Esho Funi: The Key to Human Revolution
Buddhist Philosophy
NSA Quarterly, Fall 1976, pp. 108–118. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
This is the second of a series of essays dealing with the deeper meanings of concepts found in the life-philosophy of Nichiren Shoshu. It endeavors to present the term known as ‘Esho Funi’ in a unique and different light than it has previously been explained. ‘Esho Funi,’ “The Oneness of Subject and Object,” has usually been dealt with from the standpoint of the way an individual affects his environment. In this article, we will examine the concept from the perspective of both history and human behavior.
The concept of revolution is a uniquely human one and perhaps forms the entire basis for change at all levels of society. Whether it be artistic, economic, political, or violent, revolution has consistently provided man with the basic dynamics by which he has advanced.
The purpose of this essay is to single out the often-heard phrase, “human revolution,” and show why it means something special. From the standpoint of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism, “human revolution” refers to the fundamental process by which a man changes the basic natures under which he operates, often thought to be an impossible task, and thereby changes the environment around him in the deepest, most permanent way.
When we talk about human revolution, we consider not only the internal processes that take place within the human being, but the effect that he exerts on his surroundings. For this reason, it is essential that the Buddhist concept of Esho Funi be understood, both from the standpoint of the individual and also from the scope of his society. Indeed, Esho Funi can be used to explain the course of history. We’re going to briefly attempt that here in order to make the whole Buddhist philosophy seem a little more relevant to our daily lives. In short, understanding Esho Funi will make clear the need and process of human revolution. This seems important since human revolution is often termed the ultimate objective of the Buddhist practice.
Literally, Esho Funi means the inseparability (Funi) of subject (Shoho) and object (Eho). Many times this is interpreted to mean that a person is one with his environment, i.e. that your environment is a reflection of what you are: If you are sad, even a sunny day seems gray, and, conversely, if you are happy, you can be “singing in the rain.”
More practically, Esho Funi implies that through the strength of our own efforts we can change or determine our own environment, whereas a reticence or weakness on our part will allow us to be manipulated or controlled by our surroundings. This interpretation is correct as far as it goes, but in this article we would like to look at the deeper, perhaps as yet undiscussed, implications of Esho Funi. A preliminary understanding of Esho Funi should help us to realize that we have no one to blame but ourselves for our surroundings, and yet we may need more information before we know exactly what to do about changing things around us.
Environment or Object — 依 — E
Oneself or Subject — 正 — SHO
Inseparability of the Two — 不二 — FU NI
Esho Funi and History
Perhaps the broadest approach to Esho Funi would be to consider it from the standpoint of history. For those who are not history buffs, this may seem a little dry. However, rather than being a compilation of dates and events, the application of the Esho Funi theory to history lends a whole new insight to the dynamics which comprise the ebb and flow of world events. Understanding how a concept can be so relevant to both our own lives and the entire historical fabric of our civilization may serve to finally put some perspective on the age-old question of “Where do I fit in in this world?”
Incredible as it may seem, stark images of defeat and alienation conjured up in Bob Dylan’s Desolation Row back in 1968 accurately reflected the mood and aspirations of an entire generation. The title of the song in itself is enough to convey its message; in poetry and music, Dylan conveyed an aspect of Esho Funi as he described a street of horrors which in reality was comprised of the feelings of those who lived there.
What was America experiencing in the late ’60s? Following World War II, America seemed to believe in its own movies as it attempted to fabricate an almost Hollywood-style materialistic society for its citizens. The beat movement of the ’50s and the hippie movement almost ten years later were symptoms of what could happen to a society that, while reaching a material zenith, was wallowing in a spiritual swamp.
This situation can be described in terms of Esho Funi, but first it is necessary to define terms, specifically Shoho (Subject) and Eho (Object). The basic view of Shoho and Eho holds that Shoho means the person while Eho means the environment. If we take this superficial meaning one step further we can say that Shoho refers to the more humanistic or spiritual aspects of living — those things that deal with the essence or quality of human life itself. On the other hand Eho, referring as it does to the environment, implies the manipulation of that environment achieved by the creation and maintenance of various systems, i.e. political, economic and so on.
These definitions thus established, we can now expand our Esho Funi principle to history. For instance, in the late ’60s, the Vietnam War seemed to become the focal point of everything that was wrong in America. It was the ultimate battle of materialism vs. spiritualism and Robert McNamera’s computer projections vs. Gene McCarthy’s poetry. Lines were drawn and categories were described, and in the end nobody was sure who won.
If one were to describe the Vietnam conflict in terms of Esho Funi, using our previously defined concepts of Eho and Shoho, it might look like this:
Shoho (subject: humanistic concerns)
Hippie movement
Spiritual regeneration
Needs of under-developed nations, etc.
vs.
Eho (object: systems and plans)
Military establishment
Profit motive
Defense of national status, etc.
The point of all this is to show that, as evidenced by events, even in our most recent history, a situation where Shoho is in direct conflict with Eho is not liable to result in anything resembling harmony. It is generally agreed upon that no one was very happy following the Vietnam debacle. No one group truly had its needs met or desires fulfilled with regard to a satisfactory outcome.
Prior to the above-illustrated surge of spiritual consciousness that took place in the last decade, a situation was developing in the United States in which the characteristics of Eho in our society far outweighed any effects of Shoho that could be seen.
Ever since the Industrial Revolution, mercantile and military growth put the emphasis on systems and machines more than on the human factor. Every war was accompanied by staggering progress in scientific and technological fields, while the very fact that wars increased in frequency was proof of the fact that man was not making corresponding progress in dealing with his human condition.
Nevertheless, the harmful effects of an imbalance between Eho and Shoho began to tell following World War I, which was a generally healthy financial shot in the arm to the U.S. Investments and businesses grew too fast, resulting in wide-spread cutbacks in production and employment that ultimately created the Great Depression, a cruel blow dealt men by those very institutions they had cherished for so long.
In summary we can say that the events of recent years have shown, as previously noted, that a conflict between Eho and Shoho will lead to a situation that is far from ideal. In addition, Eho without Shoho has proven detrimental due to its lack of basic humanism while it can be supposed that Shoho without Eho might point up a lack of sorely needed pragmatism. An example of the former can be seen in the present-day busing controversy. Here is a case in which a system has been imposed which, although it is efficient and workable, seems to lack basic human considerations. Many agree on this shortcoming.
The fact is that America is now taking the first steps into her third century. It is a time for Eho and Shoho to harmoniously come into balance if she is to fulfill her aspirations for the future. An understanding of past conflicts and imbalances will help to pave the way for true Esho Funi. The process of wide-spread human revolution is the key to achieving this.
[The advent of the mass demonstration was symptomatic of conditions in the mid-sixties. Held for a variety of reasons, these gatherings became the focal point for expressing popular disillusionment and confusion. As such, they served as real manifestations of the deep conflict between ‘Shoho’ and ‘Eho,’ rarely resolving anything and often creating even deeper dissatisfaction with social conditions.]
Esho Funi & Human Behavior
So far we have examined the relationship of Esho Funi to the flow of historical currents, but if we fail to take a look at what comprises the currents — the actions of the human beings that make history — then we’ll never comprehend Esho Funi at a personal level.
Perhaps the broad statement should first be made that everyday human behavior can be classified into two categories. The first, falling into the realm of what might be termed natural science, deals with a human being’s physical and material interaction with his environment, i.e. his attempts to change external circumstances or construct something tangible for himself. Applying our previous definitions of Shoho and Eho to this aspect, it clearly falls within the area of Eho.
The second human behavior we might classify as social science, in which man attempts to set up lines of communication between himself, other men, his family, his society, etc. This results in the formation of bonds and systematic relationships — certainly less tangible than environmental artifacts, yet every bit as essential to human survival. These relationships and bonds, based as they are upon human emotion and intellect, fall within the area of Shoho.
In simpler terms, what we are dealing with here is the question of practical vs. abstract principles which govern human behavior. The question of whether we pay primary attention to changing our environment or changing our behavior might well be said to be the primary source of conflict in human history.
The important thing is that man should begin to recognize the fact that his approach to life is determined by the extent to which he combines Shoho and Eho in his life. Two people starting from the exact same intellectual and emotional origins may go in completely different directions depending on the amount of energy they invest in self-realization (Shoho) or in shaping the physical world (Eho).
In America’s two-hundred-year history, our expansion and growth as a nation can be viewed from these standpoints. The original Pilgrims landed in Massachusetts driven by a desire to find spiritual freedom, (Shoho). However, in landing there they found themselves confronting a new and hostile environment and had to challenge harsh physical realities and meet material needs (Eho).
Looking at the long history of our country, we can see the constant intermeshing between spiritual drives and material challenges, from the Revolutionary War through the westward expansion through our positioning as an international power following World War I.
There are many other examples of the ways in which the concepts of Eho and Shoho have proven critical in the course of man’s philosophical and historical development. For instance, the idea that man’s total value lies in the sum of his efforts might lead either to Marxism (with an emphasis on Eho) or Sartre’s Existentialism (stressing only Shoho). Introspective beatnik or irate revolutionary — it all depends on where you channel your energies, toward the political and economic environment or toward a self-involved effort at spiritual awareness. Somehow it just naturally becomes obvious that the ideal lies somewhere in a healthy balance between the two.
Taken from the broadest possible historical viewpoint, the present loss of human dignity so acutely felt in our society may stem from causes as far back as the Renaissance. The Renaissance was that greatest of all spiritual movements in its origin which allowed man to free himself. With this new-found freedom came the realization that the pursuit of desires was not so evil as had previously been supposed. In pursuing his desires, man began to learn that he could mold and shape the environment to fit human demands. Art, science and economy all began to reflect man’s growing ability to shape a world in which he could find comfort and satisfy need.
This investment of time and energy in our environment seems today to have gotten out of hand. From the Renaissance to the present, human beings have grossly over-emphasized their attention to external affairs. As a result, the balance of Esho Funi has become severely disturbed. What must be realized is that the oneness expressed by the Esho Funi principle is the ideal, not necessarily the reality. To approach the true balance between Eho and Shoho is our greatest challenge as human beings.
What has caused the human race to become so narrow-minded? Why has man so recently become enamoured of his material existence — what makes him believe that this is happiness? One answer might be that man has come to consider himself as something truly unique, something set apart from the rest of nature.
[The Pilgrims, motivated at first by purely spiritual needs, soon found that they had to contend in very physical ways with the wilderness of an untamed land if they were ever going to achieve some semblance of a happy and orderly life.]
This is a belief deeply ingrained in each of us and stems from ancient teachings implying that man is meant to be master of all he surveys and that he is created in the image of perfect divinity.
Buddhism, however, takes severe exception to this belief. In essence, the lesson of Esho Funi is that man is a part of nature. We exist because of our environment and our environment exists because of us; there are not two separate entities. Perhaps this is easier to understand if we heed Buckminster Fuller’s words about living on “Spaceship Earth.” Our planet, viewed from space, is nothing but a huge vessel carrying the crew of humanity. From this perspective it is easy to see that we totally depend on the stability of our ship, while she serves no purpose if we are not aboard.
Nichiren Daishonin wrote about the nature of non-sentient life in his Somoku Jobutsu Ketsu. He said that even trees can attain enlightenment. In other words, both sentient (Shoho) and non-sentient (Eho) beings are all expressions of life. Simply put, people cannot be separated from the food we eat, nor fish from the sea they swim in. All serve the function of life. As living creatures, we derive our nourishment from food which in itself lives due to its ability to nourish. We should continuously be aware of this relationship with our environment and be more respectful of it.
The importance of maintaining our awareness about the environment is clear if we realize that ultimately our own human attitude (Shoho) will reflect in our surroundings (Eho). Anger we feel will manifest itself around us, as will laziness or responsibility. Ultimately our attitude controls both the tangible and intangible aspects of our relationships to other men, nations or nature itself.
Because what we do as individuals seems to hold the key, this is the last part of the puzzle to put into place. The purpose of understanding Esho Funi is not just to realize that we are part of the whole world’s history or nature. Ultimately our grasp of Esho Funi will allow us to fundamentally change the world and contribute to the betterment of all humanity. Franklin Roosevelt put it eloquently when he said, “We are faced with a pre-eminent fact that if civilization is to survive, we must cultivate the science of human relationships, the ability of peoples of all kinds to live together and work together in the same world at peace.”
Esho Funi and the Individual
What we finally arrive at is the question of what we as individuals can do using the theory of Esho Funi to make a difference. The Gosho states, “Our environment of ten directions is Eho and the people are Shoho. Eho is like the shadow, while Shoho is the body. Where there is no body there is no shadow and where there is no Shoho there is no Eho.”
Conversely, because we as human beings create value in our environment, it becomes equally obvious that without our environment our lives are meaningless. As human beings we can view our lives in two ways with respect to Eho and Shoho. The first way is to see our intelligence, emotions, attitudes, and goals — our whole mind or Ichinen — as being Shoho while the way in which our body responds to this Ichinen is considered Eho. The second way, as discussed before, is to consider the totality of our lives, body and mind, as
[Buckminister Fuller’s radical concept of a “spaceship earth” provides a scientific framework for understanding ‘Esho Funi.’ His innovations of the Dymaxion map and allocation of world resources clarify both the necessity of man re-educating himself with regard to interaction with his environment and the suggested directions that he might take in doing so.]
Shoho, while the environment is Eho.
To give an example: An employee whose attitude towards his job is good and who hopes to get ahead will express his feelings through his alertness, his quickness, even his tone of voice. As a result, such an employee will gradually gain the trust of his boss, be given greater responsibilities and eventually come to have a hand in designing and revamping systems at his place of work.
This may seem complicated and yet the distinction is necessary because they point out that the entire principle of Esho Funi is generated by our own Ichinen. Because this Ichinen is generally determined by our philosophy of life, the laws and precepts to which we adhere become of critical importance.
If these laws or precepts determine the Ichinen of those who believe in them, then they are in a sense Shoho to the believer’s Eho. Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism says that, because the Gohonzon represents the ultimate law of the universe, those who believe in it will come to manifest the basic dignity and eternity of life. Individuals in such a life-condition are capable of doing great things and affecting their environment in a number of valuable and natural ways.
In talking about the Gohonzon and Nam-myoho-renge-kyo as the law of the universe in his Rissho Ankoku Ron (“Treatise on the Pacification of the Land through the Establishment of True Buddhism”), Nichiren Daishonin said that, because the Law is respectworthy, the people are respectworthy and ultimately the land will become respectworthy. He did not mean that the law equals the people equals the land. They are all different and yet together they share a continuum of relationships in which all aspects of life affect one another.
Sometimes NSA junior leaders will say to their members, “Don’t get Esho Funied.” This slang (although inaccurate because Esho Funi is an interaction rather than a one-sided force) is meant to convey that a person shouldn’t allow himself to be swayed from a long-range goal because he perceives distracting, short-lived possibilities for happiness in his immediate environment. The term Zuijii refers to a situation in which a person takes command and the initiative for Esho Funi, whereas the term Zuitai indicates the adaptation of the individual to his circumstances — the person who has been “Esho Funied.”
Obviously, to be people in a condition of Zuijii is the goal of Nichiren Shoshu believers. In addition, there is another term called Zuiho Bini which is most valuable in helping us to understand how to use Esho Funi when going from one situation to another. What Zuiho Bini indicates is that, although superficial customs and traditions may vary from place to place, the underlying principles of Buddhism to do not change. A person going to an NSA meeting in New York may find it very different than Seattle, yet the underlying message about the validity of the Gohonzon and Nam-myoho-renge-kyo never changes. On a personal level, no matter what environmental circumstances confronts us, the immutable power of the Gohonzon inside us remains constant. The classical example used to illustrate this is the fact that second President Josei Toda attained his enlightenment in prison.
Viewed from the principle of Zuiho Bini, we can better understand the call of General Director George M. Williams when he urges us to “Discover a New America.” He is definitely not saying that we should go out and find another continent since our efforts on this one have failed. Neither is he saying that we should all don wigs and emulate the behavior and activities of Washington, Jefferson and Adams. What he does mean is that, utilizing the basic spirit of our Founding Fathers, we should strive to revitalize the ideals of democracy in our nation, working within the already established structure and traditions of our society.
When we come to realize that the new frontier is inside of us, the world opens up limitless horizons for us to pursue. Nichiren Daishonin said that the universe itself lies within the narrow confines of our “three-inch” heart — the source of our own life. This proves the need for our own human revolution — the power which it releases being enough, as President Ikeda says, “to enable all mankind to change its destiny.”
[It is imperative that man gain a new perspective on his place in the natural order of things. The time has passed when the human being could consider himself as separate from and superior to the environment that he lives in.]
