Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Summer 1974 · Features

Buffeting Winds

The Human Revolution

NSA Quarterly, Summer 1974 (Vol. 2, No. 3), pp. 82–91. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

DOUGLAS MACARTHUR’S annual message was rather unusual: on New Year’s Day 1950. It began: “To the people of Japan. On this fifth New Year’s Day following hostilities’ end, one fact inescapably stands out—although Japan is still technically at war, there are few places on earth more completely at peace.” his was of course an allusion to Japan’s demilitarized state. The end of the message, however, contained a surprising twist, something that was possibly MacArthur’s newest interpretation of the famous no-war clause in the Japanese constitution.

“While by no sophistry of reasoning can it be interpreted as complete negation of the inalienable right of self-defense against unprovoked attack, it is a ringing affirmation, by a people laid prostrate by the sword, of faith in the ultimate triumph of international morality and justice without resort to the sword. It must be understood, however, that so long as predatory international banditry is permitted to roam the earth to crush human freedom under its avarice and violence, the high concept to which you are pledged will be slow in finding universal acceptance.”

By “predatory international banditry” MacArthur apparently meant the victory of the People’s Republic of China over the Nationalist Chinese forces. This altered view of the no-war stipulation in the constitution reflected a new evaluation of Japan’s international role in the face of mounting tensions between the free and Communist camps. But how were the people of Japan to know who was right? It is true that the Americans repeatedly emphasized the importance of justice, but then, so did the Communists. The definitions of justice of the two sides differed, but there was nothing to indicate that either was intrinsically more just than the other. it symbolized was certainly the new approach to the no-war clause. When the constitution was promulgated, MacArthur had nothing but praise for the Japanese renunciation not only of military establishments, but also of the right of belligerence. Now when it seemed possible that Japanese assistance might be needed against the forces of communism, the Americans were changing their tune. According to the new posture, the no-war clause does not deny the inalienable right of self-defense.

Shigeru Yoshida, the prime minister at the time, adjusted his stance to that of the Americans. Four years earlier, at a plenary session of the lower house of the Diet, a Communist leader named Sanzo Nosaka had put a question to Yoshida about the nature of the constitutional renunciation of war and had asked how it affects self-defense. To that question Yoshida had replied: “As regards the clause on renunciation of war in the draft of the new constitution, you think that war for the purpose of self-defense ought to be recognized. But I feel strongly that such thinking is dangerous and harmful. . . . It is a well-known historical fact that many recent wars have been waged in the name of self-defense. For us to approve war for the purpose of self-defense would be dangerous and might lead to hostilities and run counter to the spirit of an international peace organization, when such an organization is established.”

On January 23, 1950, following MacArthur’s New Year’s address in the newspapers, Yoshida, in an administrative policy speech before the Diet, had a very different comment to make: “Quite naturally, grave concern has been voiced regarding the future security of Japan. Let me say that the key to our security lies in the very determination on our part to abide fully by the constitution, which renounces war and armaments, and to devote ourselves to the cause of world peace, civilization, and prosperity.

.. . Renunciation of war does not mean abandonment of the right of self-defense.”

As was only to be expected, the statements by MacArthur and Yoshida touched off controversy throughout the country about the true meaning of the no-war clause and about the related issue of possible rearmament. But these were only the forerunners of much more serious developments.

On January 31, 1950, a whole array of top American military leaders— including General Omar Bradley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff: General Joseph Collins, chief of staff of the United States Army; Admiral Forrest Sherman, chief of naval operations; General Hoyt Vandenberg, chief of staff of the United States Air Force; and others—arrived in Japan to inspect eight American air bases and two naval bases and to confer with General MacArthur. Patently, the main purpose of the visit was to assess the strategic value of Japan in connection with the growing tension between the East and the West.

Granted that Japan had the right to defend herself in case of unprovoked attack, outlining how she was to effect this defense within the framework of the peace constitution remained a controversial issue. Without some kind of defense mechanism, Japan could not protect herself at all. Obviously, then, the problem boiled down to defining the degree of armament she might possess. This issue was complicated by the nature of modern warfare, ch has now come to rely on at least the threat of nuclear weaponry. No amount of self-defense preparedness that fails to include nuclear weapons can be effective.

At the time, there were people who argued that Japan must become completely neutral, like Switzerland and Sweden. But neither the East nor the West was likely to endorse the neutrality of a nation that, though recently defeated in a major war, nonetheless possessed the greatest industrial capability in Asia. For many years to come, the self-defense dilemma was to plague Japan. A variety of solutions was to be suggested—for instance, ensuring Japan’s neutrality by stationing United Nations troops on her soil—but most of them were too visionary and idealistic to be of practical value.

Nuclear weaponry was at that time rapidly becoming a matter of grave concern for peoples everywhere, especially as the American and Soviet stockpiles of nuclear weapons threatened to grow. Japan, the only nation in the world ever to have suffered nuclear attack, was naturally most apprehensive about these weapons and the menace they posed to the survival of mankind. In 1949, a peace movement directed against nuclear weapons was born in Hiroshima. A petition signed by 107,854 objectors to such methods of warfare was sent to President Harry S. Truman, who refused to accept it. But Truman’s refusal in no way slowed down an antinuclear-weapons tide that was beginning to sweep the whole world.

In 1948. groups of intellectuals and scholars in a number of countries began postwar peace movements against nuclear weapons. In 1949, world congresses for the defense of peace were held in Prague and in Paris. A total of three thousand representatives from sixty-four nations attended the meetings, resulting in the formation of an executive committee with the aim of preventing both the spread of nuclear weapons and the rearming of Germany and Japan. In March, 1950 the first global conference against nuclear arms was held in Stockholm; and it adopted what is called the Stockholm Appeal, urging immediate bans on all nuclear weapons. This appeal, which was the crystallization of a longer movement, declared that any nation making use of nuclear arms would be regarded as a war criminal perpetrating crimes against mankind. In a period of eight months the Stockholm Appeal was signed by five hundred million people from all parts of the globe. Even in Japan, six and a half million signatures were obtained in spite of censorship, which screened out all news items about the appeal and about the operations of the executive committee formed at the world conferences for the defense of peace. In number of signatures on the Stockholm Appeal, Japan came third after Italy and France.

In 1950, people everywhere began to give serious consideration to the enormity of the threat presented by nuclear arms. They were gradually coming to see that this is an issue that cannot be solved by single nations or blocs of allies. The immense destructive power of modern nuclear weapons has removed warfare from the realm of old-fashioned military common sense. The fact that a disagreeent between nations with nuclear stockpiles might suddenly trigger attacks that could annihilate all mankind makes nonsense of the notion of war for the sake of national defense, since in such combat no one would survive. On the stage of international events, many complicated problems arise. All of them obviously deserve attention, but none is so pressing as devising a way to eliminate the danger of nuclear war because until that question has been safely and satisfactorily resolved solutions of all other issues are ultimately meaningless. A global nuclear catastrophe is not necessarily inevitably preordained. Mankind has created the monster weapon; therefore, it is within mankind's capability to control it.

The top leaders of nations in the modern world are like Damocles, over whose head a sword was suspended by a single hair. But their responsibility is infinitely greater. In front of each of them is the button that could launch a nuclear attack. In light of the threat of destruction posed by the atomic weapons of the potential enemy, if the likelihood of a nuclear attack from without should arise, no leader would have time to convene national assemblies for the sake of asking for formal declarations of war. He would feel compelled to push the button immediately and thus start what could become the end of everything.

But all these leaders are human beings. They all have loved ones and homes that they want to protect. If all top-echelon leaders were to meet with the express aim of banning nuclear weapons and giving to humanity the blessing of lasting peace, it is entirely likely that they would reach an agreement. The time has come to stop sending powerless government representatives to nuclear disarmament conferences and to insist that the men with the power assume the responsibility for making such meetings meaningful. When problems concerning international finance develop, the men holding real power in finance ministries and banks assemble to discuss the issues in person. Is it sensible, then, to send only second- or third-level representatives to deal with issues that directly affect the survival of mankind?

At a large meeting of the Youth Division held some years later, Josei Toda expressed his courageous and bold views of the nuclear-weapons sue: “I should like to take this opportunity to state clearly my opinions of the experimentations with nuclear weapons and hydrogen bombs that are currently stirring up a great deal of controversy. It is true that movements have been instigated to halt this kind of testing, but I feel we must make nuclear experiments completely harmless. The one way to do this is to decree the death penalty for anyone proposing to use nuclear weapons, no matter what his nation and no matter whether he is on the winning or losing side of a conflict.

“T feel this way because all of us, the ordinary people of this world, have the right to live. Anyone who attempts to deprive us of that right is a demon, a monster. People who would use nuclear weapons in war and in that way rob vast numbers of people of their lives deserve death. Should it ever happen that one nation conquers the whole world by means of nuclear weapons, it would be the duty of you, the young men and women of Japan, to spread throughout the globe the idea that such conquerors are diabolic fiends.”

Toda was aware that, at the time, he and the society he represented were too small and powerless to make their opinions felt on a large scale. He was nonetheless convinced that the time would come when Obutsu Myogo—the harmonious blending of Buddhism and all aspects of human society—would take place, and to that end he continued to train his faithful followers.

Many things made his task difficult. Among them was the rapidly worsening social condition of the Japanese people. In an article he wrote for Daibyakurenge Toda said: “The nation is filled with sorrow and suffering. Many people are out of work. Even those with jobs are unhappy; and without peace, happiness, and hope, human beings are truly miserable. lhe leaders of the nation tell us that we must lead a life of austerity. This may sound heroic, but in fact it spells only tragedy for the people. If politicians in power see nothing but austerity as a way out of our dilemma, perhaps the people must resign themselves to their lot. But there are limits to what the people will endure. They will not tolerate bad government forever.”

By “bad government” Toda meant the Dodge Line ninepoint stabilization program, which was wreaking havoc on the national economy. Big enterprises were forced to close large numbers of plants. They were lucky to be able to trim their sails. Small- and medium-size industries could not afford to cut back; they had to go bankrupt. Almost every day the newspapers carried stories of whole families who committed suicide because of financial disasters, sometimes aggravated by heavy taxes. On one occasion, Hayato Ikeda, minister of finance and later prime minister, made a statement that was incredibly callous: “An investigation would have to be made of the extent to which bankruptcy and heavy taxes have caused the suicides. But in times like these, when the nation has lost a war and when we are trying to control inflation, some sacrifices are inevitable. It cannot be helped if five or ten people commit suicide.” A remark of this kind from the finance minister incensed the people, but times were so difficult that they could do nothing to make their anger felt.

Toda and his new credit cooperative were faring no better than other small businesses of the time. Money was very scarce. Consequently, though there were countless people eager to borrow, Toda found it impossible to acquire the needed capital to operate. As if this were not bad enough, the failure of his publishing company dissuaded prospective investors from putting into the company the money that was so desperately needed. Week by week, funds dwindled. The shortage became more acute when, as often happened, it proved impossible to collect loans that had fallen due. In addition to the trials of the new company, Toda faced the liquidation of the publishing firm. Salaries to his employees were paid in installments and were behind schedule. After a while, several people left the company, and he would do nothing to try to stop them. As general director of the Sokagakkai, Toda never allowed his business worries to hinder him in carrying out his duties as leader and teacher. Though his daytime work taxed his mental and physical strength, he continued to hold discussion meetings and to offer counsel and help with his usual seriousness and compassion. But one thing about Sokagakkai began to trouble him. A number of old acquaintances, former disciples of Tsunesaburo Makiguchi who no longer took any active part in the work of Nichiren Shoshu or of Sokagakkai, had begun to frequent Toda’s offices. For a long time, none of them had shown his face except for so-called honorary staff appearances at general Sokagakkai conventions. Their exact purposes in calling on Toda now often were not clear, but desire for profit seems to have motivated them. They brought dubious investors and many loan seekers. All of this traffic contributed to bustle in the offices that gave people the erroneous impression that the credit cooperative was thriving. Toda knew better and was fully aware that the faithless old members of Soka-gakkai and their loan-seeking cohorts were not contributing to an improvement in conditions. This became manifestly clear whenever old acquaintances and customers disappeared without a trace when time came to collect an outstanding loan. Toda was disgusted with these people and let his feelings be known when he talked with the younger, faithful members of Sokagakkai: “We are an active, practicing organization. We don't need people like these men who have long since given up practicing their faith. They are worse than deadwood because they can be a source of real harm in the future. You young people must be reliable. You must grow quickly into fine members, because without you the future of Sokagakkai will be unsteady.” Old dropouts may have given Toda discouraging moments, but some of the younger members of the organization provided him with assistance in work and moral support. For instance, throughout the company’s dark times, Shin’ichi Yamamoto worked ceaselessly at tasks that he genuinely disliked and at which he was not very good. Since the opening of the credit cooperative, Yamamoto had been in charge of obtaining endorsements or support from creditors and of collecting—or trying to collect—outstanding loans. Because he was by nature timid and serious, the psychological demands of convincing and cajoling people left him exhausted at the end of every day. But he never sloughed his duties.

About a year earlier he had left his parents’ home and had rented z small, unheated apartment in Omori. Work kept him late at the office mor often than not. And when the innocent young man, who was only twenty two, returned to his cheerless room, he found that after chanting th Daimoku he had insufficient energy to do anything but go to bed. Fron time to time, physical weariness and loneliness made him want to rus} home to his parents and never leave them again. But one thing kept hin from taking that step: if his family could see how much damage overwork and long hours had done to his body, they would blame Toda. Because his devotion to his teacher was too great to allow him to hurt him in any way Yamamoto resolved to bear his loneliness.

A longing to cry out for help often filled his heart, but rather than give ir to grief he chanted the Daimoku, which gave him spiritual strength. If only his health had been better, he would have been able to stand the strain of work. But at the time, his body and his spirits had plunged to new depths.

As a self-discipline and to gain knowledge and courage, Yamamotc made it a rule to read one passage from the Gosho each night before going to sleep. After reading, he commented on the contents of the passage in his diary. Both the text and the act of thinking about it brightened the dark and lonely hours.

One night, as he was thumbing through the Kaimoku Sho, his eye was caught by: “When one leaves home and enters the priesthood, one will always save one’s parents.”

Reading this, Yamamoto felt as if Nichiren Daishonin were in a way endorsing the kind of life he had chosen for himself. It was true that he was not a priest, but he had left his home in order to devote himself to the great task of a religious revolution. All of the sufferings he endured seemed to augur well both for his own inner revolution and for the welfare of his parents. As he reflected on this situation, Yamamoto thought: “I must be strong now in the face of suffering. I can do it; I am still young. All I have to do is allow courage and happiness to well up from within me and keep moving forward. The Dai-Gohonzon is watching everything I do. I don’t have to worry about people who scoff or laugh.”

Lying on his back in his cold, narrow room, he thought deeply about the present crisis in the company and the effects it would have on his future. His throat was clogged with phlegm—a painful reminder that his tuberculosis was far from cured—but the willpower and sense of purpose filling his heart would enable him to go on with courage and determination.

[hough Yamamoto found courage to help him stand firm in the winds of trouble buffeting him, Toda, and their business concerns, the Japanese nation was about to be thrust into much more violent gales of unrest. On Imperial Plaza, mass meeting of leftist workers and students held at the an incident occurred that proved indicative of future political trends. The meeting, in fact an anti-American demonstration, turned into a melee of fighting and Shouting. Students spotted and surrounded a Japanese plainclothes policeman taking notes on the proceedings. An American military officer became involved in the fracas, which did not halt until eight leftist workers and students had been arrested.

These people were tried before a provost court and were sentenced to unduly severe terms of imprisonment, the maximum of which was ten years at hard labor.

The next development in the course of social upset was to be a general strike on June 3, but the Japanese authorities mobilized the police and the fire brigades and placed them on alert against leftist activities. Rallies and demonstrations were banned, and Tokyo was placed under what almost amounted to martial law.

On July 6, two days after elections for the upper house of the Diet, General MacArthur surprised the nation by ordering the twenty-four members of the Japan Communist party central committee purged. In his directive to Prime Minister Yoshida, MacArthur revealed a completely new stand on the definition and use of the purge. His note read in part:

“The guiding philosophy of this phase of the Occupation has been protective, not punitive. . . . The area of its application for the most part has embraced those persons who because of position and influence bear responsibility for Japan’s totalitarian policies, which led to adventure in conquest and exploitation.

“Recently, however, a new and no less sinister group had injected itself into the Japanese political scene which has sought through perversion of truth and incitation to mass violence to transform this peaceful and tranquil land into an arena of disorder and strife as the means of stemming Japan’s notable progress along the road of representative democracy and subvert the rapidly growing democratic tendencies among the Japanese people. . . . Their coercive methods bear striking parallels to those by which the militaristic leaders of the past deceived and misled the Japanese people.”

Until this announcement, the purge h ad been limited in application to militarists in political and financial circles. Now, aimed at the Communists as well, it was to have double-edged power. On June 7, the seventeen editors of the Communist party organ Aka-hata, or Red Banner, were ordered purged. The situation grew extremely tense for people of communist persuasion, although the purge never went so far as to bring about the outlawing of the party itself. Nevertheless, most of the top leadership went underground. Ten days before the purge of the newspaper editors, as if sensing that something untoward was in the wind, Lieutenant General Kuzma Derevyanko and the forty-nine-member Soviet delegation to the Allied Council for Japan suddenly left for home.

But the tension between the capitalist and communist worlds was headed for a more serious outburst. On Sund June 25, all regular noon-hour radio broadcasts in Japan were interrupted with the startling news that North Korean troops had invaded South Korea across the thirty-eighth parallel. Only recently launched on a road of recovery after the hell of World War II, the Japanese people saw in this eruption of hostilities a forerunner of their most dreaded nightmare, another global war.

Of course, the Korean conflict would have remained no more than a civil war if it had not been for the fact that the Soviet Union and the United States operated behind North and South Korea and in this way gave international significance to the fighting

On June 26, President Truman promised aid to the South Koreans and asked the United Nations Security Council to discuss the Korean conflict at once. The Security Council met on June 28 and passed an American-sponsored resolution branding North Korea as the aggressor and requiring immediate United Nations military sanctions. The Soviet Union was absent from this Security Council meeting.

United States forces went into action at once. Under the direction of MacArthur, as commander in chief of the United Nations troops in Korea, egan air raids and coastal bombardment of North Korea.

The North Koreans met the American attacks with strength and force. They drove the South Korean government out of Seoul and made such serious advances that the United States appealed to United Nations members to dispatch ground forces to Korea as quickly as possible. While the Korean people suffered the agony of war, Japan was being transformed into the major logistics and supply base for the United States forces participating in the fighting.

As soon as the fighting broke out in Korea, strict security measures went into effect throughout the islands of the Japanese archipelago. The Communist newspaper Akahata was first suspended for thirty days; then, on July 18, it was suspended indefinitely. Rallies and demonstrations were forbidden. On July 28, a sweeping purge was conducted of all leftists engaged in newspaper and other communications business, This was ostensibly done to maintain peace and security. By mid-November, 10,869 such people had been removed from their jobs. In August, the Federation of Labor Ministry Workers was ordered disbanded. These are some of the Steps that the gag authorities took in what can only be described as direct intervention in Japanese domestic affairs. This intervention was, of course, counter to the Japanese constitution.

The apprehension the Japanese people felt about these measures naturally grew, but it was to reach a peak when to their surprise they found themselves put on a virtual war footing by the establishment of a 7,000- man, so-called national police reserve force and by personnel increases in the Maritime Safety Agency. Like a fire in a neighbor’s house, the war raged in Korea and kept the Japanese in constant fear that it might spread to their land.

There can be no lasting peace on earth and no progress toward the resolution of differences between capitalism and communism as long as the two persist in confronting each other with antagonism and narrow-minded prejudice. Furthermore, large countries must not be allowed to sacrifice weaker nations to their own selfish ends, for such an act is inimical to all mankind. What was needed in the time of the Korean war and is still needed is a moderate third party that, with the guiding principles of a profound philosophy, can reconcile the two opposing groups by rising above them. The true Buddhism of Nichiren Shoshu meets these requirements.