Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Fall 1976

News Views

NSA Quarterly, Fall 1976, pp. 76–81. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

Should Inflation Terrify You?

Inflation is like the weather: lots of people complain about it, but no one seems to be able to do anything about it.

Economists explain that inflation is the result of governments spending more money than taxes provide. Unfortunately, that knowledge doesn’t seem to help Mr. and Mrs. America with their basic dilemma — their dollar is buying less and less at the marketplace.

Does that mean that inflation is necessarily bad? Will Americans have to suffer with dwindling buying power, limiting their life-styles until they do nothing more than eat, sleep, dwell, travel and dress in the simplest way possible?

Some economists don’t think so. Society tends to adjust, they say. Only a few will have to make major adjustments as a result of the stretched-out dollar.

Dr. Gardner Ackley, a noted University of Michigan economist, told the Midwestern Governors’ Conference two years ago that the impact of inflation on our society “is commonly misunderstood and probably exaggerated. Most people believe that inflation impoverishes us. The facts are that, with modest exceptions, inflation necessarily raises the average of money incomes as much as it raises the average of money prices.”

UCLA economist Dr. Benjamin Klein said this process provides an important psychological boost for the average wage-earner. Periodic wage adjustments have meant people are steadily making more money. Everyone is glad to have more money in his pocket this year than last. The gripe, of course, is that wages are just barely keeping up with market prices, if that. Dr. Klein’s contention is that if market prices had remained the same in the last few years, so would most peoples’ paychecks.

There are even those who benefit substantially from inflation. Homeowners are an excellent example. They will see their homes rise in value far faster in times of inflation than at more stable times. For example, a home purchased in 1966 is now worth at least twice as much as it was then. In every major metropolitan area in the United States, | 78 NSA QUARTERLY many homes have appreciated considerably more, according to the National Association of Realtors.

For the person whose home has only doubled in value, that still means a sizeable profit. If, for instance, they bought their $30,000 home with $10,000 of their own money and a $20,000 loan, they can sell it today for $60,000. Their profit will be $40,000 — an average annual profit of $4,000. For them, inflation is a boon.

If inflation is a livable matter for most and a great opportunity for some, economists admit it is disaster for a few. These are people living on fixed incomes — often retired people who are unable to re-enter the job market. Retirement may have looked rosy ten years ago when $600 a month would provide a modest but satisfactory living. Today that amount may be barely enough to survive on.

One adverse effect of inflation that can pinch every American is that higher wages meant to counteract inflationary prices may push people into higher tax brackets. He or she will then have to pay a greater percentage of their income to the taxman. What’s left over may not buy as much as the smaller amount they took home before the wage boost, since market prices have climbed in the meantime. In times of inflation, more can therefore mean less. The tax rebate of 1974 was an effort by the government to offset this inequity.

Another negative aspect of inflation is that it can hinder long-term loans. That in turn can affect prospective homeowners, businessmen who wish to expand their company, and anyone else seeking to grow economically.

The reason for this is that banks are in a quandary as to how much to charge for loaning money. If they charge too little, then they will see their interest rates overtaken by inflation. For example, if banks charge eight per cent annually and inflation is also eight percent, they make no money at all and go broke. (The dollar has inflated at about eight percent for the last few years.)

But should they charge excessively high interest rates, no one will borrow money, the banks won’t profit, and businesses and private parties will be unable to expand. The disadvantage here is that, without an expanding economy, there will not be enough jobs for our increasing population. Thus inflation can slow down the development of a country, as is happening moderately today in the United States.

What does all this mean for the average man on the street? According to Dr. Ackley, not much at all.

“There is no clear evidence that inflation consistently hurts or helps workers rather than business or its owners, the poor rather than the rich, the organized rather than the unorganized, the farmer rather than the city dweller. Or that it has any other systematic effect except that it tends to hurt the (fixed-income) old and to benefit the young.”

And as Will and Ariel Durant point out in their tome, The Lessons of History, history itself is inflationary.

Nevertheless, despite all this, as Dr. Ackley points out, the plain truth of the matter is that “without (inflation) we would all feel much better.”

Perhaps inflation really is like the weather — it just gives us all something to talk about. □

Property Taxes: The Hue and Cry for Reform

By Leigh Romero

O: Tuesday, July 20, homeowners in Los Angeles County expressed their growing discontent with skyrocketing house assessments when 3,000 noisy, hostile people gathered at Pierce College in the San Fernando Valley. Increases in some parts of the largely middle-class region had risen as much as 135 percent in one year. Based on last year’s tax rate, the increase amounted to as much as $1,000 in taxes.

The meeting caught the attention of city and county government in Los Angeles, and immediate emergency measures were called for. Mayor Bradley announced a 30-cent rate reduction. Prompted by 900 raucous citizens at the August 10 County Supervisors’ meeting, the county officials voted to rescind the already-in-force budget.

But frustration mounted, and a second rally was staged at Valley College on August 12. Four public officials, including Mayor Bradley, were booed as they endeavored to address the throng. Most homeowners share a sense of alienation from the programs that their property taxes support — mostly welfare and education.

On a recent television program, Property Taxes — Up Up and Away, State Assembly minority whip Paul Priolo remarked that the people had to ask themselves, “Am I my brothers’ keeper?” and that they would have to agree that they were. But the audience, made up of representatives of all the angry taxpayers groups, responded resoundingly with loud boos.

The fact is that property taxes, while the largest single tax source, no longer bring more than 25 percent of the total revenue of local government. Inflation without a corresponding rise in personal income has created the inequity between astronomical assessments based on the market value of homes and the ability to pay taxes, based on income. The elderly person on a fixed income, for example, cannot respond to any increase and is literally taxed out of the home.

Incensed property owners want to change the valuation on an Owner-occupied home to current use: the original value, plus the dollar value of improvements. In Los Angeles County at present, homes are taxed at 25 percent of the assessed market value, which indicates what the home should bring if it were to be sold that year.

The “Summer of Discontent” in Los Angeles reflects the mood of property taxpayers throughout the United States. San Francisco has experienced extreme hikes in property valuation and increases in the tax rate, bringing in a whopping $13.50 per $100 of assessed value, compared with the current rate for Los Angeles, which is $3.08 per $100.

While not as extreme, residents in other cities are also hit by jumps in assessments and rates. In Montgomery County, Maryland, the voters booted the county government out of office after a double tax hike in one year.

Although it is evident that the practice of property taxation should be reformed, it has become such a labyrinth of regulations and exemptions that it’s difficult to determine what steps are the best to be taken. This levy has been the basis of revenue gathering in the United States since colonial times, when it was considered an equitable alternative to British imposed stamp and other taxes. In the 1700s, the Massachusetts constitutional convention expressed the attitude that those who did not possess property must be just beginning life, were living with parents, or were guilty of “idleness of life and profligancy of manners.”

By the early 1900s, modernization of the cities created public needs such as transportation, public health and sanitation, street cleaning and so on. One commentator of the time wrote, “. . . the cities (now) provide for the individual citizens things which they might — and for a long time did — provide for themselves ... The big motor-driven street sweeper has taken the place of the primitive rule ‘let every man sweep in front of his own door.’ ”

The increased municipal responsibility resulted in higher taxes. Compared to today’s inflated rates, the figures in 1915 seem laughable. But the citizens Of the time considered three percent of the assessed value of their homes too much to bear. In response to the angry clamor, many states began to share local expenses. 80 NSA QUARTERLY

The performance of the property tax during the Depression proved its utter dependency on the condition of the economy. Whereas the states were able to maintain revenues through various fuel, vehicle and business taxes, cities and counties reached bottom and could not recover, as property owners defaulted on mortgages as well as taxes; consequently assessments declined sharply. Since municipalities couldn’t meet their own debts, they also defaulted on loans, leading to the Municipal-Bond panic in 1933. At that time New York City’s financial management went into receivership for four long years.

Presently, government expenditures provide for programs benefiting low and middle income groups, while the tax burden is shouldered by the more fortunate. Property owners, especially, object strenuously to the idea of providing services from which they do not directly benefit. Justice Stone of the United State Supreme Court addressed this objection in 1937:

“The only benefit to which the tax-payer is constitutionally entitled is that derived from his enjoyment of the privileges of living in an organized society, established and safeguarded by the devotion of taxes to public purposes. Any other view would preclude the levying of taxes except as they are used to compensate for the burden on those who pay them, and would involve the abandonment of the most fundamental principle of government — that it exists primarily to provide for the common good.”

Today, property taxation is not only less representative of all people; it actually has detrimental effects. It has evolved as more of a levy on real estate, wherein a neglected building will be assessed at lower value that a new, or fully maintained building. Since heavy taxation discourages renovation and maintenance, renters and people living in the inner city suffer the most. At the same time local costs for servicing run-down property with a lower assessment value is far greater in terms of fire and police protection, and the possibility of welfare and health considerations.

The same high property taxes have contributed to urban sprawl. As taxes rise, families and businesses seeking relief move to the outskirts of an urban area, leaving the core of the city to decay. It is a vicious circle. As property values decline, the tax base falls and the city is less able to pay for the rising costs of municipal services that are brought on by the depreciation of property.

Both building construction and the fate of rural and farm lands are affected by the property tax. Since land is always assessed at the prevailing market price, farmers are taxed off their farms through non-agricultural demand for them, due to urban sprawl. At the same time, rising taxes dictate a decline in space and quality of construction. In turn, the selling price for a house or apartment will be greater. Studies have shown that the cost of building a good quality, single-family dwelling goes up in proportion to the reduction in cubic footage. It’s another vicious circle that began in the late 40s with tract houses, and continues today with the widespread construction of condominium complexes.

Contrary to the opinions of most taxpayers, city, county and state officials are concerned about property taxation. In California, Los Angeles County Assessor, Phillip Watson, has proposed an initiative that would restrict property taxation to 1.5 percent of market value, and provide other homeowner benefits.

Other revisions of the existing structure are under consideration. The Smith Proposal has passed the California State Senate and is now under consideration by the Assembly. It provides a split tax role for local governments, with residential property taxes limited by the previous year’s total, plus a cost-of-living increase dictated by the Consumer Price Index, plus population growth. Income producing properties would be taxed at the full amount of growth.

Two groups, the People’s Advocates from San Francisco, and the Associated California Taxpayers of Southern California, have gathered together to collect signatures to qualify another initiative. It would limit raises in assessments to two percent per year and reduce property taxes as such programs as education or welfare are removed from its support base. It calls for no increasing of assessments for minor improvements or repairs, limiting exempted properties, and sharing homeowner gains in benefits with renters. Additionally, Senior Citizens would have a $40,000 homeowners exemption, and all others would enjoy a $10,000 exemption. The present automatic homeowner tax credit in California is $1,750.

Jonathan Lewis, President of the California Tax Reform Association, proposes that all welfare and education costs be funded by the state graduated income tax. He reasons that these services are properly the concern of the state, a contention which is supported by the recent Serrano decision which ruled that students were denied equal protection under the law by the unequal per capita expenditures available locally.

Lewis plans for a more progressive and just property tax by the adaptation of the graduated scale of the existing Senior Citizens Property Tax Assistance Act. He would extend the rebate system to all property owners, with the amount of personal income compared to the value of property in order to arrive at an equitable tax share.

One major area of reform has not been mentioned by any politician. An economist named Henry George created quite a stir in 1879 with the publication of his book, Progress and Poverty. George proposed a graduated reduction of other taxes in favor of a single land tax which would assign nearly all the rental value of the land to public use. That way owners would pay, in taxes, all the rental value of the land, but would be free of valuations made on buildings and improvements. His idea met with ardent admiration, as well as skepticism. Several trustee-run communities sprang up that exist today.

In his report on the role of property taxation in government finance made for the Tax Foundation, C. Lowell Harriss, Professor of Economics at Columbia University, makes a case for the basic idea of land taxation. He advocates a gradual five-year transition in proportionate taxation between land, and buildings and machinery toward a 3-1 or even 5-1 ratio, Such a change would not substantially reduce present tax levels, but would induce owners of rundown or substandard property to improve it in order to realize a better financial return. Investments made to the property would then yield benefits to owners, instead of acting as a tax penalty.

Furthermore, reinvestment in and renewal of property would effectively drive down the annual tax, since higher land tax rates decrease market value, which in turn reduces the tax. Urban areas would be the obvious benefactors of this process. Paying a higher land tax would tend to put the land to the highest and best use, according to Professor Harriss. Land tax reform would weaken the power land owners now possess to create urban sprawl through the under-utilization of urban property.

The single land tax involves a revolution in the whole property tax structure and would require massive Constitutional and Statutory revisions, taking much time and effort. On the other hand, property owners have reached the limit of their ability to pay in the present economic climate, and they need immediate relief.

Ona Los Angeles news station, a science commentator recently broadcast his view of our future. He lamented, “We find our government locked into economic, social and environmental methods, without the ability to make healthy experiments in these areas.”

Hopefully, the people and their legislators will find the means to bring major experimentations and reform to the two-hundred-year-old property tax. Oo

[The monolithic gas pump is rapidly becoming the enemy of many motorists and the universal symbol of inflation and economic woes to consumers everywhere.]