him. It is natural that he feel, “Now my troubles are over, since I have such able assistants under me.”

Within a few weeks after his appointment though, after the newness has worn off for both the group chief and his members, things look quite different. Then the same person who was so appreciative of his new position begins to realize that being the leader is not nearly so easy as he thought. In fact, it might easily prove to be construed as one big headache after another.

On a positive side, the group chief is beginning to realize that the higher the position in NSA, the more responsibility and hard work a leader has. Generally, people assume the opposite to be true. Even district chiefs might feel, “Boy, when I get to be a senior leader, things will be a lot easier!”” Needless to say, that is far off the mark. It might sometimes be true that an irresponsible person thrives with more people to order around and less people to listen to, but that person will find it very difficult to lead people in NSA. Without power or money, NSA leaders have only their ability and their understanding based on faith in the Gohonzon with which to lead people. One who relies on others to get the job done will always fail.

In this vein, President Ikeda explains that there are three kinds of people. The first is the type that everyone is happy to have around. The second is the type no one cares about whether they’re around or not. The third is one that everyone is happy not to have around at all. Obviously, it is desirable for a leader of people to belong to the first category. Those who fall into the third category are usually those who like to give advice while not following it themselves. They like to blame others for failure and never assume responsibility themselves. This person is not qualified to be an NSA leader until he himself changes.

He is the kind of person that makes people angry just by being around; if he goes over to someone’s house, they pretend not to be home.

The leader whom people are drawn to is one who first practices and then asks others to join him in receiving benefits. He proves the power of the Gohonzon to others through his own life. If he sees a problem in another’s practice, he helps that person get to leaders who can give him good guidance.

This brings us to the second means of training leaders. After setting a good example himself, a leader can bring his members to receive guidance from a higher leader. A group chief does not really give guidance at any time; his job is to encourage the members. Teaching them how to receive guidance is the best way he can encourage their practice.

Before bringing them to the leader, the group chief should let the leader know the condition of the member’s practice and any other pertinent information that will help the leader give meaningful guidance. It’s a good idea to avoid trying to give one’s impression of the member’s practice in front of the member. Nothing is more discouraging than having a leader who introduces the member with, “This is so-and-so, he’s doing poorly,” or even “. . . he’s doing great.” A weather report on a person’s condition of life is like a cold shower for an introduction.

On the other hand, if the leader knows the member’s situation beforehand, he can comfortably lead the discussion toward the member’s practice. This is obviously better than the “cold shower method” of introducing someone to his senior leaders by his name and life-condition.

These two points are the only “method” needed in leading people to the Gohonzon. A leader who sets a good example for his members and takes them for guidance is functioning like a clear window through which his members can see the benefit of practice. To become such a leader is the challenge of being a group chief. It is a simple formula that, when practiced, will yield benefit not only to the members but to the leader himself.

One who masters the basics of leadership has really begun to master his own destiny. At the same time he will have set the foundation to enjoy a great future himself, while leading many others to absolute happiness.

Q: Recently, a young leader in NSA explained to his chapter chief that he had been trying very hard to encourage one of his new members, but that an incident at a discussion meeting had apparently discouraged the member.

“My member asked what seemed to me a fairly simple question, but my district chief kind of brushed over it, saying that it wasn’t very important. I know that my district chief was trying to get him to understand that practice is what is most important, but my member didn’t understand and now he’s really bitter about the organization. What should I do to encourage him and at the same time explain why my district chief was short with him?”

A: This is a complex question with several parts to the answer. The first is that the young leader should do his best to answer his member’s question if it was not answered at the meeting. This might mean asking the district chief for a further explanation following the meeting, or another leader at a later time. In any case, the member might be greatly encouraged by a more detailed answer than the one his district chief was able to provide at the meeting.

The second part of this answer involves timing. While a district chief is well advised if he tries to answer every question at a meeting, there are some questions that interrupt the mood of the meeting and therefore an extensive answer could have a negative effect. It makes no sense to provide an elaborate answer if the question apparently affects only the person who asked, but does not apply to the twenty or thirty other people present.

For example, imagine that there has been a bad traffic accident. Several people have been seriously hurt, their cars are still locked together in the middle of the busy highway, and a crowd is gathering, complicating matters. The police have arrived on the scene and are doing their best to direct traffic around the tangled wreckage while caring for the people who have been injured. If you were the policeman directing traffic and trying to clear away the damaged cars, would you take time to answer someone who walked up and asked, “Officer, what happened?” In all likelihood, you would tell him to get out of the way and not bother you.

Some questions at a meeting are equally as poorly timed. For instance, imagine that the guests are enthused about practicing and are asking questions like, “How do I join?” and “Can I really chant for anything?” Then a member pipes up and asks a long and complicated guidance question, slowing down the pace of the meeting. He is asking a question whose answer will probably mean little to the guests, and the prime purpose of the meeting is to encourage them to join. This is not to say that it might not be a good question, but it should be asked and answered at another time.

Healthy questions at a meeting relate directly to daily life. “My refrigerator is empty, I have no money, how do I remedy that?” or “How can I keep active and happy at my job, which I don’t really like?” For a religion, these are unusually practical topics which may sound surprising and even trivial to guests. They in turn may be wondering about abstract questions — “What happens when you die?” — and it is very much a part of the process of Shakubuku to get them

“out of the clouds” and “down to earth.”

Though the experiences probably are about everyday matters, such questions make it even more apparent that NSA is like no other religion in the world in that it deals with practical matters which influence our day-to-day lives. No guest who understands this can say he has nothing to chant for since everyone faces unknown problems daily which he wants to overcome.

Finally, it is certainly possible that the district chief did not know the answer to the question asked, or did his best to answer it completely, although the member felt he was brusque. District chiefs are only human, and Buddhism is a practice for human beings, not people who are perfect. They are undergoing their own human revolution. If a leader was a “perfect human being,” how could he understand the problems of ordinary people fighting for their own happiness? Members are often encouraged to learn that their leaders are also struggling for their own human revolution, and have therefore undergone many of the same problems that the members who have practiced for a shorter period are discovering.

Some, or all, of these answers might help in encouraging the member who is puzzled by an incident which, if clearly explained to him, could lead to a greater understanding of this life-philosophy.

Q: In order to step up the Shakubuku in a district, is it a good idea to increase the number of meeting nights a week?

A: Before that question can be answered, there are several important elements that must be considered. First of all, how many meetings does the district in question hold each week now? Secondly, what is the present attitude of the members in the district in regards to Shakubuku? And third, what is the intention of the district leader in changing the schedule?

Assuming that the average district holds two to four discussion meetings a week, when a Shakubuku campaign begins, it is conceivable that the senior leaders may instruct the district chief to increase the number of meetings, or the district chief may decide to do so himself. What is important to consider in this regard is that quality is just as important as quantity. Even a dozen meetings a week will not increase the Shakubuku results if the meetings are poorly organized and without the heartfelt support of the members.

President Ikeda often refers to the discussion meeting as the battleground where a leader must have the determination to absolutely win. It is vital that the leader in charge never hold a single meeting that ends in failure or gives the members a feeling of hopelessness. President Ikeda has stressed that it is the leader’s responsibility to win in every campaign so that his members can say, “When he’s here, there is nothing to worry about.”

In considering the quality of the discussion meeting, there is the question of the present attitude of the district members. For example, if the district is one where the members are having a difficult time attending even the two or three meetings presently being held a week, and if at those meetings there are rarely any guests present, this should indicate to the leader that what is needed is not more meetings, but meetings that will encourage the members more.

When each meeting comes to represent in the minds of the members an exciting and inspiring place where they can attain benefits, they will enjoy coming as often as they can, and it will be much easier for them to bring guests. The guests who come will be encouraged to practice, and they will want to come back with guests of their own. When that happens, the older members and leaders will be encouraged even more. In such an atmosphere of growing enthusiasm, it might then be a good idea to increase the meeting schedule.

Members are sincere. They will try to do Shakubuku even if they don’t feel enthusiastic about doing so. The district leader should be the person who makes the activity enjoyable for the members.

This brings us to the last, and perhaps most important point, that of the leader’s intention. If the leader feels that, merely by increasing the number of meetings, he will increase the results, he might be taking the attitude of an employer who is trying to get his “money’s worth” out of his employees. The members are not working for the district chief. President Ikeda addresses the members in the Guidance Memo, “You do not practice Buddhism for your district chief’s sake, nor do you do Shakubuku for your chapter chief. Shakubuku is the teaching of Nichiren Daishonin, and you do it for your own sake.”

A district leader should encourage the members to practice Shakubuku for their own sakes. When he assumes responsibility for the Shakubuku campaign and makes that determination to the Gohonzon, the district chief suddenly finds himself in the position of determining the growth of his district. He no longer needs to make demands on his members. His sole purpose becomes to encourage their own practice for their own benefit.

“A leader’s first concern is to chant Daimoku sincerely and have an exemplary practice himself.” This phrase from President Ikeda’s guidance expresses the spirit of an NSA leader to be strict on himself and warm to the members. The determination of the leader, Cho-no Ichinen, is of fundamental importance in deciding the outcome of any campaign.

“A leader should love his members, protect them and encourage them warmly. He is responsible for their happiness. His sense of responsibility is deepened by his affection, so that whatever obstacles they meet, the leader will feel, ‘I’ll never let my members down.’ Being irresponsible shows a lack of mercy.”

This quotation from the Guidance Memo, when put into practice by a district chief, creates a happy district where many people flock to find out about the philosophy that people can actually practice, not just talk about. In such a case, a leader will find it necessary to increase the number of meetings to accommodate all the people who are seeking the benefit of the Gohonzon.

What is most important, then, in considering increasing the number of meetings is to guarantee that the move will be a step forward for the district. This is determined, more than anything else, by the district leader’s sense of responsibility.