Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Fall 1975 · Features

Newspapers: Mirror of the Times

News Views

NSA Quarterly, Fall 1975 (Vol. 3, No. 4), pp. 144–147. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

By Gary McCarty

It is said that Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) was the last man who knew everything about the world he lived in. But today, life is vastly more complex. Even where a person may feel helpless to change chaotic events, he may challenge and know himself better by striving to know his world.

The working conditions were not the best: the pay was low; you thought you were serving the public, but you could never please anybody. After working all day, you might get a comment like this: “The lowest depth to which people can sink before God is defined by the word ‘journalist.’ ”

Conditions at newspapers have improved in the years since the Danish philosopher, Soren Kierkegaard, penned those words, until today journalists at the major outlets have risen to the ranks of the professional. At the Washington Post, in fact, a writer can earn not only national recognition, but also $23,309 annually after five years on the job.

[A free press is a powerful force to keep democracies honest and responsive to the people’s voice. In this 1936 photograph, newsmen gather in a make-shift press room to cover the execution of convicted kidnapper Bruno Richard Hauptmann.]

The contemporary American newspaper owes its origins to Great Britain, where underground publications called Intelligencers first appeared to report news of foreign wars — news that was often suppressed by the crown. In the decades after their emergence, debate over freedom of speech and of the press rocked parliament until newspapers were granted the right of publication.

With the colonization of America, these Intelligencers were transplanted and served the revolutionary forces as the thirteen original colonies struggled for independence. Then, with independence and the search to secure the United States’ economic survival, the newspapers began serving commercial masters as they flourished in port cities with news of arrivals and departures of ships and with notices of auctions and sales. A similar change had already occurred in England.

This rivalry between serving two masters — the public and the monied interests — forced newspapers into a schizoid existence ever since. As a consequence, when America has been peaceful and calm, newspapers tend to be docile and non-controversial. When the government and the public are at odds, newspapers begin flexing their muscles, as during the Vietnamese war and the Watergate scandal.

Still, newspapers went unchallenged in the field of reporting and formulating public opinion until the emergence of radio. They were especially hard pressed during the Great Depression when they lost many of their advertising dollars to the new elective media. Then, with the rise of television after World War II, an even worse turn of economic events forced scores of newspapers to merge or even fold. Today it is not unusual to find only two newspapers in the nation’s larger cities.

As the 1960s approached, newspapers found the competition growing stiffer and stiffer. Both the ABC and CBS broadcasting networks increased their nightly news programs from fifteen to thirty minutes in 1963, and ABC followed in 1967. Increasingly, the American public was beginning to rely on television for its “window on the world.” Newspapers and newspapermen were forced to react.

Editors and publishers restylized their products, decreasing the number of columns, using more and bigger photographs, employing bolder layouts and allowing their writers to grapple with problems going to the root of the American consciousness itself. In so doing, they were approaching the goal that social critic Walter Lippmann had once set as the ideal — providing “a true picture of life.”

One group of writers, found at newspapers scattered from coast to coast but concentrated in New York, decided the solution was a whole new approach to journalistic writing itself — the adaptation of fictionalized prose to news itself. The members of this group heralded themselves as “the new journalists.” Proponents included Gay Talese, Jimmy Breslin and Tom Wolfe. Wolfe himself once said that to correctly convey the subject of his article a writer must live through the event itself. Thus, if Wolfe were doing an interview with a certain public figure, he would live with that person for three or four days and then write his story with lengthy, penetrating quotations from the source himself.

Explained Clay Felker, editor of New York magazine and godfather of “New Journalism” in the 1960s: “We had to do something TV couldn’t do. It wasn’t enough to give interpretation. We had to give style too.”

Such comments won a ringing retort from Los Angeles Times Editor William Thomas:

[Newsmen accept the responsibility of keeping track of what the government is doing. Here, President Ford leads reporters on a chase back to his plane, trying to avoid questions about Vietnam. (UPI Photo).]

“We’re opening up the pages to elements of society never before covered. At the same time, we run the danger of closing out what used to be the Establishment voice. We don’t listen enough to business. The old Establishment voices aren’t in the paper enough. Often we put them in the same category that blacks occupied fifteen years ago.”

With the advent of Watergate, Vietnam and other crises that once again pitted the press against the government, Wolfe and his fellow travelers found their brand of writing less and less in vogue. Today, the biggest crisis seems to be the almost humdrum level of activities — or scandals — radiating from Washington, followed closely by the staggering rise in the cost of producing a newspaper. The price of newsprint, for instance, now stands at $260 a ton, a forty per cent increase in the past year and a half.

This price increase has forced new changes on newspapers. The Christian Science Monitor altered its format from a standard-size newspaper to a tabloid, and the Los Angeles Times opted to decrease the width of its paper by three-quarters of an inch. Less space means an altered approach to writing, but the approach has yet to be systematized. So, as it stands today, the newspaper of the future is still very much an issue open for discussion.

In a questionnaire mailed to editors, publishers, advertising executives and journalism professors a few years back, inquiries were made as to what the average newspaper of the 1980s would look and read like. The only agreement seemed to be that the average newspaper would change very little as the years rolled by. This viewpoint seemed to be best expressed by then Columbia University Editor-in-Residence Norman E. Isaacs, who said:

“My general answer is that change is constant within newspapering, but it is agonizingly slow. The newspapers in the 1980s probably will look somewhat cleaner in typographic approach, there will be better writing and if they are measured, say 1972 against 1983, the changes will be reasonably substantial. But year by year, it will appear (and be) glacial in movement.”

Copley Newspapers’ Walter Swanson concurred and amplified on Isaacs’ statement:

“If someone makes the newspaper into something like a Life or Look in their latter days, I will probably want to curl up with a good book or look at television, where I can get a subject either with less effort or in greater depth. Our good 20th-century newspaper is like the car, a great and convenient invention of our times; until someone invents levitation, perhaps we will do well to simply improve it and make it run without smog.”

Whatever the course newspapers may take in the years and decades ahead, it seems certain that they are a part of life in democracies that we can never let lapse into oblivion. As Thomas Jefferson once said: “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.”