Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Summer 1975 · Features

Happiness — the Goal Many Americans Forgot

NSA Quarterly, Summer 1975 (Vol. 3, No. 3), pp. 127–133. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

A commentary on the climate of our times, and the possibilities they hold for our future.

Excuse me, would you like to come to a discussion meeting about happiness?”

He acts as if he doesn’t hear you, pulling his wool collar up and focusing on some non-existent point of interest, plunging on across the rain-soaked parking lot.

“Excuse me, I would like to invite you to a meeting of Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism . . .” you say.

“What?” the young man replies, halting tentatively amidst the cars, frowning through his wet glasses.

“Yes, it’s a philosophy of happiness. You can achieve anything in the world you want to make you happy by. . .”

“What are you talking about. I am happy,” he growls. “And what’s happiness got to do with anything?” he says as if angered by your words.

You try again, hoping he will hear.

“This is a meeting of a philosophy of happiness, it’s what everyone is looking for. See, it makes us happy. Why don’t you come with us and. . .”

‘Oh, come on. What are you people talking about! Why don’t you wake up to reality. This happiness stuff is just stupid. Now leave me alone — I gotta get some groceries and get home to my wife; she’s sick. Just leave me alone!”

He turns abruptly and walks away, unaware that the most important thirty seconds of his life have just passed . . . and he missed them.

To most Americans, the young man is right — happiness is stupid.

The reason is obvious — they see no solutions to their problems and so have stopped looking.

“Look at technology and science. Fifty years ago, that seemed to be the answer. But take the automobile, for instance, that seemed like a great invention — now all we hear is how much it pollutes the atmosphere,” the young man might have said.

‘So science doesn’t work — what does? Christianity? Communism? Flag-waving Americanism? Listen, those have all been tried before and look where they got us — nowhere,” he might add.

Many Americans today are just like that young man — convinced that their lot in life is unchangeable. They are caught in a quagmire of apathy, indifference, alienation or outright revolt. They are divorced from their country and from themselves.

America, to many citizens, is like the mother who speaks of love to her children, but rebuffs the response to her words. The American mystique is that ours is a land of unlimited opportunity, but millions of Americans find a far different reality.

They also see that while scientific solutions only compound present problems, no retreat from modern technology is possible.

That is the classic example of what behavioral scientists call “the double bind” when speaking of schizophrenic or alienated children.

Behavioral scientists say the “double bind” leads to disassociation by the child, who learns to mistrust what he feels as well as the world around him. A child caught in a double bind doubts his own value and often acts out of frustration and resentment, social scientists say. Such conduct brings a rebuff from those around him, confirming his own feelings of inadequacy and convincing him that worthlessness is his lot in life.

The majority of Americans today are apathetic towards personal problems and those of their country.

Author Harry Stack Sullivan said in The Psychiatric Interview:

“Apathy is a curious state. It is a way used to survive defeat without material damage, although if it endures too long one is damaged by the passage of time. Apathy seems to me to be a miracle of protection by which a personality in utter fiasco rests until it can do something else.”

Commenting on the above analysis, Rollo May remarks:

“The longer the situation goes unmet, the more apathy is prolonged; and it sooner or later becomes a character state . . . a freezing in the face of hyperstimuli, letting the current go by since one fears he would be overwhelmed if he responded to it. No one who has ever ridden the subway at rush hour, with its cacaphonous din and hordes of anonymous humanity, will be surprised at this.”

A characteristic disease of our time is the fear of involvement which, coupled with a mistrust of self, makes our own actions seem risky. The classic case was the slaying of Kitty Genovese in March, 1964, as she was returning home from work late at night in New York City. Although she fought off her attacker for half an hour while at least 38 of her neighbors watched from their apartment windows, no one made even an anonymous call to the police.

In a recent address, psychologist Philip Zimbardo of Stanford University said:

“From a recent study at Princeton University we learn that one of the reasons we don’t help a fellow in distress is not because we have grown callous, but simply because we don’t have time, we’re in too much of a hurry. In this study theology students were on their way to deliver a sermon on the parable of the Good Samaritan. Some of them had been told by the experimenters they were late, others that they had time . . . each theology student came across a man who was lying in an alleyway moaning and covered with blood. . .

‘Only ten percent of those in a hurry to give the Good Samaritan sermon stopped to aid a victim in distress. The more time they thought they had, the more likely they were to stop.

‘People who violate basic laws of humanity often . . . rationalize their behavior according to some principle acceptable to others in their society . . .”

In short, evil or aggressive acts are not the province of a malevolent sub-group, but a potential in each of us.

How can we break through the rigid spaces between us, establishing trust and cooperation where now only fear exists? Professor Zimbardo offered this solution to the problem of eroding trust among people:

“Make other people feel wanted, recognized and worth while — your employees, your kids and even strangers; make the time to help someone in distress; look at your own possible evil actions not from a Self-justifying perspective, but from that of someone else; don’t reject people because they are different from you in appearance or ideas, instead try to appreciate the basis for that difference.

“As we approach the bicentennial year of our nation, I encourage you to help prevent evil by promoting the old-fashioned virtues of neighborhood and community values.”

These words are reminiscent of Nichirenshoshu which has carried on as a little-known religious group for seven hundred years. Despite imprisonment of its lay leaders during World War II, the group continued to resist the war and the abuse of human life.

Upon his release, the surviving leader, Josei Toda, immediately began reconstructing the organization to reduce the likelihood of future wars on all levels by subduing “the war” within each person and expanding to the global scale of world peace.

Toda was following the precedent begun seven centuries before by the founder, Nichiren Daishonin. Toda understood how to awaken in a devastated people the desire, not simply to survive, but to evolve as individuals despite the difficult post-war conditions.

The philosophy of Nichiren Daishonin provides modern man with a practical method for reversing the “diminishing force of grace, discrimination, intellect and feeling” which Paul Goodman saw as sacrificed in Growing Up Absurd in America. Through chanting Nam-myoho-renge-kyo to the object of worship — the Gohonzon — people gain wisdom and a revitalized life-force in the same way that an iron chip becomes magnetized by constant rubbing against a magnet.

Just as the iron chip acquires north and south poles and the power to attract other iron filings through that exchange, so people manifest their latent wisdom by establishing harmony with the larger universe as represented in the Gohonzon.

This process is similar to what Florian Znaniecki calls the “participant observer technique,” which involves understanding social actions by performing them oneself rather than first attempting to comprehend them intellectually.

“When I wish to ascertain at first hand what a certain activity is . . . I try to experience it. There is only one way to experience an object, that is to observe it personally. There is only one Way of experiencing an activity; it is to perform it personally. Practical men insist on this; they will tell you that you cannot fully realize what they are doing until you do it yourself. Scientists have come to recognize this,” Znaniecki said.

Znaniecki’s open-minded, participatory spirit demonstrates an approach viewed by most social scientists as a prerequisite for healing alienated individuals who make UP a society with multiple fractures as in America today.

Critics are divided between hope and despair on the issue of prognosis for this patient — mankind. Some base hopes on the dramatic changes in perception of social and intra-personal issues we have experienced in the last decade.

Critic Kenneth Kenniston says that:

“The turning point at which we stand today requires a . . . translation of already existing dreams of human fulfillment and social diversity into the concrete goals of individuals and of our society. The values we need are deeply rooted in our own tradition: we must merely begin to take them seriously.” Ideals must be translated into realities.

This “translation” of the theoretical into the concrete is the core of the problem — indeed, of most problems. Kenniston’s call for the alienated to ‘resolve their alienations by committing themselves — through the analysis, synthesis, and reform of their own lives and worlds — to the preparation of . . . anew society . . .” does not provide a course of concrete action.

Social observers Thomas Hanna and Charles Reich see change in the next few decades as an irresistible evolution, like it or not. No specific course of action by individuals is required, they imply. Social interaction will naturally result in what Hanna calls the “protomutant,” and Reich terms “Consciousness III.” The visible evidence they cite is the so-called “counterculture” or youth sub-culture of today.

France’s Jean Francois Revel also finds hope in the youth counter-culture. Basing his conclusions on the effectiveness of the anti-war movement in the United States in altering public policy in the Vietnam War, Revel says in his book, Without Marx or Jesus:

“The revolution of the 20th century will take place in the United States. It is only there that it can happen. And it has already begun. Whether or not that revolution spreads to the rest of the world depends on whether or not it succeeds first in America.”

But Urie Bronfenbrenner sees a waning of radical youth in the 1970’s replaced by a still younger generation filled with cynicism. Accompanying this cynicism is a feeling of powerlessness and of having already been defeated.

Bronfenbrenner cites a decrease in spheres of interaction between parents and children since 1950 as the reason for this malaise. Children are spending time with the television set and their peer groups that formerly had been spent interacting with adults. The home — once a dynamic center for individual communication and value formation — is now a refuge from the cruel realities of outside life, he says.

Those qualities that Bronfenbrenner sees missing in American children are the same qualities which other contemporary social analysts find vital to unify modern man with himself and those around him:

“. . . the young person in America finds himself in a profound and crippling moral dilemma. He identifies with the ideals and values of his society, but he has been taught to recognize the widespread betrayal of these ideals and values in everyday life, and has been given only minimal exposure to the substantial achievements of the ideal, and . . . to the concrete courses of action through which the ideal might be pursued. Neither in school nor in the university, is he given much information or . . . experience in how to use the institutions of his society . . . to remedy social and political ills . . . all he knows is the simplistic, one-shot (demand or destroy) so characteristic of the context in which he has spent so much time — the age-segregated peer group and the commercial television screen.”

It is an indictment of adults for not getting involved with one another and with the younger generation.

Most contemporary psychological theories see these interpersonal relationships as an antidote for alienation of adults as well as their developing children. But, most of the current social theories of human fulfillment are conceptual drawings of finished architecture rather than concrete blueprints and construction work orders. In other words, they present no course of action and do not deal with men as they are.

Most of us have experienced pain from trying to establish even basic human relationships or in trying to change such simple but destructive habits as smoking or littering — habits which have disappeared into the fabric of our lives like a thread immersed in a bolt of cloth.

Often the presence of others going through similar struggles is helpful in focusing attention and fighting discouragement before success can be achieved. An example is the success of such organizations as Alcoholics Anonymous and Synanon, which utilize shared experiences, supportive inter-personal involvement and honest behavorial feedback.

These groups are useful for those desperate enough about a particular problem to involve themselves. But they are useful only in solving that single, identifiable problem.

For the bulk of humanity, however, the stigmatizing admission of failure outweighs the rewards of joining such groups. Most people don’t feel that their unhappiness is caused by a single problem or that their lives are dangerously out of control — they are simply-painfully-unrewarding. Such people are alienated from their own existence.

But, as Arthur Koestler pessimistically observed, man is “deaf to persuasion.”

“All efforts of persuasion by reasoned argument rely on the implicit assumption that homo sapiens, although occasionally blinded by emotion, is a basically rational animal, aware of the motives of his own actions and beliefs — an assumption which is untenable in the light of both historical and neurological evidence. (Only if there were) a spontaneous change in human mentality all over the world — the equivalent of a major biological mutation ... would mankind as a whole, from its political leaders down to the lonely crowd, become receptive to those unorthodox measures which would enable it to meet the challenge.”

Koestler, like almost every other serious observer, seems to be calling for a change in consciousness and, lacking any tool to implement it, pessimistically decides such a change is, at best, highly unlikely.

According to Willis Harmon, it is impossible to deal with fundamental problems of human relationships when our assumptions about human nature are flawed.

‘The nation is beset by numerous social problems — poverty, crime, racial discrimination, civil disorder, unemployment, pollution, and the like. Attempts to deal straightforwardly with these problems — to tackle discrimination with civil-rights legislation, to alleviate the ills of poverty with minimum-wage laws and welfare payments, to eliminate ghettos with urban-renewal programs, to deal with civil disorders by increasing police power — typically have unexpected and unintended outcomes. It is as though an ‘ecology of situations’ were upset by a piecemeal approach.

“The most carefully designed social measures will not achieve their desired goals unless they involve not only rationally designed programs and Structures, but also changes in deeply-rooted beliefs, values, attitudes and behavior patterns, both of the individuals who constitute the problem populations and of the self-righteous others who assume that they are not implicated.

“It may be with our social problems that the significant constructive change is first of all an inner one rather than outer, and in the direction of recognizing the hidden lies and resolving the hidden divisions. Just as it is possible for a person to have a pathological set of beliefs about himself, so it may be possible for our society to possess a disfunctional belief and value system.”

Harmon defines the problem as ineffectual or distorted beliefs or values, but cannot recommend any practical solution.

People, then, act in accordance with their beliefs, preconceptions and prejudices. Belief is a lens through which they view the world. Exchanging one lens for another will change their focus and actions; if the lens is distorted, they may stumble and fall based on those false perceptions of reality.

However, people are almost as unaware of their value set and its influence on their perceptions as of the muscle movements when focusing their eyes. These things have become automatic, no matter how distorted or crippling they may be. Rational discussion alone is not the way to balance distorted beliefs or values, because those are a result of personal experience. Intellectual concepts are fitted to them afterwards to explain that experience.

In everyday life, it would appear an unbreakable cycle — a man’s experiences give rise to his beliefs, and his beliefs reflect his experiences. How, then, can men achieve what all social philosophers say they must — a revolution of nature, a human revolution of the self?

Some philosophies attempt to do this by altering man’s external environment, i.e. by imposing a strict code of behavior, such as dietary habits, dress codes or social restrictions.

These restrictions tend to reinforce the group by separating its members from others, but it is debatable that they change a man’s consciousness.

Buddhism deals with the essence of the problem — man himself. A different vision of the world and that of man himself is the result.

The new practitioner of Buddhism is like a person who has been blind all his life and is suddenly able to see.

British physicist David Bohm describes the process of sight in infants — a process similar to the experiences of those who begin to practice Buddhism.

‘When he (the infant) first gains vision, he does not perceive objects as such, nor does not generally understand what appears in his field of vision. It takes a long time (possibly years) of relating vision to touch and bodily movements before such understanding develops. He has thus learned how optical sensations are to be related to bodily movements and tactile perception.” In physical terms, the child is learning to relate to his environment.

The person who begins the practice of Buddhism experiences widened perspectives similar to those of the infant experiencing sight. He naturally learns mastery of causality in human life by application of the philosophy changing his negative destiny or karma (the cumulative effect of countless negative or life-denying causes) and accumulating fortune (a pattern of positive effects gained through accumulation of positive causes).

None of this is based on blind belief or rational argument, but rather upon personal experience. As each new NSA member perceives the law of cause and effect as it relates to his life. he also learns to positively influence his life. The natural result is increasingly positive feedback from the environment — his job, his wife, etc. As these exterior influences confirm a more and more positive self-image, self-concern is shed in preference for an unselfish dialogue with others. It is the same goal which social philosophers have long sought — a new consciousness, Dialogue is the foundation of the NSA organization. Although no shared beliefs form the sort of “creed” the Western world expects from a religion, NSA members are united On One vital issue — the fundamental value of human life. Rather than a creed espoused at conversion, this invariable arises in the course of practicing Buddhism. It is what modern critics see as essential for uniting an alienated society — enlightened consciousness.

Bohm speaks of the importance of such dialogue among people, saying that “the insoluble failure of communication that is now being encountered in almost every phase of life” is a result of people refusing to consider others’ ideas.

“One of the most important reasons for failure of a true dialogue to arise between people is that each person tends to regard himself as existing separately from the others and from the world as a whole.”

Such a person is — in a word — alienated.

With an open dialogue it becomes natural to form bonds with others, even those who have diverse backgrounds. In the NSA organization, humanistic involvement and altruistic actions are nurtured because of the tremendous growth potential implicit in such actions. Through a steady flow of episodes of individual life-to-life dialogues in NSA, each person’s life is enriched.

President Daisaku Ikeda describes the standard of evaluation for individual and group goals:

“.. . The humanistic way of thought should be the basis for the selection of different means or methods in the pursuit of the goal. This humanistic way of thinking means to recognize the highest value in each individual person’s life. Ultimately, human life itself should be, not the means, but the end, no matter what subsidiary goals one may have.

“Of course, it is always respectworthy for a person to devote his entire life to one goal. This is the essence of expressions like ‘living for an ideal’ or *having a purpose to life.’ When a person lacks such a goal or ideal, he is destined to be unhappy and is already dead while still alive.

‘Only with such an ideal can one always progress on a new and limitless path of life. And only with this attitude does human wisdom spring forth.”

[The fresh feeling each member of the Fife and Drum Corps receives through their practice to the Gohonzon is an answer to the lack of humanism common today. True Buddhism shows how to revitalize the life-condition of each individual.]