Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Fall 1974 · Features

The American Cowboy

NSA Quarterly, Fall 1974 (Vol. 2, No. 4), pp. 60–81. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text was read by OCR from a scan of the printed magazine and may contain errors. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

TOM JUSTIN is the proprietor of the Lazy B Ranch; NSA T members who attended the Denver neer Meeting last July know it was no ranch in the real sense of the word. The Lazy B did give the 1,200 NSA pioneers an authentic taste of the place dear to the heart of the cowboy when he was off on his cow drives—that place was the Chuckwagon. That’s where the cowhand could get what might be his only meal on a day of which, 16, 18 or more hours would be spent in saddle; it was also the setting of that old campfire entertainment. Tom Justin exemplified one tendency which seemed true of all cowboys—hard work. He hustled in getting together the supplies for the 1,200 guests, supervised the cooking and later that evening served it up along with the rest of his hands on the serving line: Colorado beef in “Lazy B sauce,” foil wrapped potatoes, beans, peaches, biscuits and spice cake, all of which oozed together on a crude tin plate, but which was nonetheless delicious; except perhaps for the beans. They were just hearty. And Tom was right in there with his men for the clean-up, about a five minute rapid-fire process. With that done, Tom was fast in getting on the stage to lead his singing group, the Lazy B Wranglers, in a very competent rendition of some Western favorites, well spiced with a canny sense of humor and interspersed with some Indian war dances representative of those of the original Colorado natives.

Tom Justin, himself a cowboy for many years in Arizona and Texas, spoke about his experience on the range, as he tested the boiling potatoes and stoked the fires. He spun out his yarn of the American West as he had lived it. As he talked, you could sense his appreciation of nature and his recognition of the poetry in the style of a man’s riding and the beauty of the rugged independence of the cowboy who might spend long stretches without seeing another man.

The ranches in Texas and Arizona which I worked as a kid were just too big to have fences. In fact, I was two months late in receiving my draft notice because it took that long to get the mail when I was out on the range. I remember one old man who had to ride 20 miles just so he could mail his income tax.

I was seventeen when I left home in San Diego in 1950 to look for work on the ranch. Course, I had ridden a lot when I was a kid; there’s a lot of good country that’s wide open in Southern California — it’s not only L.A. I had the chance to be with animals as a boy, and raised calves and chickens. Was always kind of independent that way, and started as a cowboy young, but the life is too rough to find a good cowboy today, it seems.

After the service I went to Cal Poly for a couple of years, but I always had my saddle, a bed and guitar in my station wagon, and I found the academic life was not for me. I came out here with a friend to Colorado on a job, and I never went back.

I feel kids in college are limited today in that they miss the most important thing, practical experience. They miss the fun of it, the incentive it gives them to carry out their dream, and the mental sharpness which comes from it. Why, I learned many things as a cowboy. When I was on the range around my own campfire, I'd make biscuits right on top of the fire, mix ‘em right in the sack. They were so light that when you’d pick ’em up, they’d fall in half.

And kids today lack a dream. Seems their parents can’t give them one. Take Werner Von Braun. He failed math as a kid. Then he had a dream to get something up there in the sky and he went back to his books and knew he’d have to pick up some math to make rockets work like his imagination told him they could.

You know, when you’re out on the trail on a horse, you’ve got to use your head. Got to know where a cow is going to go. Got to be a bronc rider. And if you are going to a ranch for a job, the boss will ask if you can ride. He’ll bring out the meanest horses he’s got, and they’ll buck you. Only some cowboys ever learn how to break a horse from scratch, it’s so hard. When they’re two years old you start playing with a horse. You have to show em to stop whenever a rope hits ‘em. Then you hit ’em with a blanket to get ’em used to it. There’s only one or two men out of all those wranglers down at Rex’s place (Rex Walker’s Sombrero Ranch, a livery serving the public with trail riding) that can train a horse. Then out on the range you have to shoe a horse in the open. On the range, one man would have twenty to twenty-five head of horses. The new man would take them over if one cowboy quit. Charlie Russel, the famous painter of the West, liked this kind of life. Though he was never a top cowboy, like Remington he came out and studied horses. And Will James, the painter and writer, had a special knack with horses in motion.

I started to talk about using your head on the trail. The hardest part was knowing where a cow was going to be so that you would be there. A cowboy has got to know when to be there and when not to. You had to know how to survive in desolate country all alone. If a horse threw you and you were hurt, there could be trouble. It became law that the foreman had to see you every three days, but you might not see another cowboy for the longest time. One place might have six or eight hands for example, and they’d all come together just twice a year during round up time in the spring and the fall.

There was one tough old guy I remember well — Spurlocks. Spurlocks was about seventy-five years old when I knew him, and he had a long handlebar mustache. I remember once seeing him split his head open trying to break a mustang, and then immediately get back on the horse. Spurlocks wouldn’t work with his three sons on the ranch because they were too modern in their ways of ranching — so he said. But then again, he knew how things were changing, and he told me once, “Boy, you listen to those new guys. They know what they’re doing.”

Spurlocks had to have had a few years in as a cowboy before the start of this century. I remember he was from the H Bar Ranch. He had long gray hair and wore his hat peaked. Would come to my campfire now and then. When you saw him coming, he rode just so straight and beautiful it was something else. he impact of the news surrounds us on all sides. Our T impression of the world is largely shaped by the paper we read over breakfast each morning, the car radio we hear on the way to work and the late night newscast we watch on television. This influence is ultimately the product of the reporter—the individual who goes to the source and interprets the news. Freedom of the press is unquestionably one of the pillars of the American way of life. At this point in history, however, the news media is often the subject of attack and controversy. Featured in this issue of the Quarterly are the comments of journalists who speak of their profession and role in society.

Michael Goodwin, reporter for the “New York Times,” related the background preparation for his article about a martial arts program for ghetto youths entitled, “An East Orange ‘Warrior of Peace’ Goes Public,” appearing in the Sunday “Times,” on June 23 of this year. Mike is NSA’s Wall Street Chapter Chief 1 he to be honest. I he a basic mistrust and fear of the martial arts, and anybody connected with them.

On the other hand, experience has taught me that good personal interviews only come about when a bond of mutual trust and respect exists between the parties involved. Thus, my first challenge in a recent interview with Abdul Mfundishi Maasi, a master of the martial art form known as Bando, was to calm myself down!

The program, located in the heart of a nearby New Jersey city, is the first martial arts project in America to be financed by a city government. This fact only further strengthened my skepticism: I could think of a million and one things more valuable to ghetto youth than martial arts training.

When the photographer and I arriv at the program’s headquarters, the mayor of the city and Mr. Maasi, the instructor, welcomed us. The mayor, big and bright, was definitely a politician. The instructor was not. He was more the stoic type to whom smiling seemed unpleasant.

Immediately we were ushered into a large studio where some fifty or sixty young people, divided into pairs, were busy practicing their kicks and punches on each other. Most were about fifteen to twenty years old, but some were no more than ten. I found their body movements remarkably coordinated and their concentration intense, but frankly, the whole scene just plain scared me. This could be the world’s meanest street gang, I thought.

The mayor, Mr. Maasi and myself went into a small office and began talking. Since the mayor had to leave for another appointment shortly, he began talking first. He had nothing but praise for Mr. Maasi and his staff. He called them great, hardworking dedicated people who had created a “human” program. In conclusion, the mayor stated that the Bando program, which now has nearly 400 members, “has done more for black families than the church has.’

The mayor departed and Mr. Maasi and I sat down for a talk. By this time, my interest had been stirred, but I still couldn’t understand how martial arts could benefit ghetto youth. Yet, for some reason the program was definitely

For about half an hour we discussed aspects of the program, mostly in generalities and it seemed, in a superficial way. We were both ill at ease, for my part, I felt that I wasn’t really getting to the meat of the story and I could sense that Maasi was reluctant to be open and honest with me. I realized that the whole thing would be a gross failure for all of us unless I could establish a basic trust between us. Somehow, we had to break down the facades and begin sincere communications.

Awhile longer, and it began to happen. It wasn’t magic, or even instantaneous, but in retrospect, it sure seems like it. I do not know when the first break in the ice came, but at any rate, we soon seemed to be discussing things on a more personal and friendly basis. Gradually, our tones grew warmer and the tension less and before I knew it, he was telling me about his personal philosophy of life and how it related to martial arts.

Before we had finished our discussion, which lasted several hours, we talked about the various problems facing contemporary man and society. All the while, Mr. Maasi gave me the theme of my story by relating how the practice of martial arts had allowed him to overcome his own fears and hostilities and contribute constructively to the world The program, he said, was his way of sharing these benefits with the victimized and aimless youth that populate our inner cities. Finally, he summarized how he viewed himself and martial arts in relation to man’s quest for world peace he described himself as a “warrior of peace.” Before I departed, Mr. Maasi and I agreed that we had each made a new friend that day.

The upshot of this event was an article in the folllowing Sunday’s New York Times that earned me my first byline and Mr. Maasi’s program wider community support, more members and a larger budget. Beyond this aspect, however, I got the priceless lesson of how communication is possible between people if we are only willling to trust and respect each other as equal human beings, regardless of race, religion or ideology. In this way, I feel that journalists can go a long way toward removing much of the alienation, fear and mistrust that has become a hallmark of our times.

Frank Hotchkiss of the Beverly Hills Chapter of NSA is a reporter for the Santa Monica Evening Outlook, 1) journalistic experience has been brief, but in the ten or twenty interviews I have done, one thing seems to stand out—the success of the resulting article depends on the sincere interchange of ideas between the person being questioned and the interviewer.

One example stands out. While working for the Associated view the wife of expatriate and black militant Eldridge Cleaver. Mrs. Kathleen Cleaver was in Los Angeles to testify as a character witness at a murder trial of an acquaintence of hers. It was the first time in several years that American journalists had had direct access within the United States to any member of Cleaver’s family He, of course, had fled the country and was in exile in Algeria.

Mrs. Cleaver emerged from an elevator in the Superior Court Building and was immediately surrounded by a bevy of flash bulbs and microphones. The press—largely white, middle class, and therefore hostile in her expectation of them —began firing questions at her. After perfunctory introductions, questions were posed, such as, “Mrs. Cleaver, I’m so-and-so, now when is your husband coming back,” or other questions relating not at all to her directly.

The woman was obviously upset at both the attention and the tone of the questions. The newsmen seemed to speak to her as if she were merely a source of information—a computer. She turned her back on the majority with a few curt replies.

I felt what was lacking was an appreciation for the person herself—that she was justified in not answering questions from those who apparently did not give a whit about her or her famous husband. I tried to convey that feeling by merely saying I was sure the day presented a difficult situation for her, and asked her if there was anything she would like to say to the public.

Mrs. Cleaver, who was about to undergo a search, as was required of everyone entering the courtroom, reporters included, stopped emptying her purse to turn and look. She paused a moment, then said, “Yes, there is something I would like to say.” :

By now, she spoke directly to me. I held a small microphone as inconspicuously as I could near her to pick up her comments, yet was careful not to offend her with it. She spoke only briefly—and I don’t recall what was said—but all the other journalists there were hounding me to know within seconds. I told them as best I could and followed Mrs. Cleaver into the by then-filling courtroom.

With a little luck, I managed to sit directly behind her. She was accompanied by a few friends as well as her lawyer. There was only a little time left before she would take the stand and I would have to call in my story.

Newsmen to the right and left were again pressing her for comment. She turned around and said to the rest, “I'll talk with this one,” indicating me, “because he seems to hear differently.”

A few moments later, I was telephoning my editors at Associated Press—not with an earth-shaking exclusive, but with a few personal comments from a woman at the eye of a political storm whose comments brought to life an otherwise ordinary story. That made a difference.

Madeline Eller is the executive editor for the New York based movie magazines, Hollywood Hot-line, TV Picture Life and a member of NSA’s Manhattan Chapter.

HE ROLE of a journalist is to share experience with others. One of the first lessons I learned in interviewing is to try and get rid of any preconceived notions I have about a person before the interview.

Once I interviewed a famous comedy writer. I had a few “false starts” on the interview because I was treating him as a “plastic star” and not a person. I realized after both of us were uncomfortable for a long time that in order to get the best interview, it was my job to put him at ease. When I was able to do that, he became very warm and vulnerable very different from all that the “hearsay” led me to believe. The experience taught me something I thought I already knew—that we are all really more alike than we are different as human beings. He was a person struggling with his life situation just like everybody else. He revealed this true part of himself when I gave him the opportunity to let me know who he really was and when I did more than just relate to him in a superficial way.

A success story that really fascinated me was that of a man who heads a giant corporation. I expected him to be a very callous, money-making, business tycoon with ulcer trouble. As I spoke to his employees, I found they regarded him as a father figure rather than an “old scrooge.” Then he told me his “formula”—when he was young, his father and many of his contemporaries had suffered big defeats in business and some just gave up on life. “They lost great fortunes,” he told me, “that they had spent their lives in building. Their homes became unhappy and they were miserable, broken men who didn’t want to try anymore. Maybe I was lucky because, even when my own dad lost his business, he instilled in me a sense of the importance of self-respect. If you make up your mind you're a loser because of a loss, then you’re always going to be a loser. But if you make up your mind to win, you'll study every aspect of a situation, you'll get expert advice and try to make the best decisions.” The man applied these principles to his staff. “If your employees hate you and hate their jobs, you can’t wind up successful in the long run. But if you treat people with respect and nurture the best in them, they can win and so can you. It’s not only a healthy environment, it’s good business.”

I was impressed with the simplicity of his outlook. Though his life was complicated by the many pressured decisions, his approach was clear, humane and consistent—not at all like the ulcer-ridden executive I’'d expected to meet.

I learned a lot from a well-known actress whom I was interviewing in a restaurant. The place was fairly empty and the actress answered my questions pleasantly enough, until the waitress came over to take our order. The waitress was very abrupt and impatient. For a while, the actress sat quietly, obviously annoyed at our treatment; then she told me that she had been a waitress during her “struggling years.” During that period, she had made up her mind to be the best waitress in the world. “If I had twelve people at my table, I made it a challenge to remember who ordered what. No matter how busy I was, I would try to be alert to each customer’s needs without making them uncomfortable. Any job you do is as boring or satisfying as you make it. If you don’t do your best in every situation, you wind up cheating yourself and having no self-respect.”

A singer I interviewed was so full of charm, poise and confidence, it was hard to imagine her ever being unsure of herself. She laughed when I told her how she impressed me and admitted there were many moments of uncertainty.

When she finally decided to pursue her dream, she knew she couldn’t just “up and be a star.” She worked for two years in a bank in her small midwestern hometown and saved practically every penny of her small salary so she could put it towards investing in her career. Everytime she wanted to buy even a ten cent item, she would ask herself, “Do I really, really need this?” She struggled hard but she felt happier each I day because she was on the road to accomplishing her goal. She cried many times with the rejection she received in her early attempts to break into show business and knew how slim her chances were of success. “But I figured if other people I could make it, I could make it—if I had the guts to fight and ' the belief in my own talent.”

In all of my work, the people I’ve interviewed, no matter what fields they’ve been in, were successful because they I made their luck. They were not superhuman in any remarkable way, but decided on what they wanted and were willing to struggle against great odds to achieve their goals.

Leigh Kennicott is a freelance writer in Los Angeles. She is a member of the Paramount Chapter of NSA.

A Diehl came to California and. UCLA for graduate work in theatre Se criticism. With that unlikely prepara- 3 aN tion, he became the editor of the UCLA ™ re. Bruin, a critic for the Los Angeles q ‘a. : Times and finally, the Los Angeles a I Times Book Editor. His column, , . “Booktalk” gave rise to Q & A’s that § ran in “West,” the Times’ now defunct DIGBY DIEHL Sunday supplement.

Recently, a collection of these revealing Q & A’s was published and appropriately titled, SUPERTALK. Such diverse personalities as Henry Miller, Huey Newton, Gloria I Steinem and Peter Bogdonavich opened up to Digby Diehl in an engaging way. |

On the occasion of the book’s publication, Mr. Diehl consented to relinquish his role as interviewer and try his hand I as an interviewee. He’s still an earnest young man, although he’d never own up to it. His ability as a teacher is inborn, I which he demonstrates as a lecturer on criticism at UCLA.

In 1972, he arrived at the NSA America Joint Headquarters to talk to World Tribune correspondents about interviewing techniques. The resulting instructions about writing exercises and interviewing hints left the fledgling journalists electrified by infinite possibilities to explore.

On a moist, West Coast summer’s eve, Digby Diehl relaxed at his Santa Monica Canyon home and talked through the hour of dusk about interviewing people.

Quarterly What distinguishes a good interviewer?

Diehl It seems to me that the essential thing for a good interviewer is to be a good listener. If you want to get to know or at least explore someone’s ideas, you ought to approach them in an open-minded manner. The way I do it: first, do a great deal of research on the subject. I spend a lot of time in libraries developing background material. If there are books on the subject I read them.

When I interviewed Burt Bacharach, I went and did all the background reading and got hold of the scores to his music. In fact, that turned out to be one of the key things that developed kind of a rapport between Bacharach and myself. Music, naturally, is his way of expression. I found that by talking in very technical terms he was put at ease. We found our level of communication and went on to other subjects.

In addition to looking at the scores, I also interviewed Hal David, who writes the lyrics for Bacharach’s music. I got a feeling for the man, a new understanding, by talking to David. When I’ve done that kind of backgrounding, sometimes I know a little more about the subject than, at least, they remember about themselves.

I don’t prepare questions at all. I'll try and leave an hour or two free before the interview, so that I can actually sit down and just saturate myself with the material. Then, when I’m talking with people, my approach is simply to try and get some rapport, some sense of empathy going with them.

Quarterly Along with being a good listener, don’t you have to have an innate interest in humanity when you do interviews?

Diehl Let’s put it a different way. It seems to me that there is no such thing as a bad interview or interviewee. There are only weak interviewers. I think everybody’s got something to say and it’s the interviewer's job to get to it. There are stories everywhere and there are fascinating individual experiences that each person has to offer. I find when I read interviews that portray people as dull and uninteresting, the interviewer simply hasn’t done his work.

Studs Terkel’s Working is a book done almost precisely the same way mine is, only he went out and interviewed waitresses and elevator operators, and what they had to say was fascinating.

It was Studs Terkel’s ability as an interviewer that found lots of interesting facets and worthwhile things in all humanity.

Quarterly

Diehl Studs Terkel just reviewed your book in the Los Angeles Times, The most interesting thing he said was, now isn’t it time to do a book on ordinary people?

He said that he thought that I could do a book on “non-celebrities.” He was kidding, a little bit, because his own book deals with non-celebrities. And Studs made a point early in the review about the fact that the famous people are not always the great minds of our time. I take issue with that. Everybody’s in my book because I thought what they had to say was interesting and seriously worthwhile.

The Q & A form is probably one of the cleanest, and in some ways, the most difficult way of really getting at a personality. You’ve got to work very hard to get statements that truly typify their thinking, and at the same time have a lot of content for the general reader.

Quarterly

Diehl

How did you get started on Q &A’s?

The interview which was really the formulative kernel for them was the one with Revel and Bradbury. I guess it was in 1971. I was going to do my column, “Booktalk,” on Jean Francois Revel’s book Without Marx or Jesus: The New American Revolution Has Begun. I mentioned to Ray Bradbury that I was having lunch with Revel. He said, “Oh, how exciting. Would it be possible for me to come along?” I invited him and the two of them started in talking about science fiction — Revel is an admirer of Bradbury’s. We had a marvelous hour or so at lunch. When I got back and listened to the tape-recording, I realized that nothing would convey the bouyant sense of optimism that both of them seemed to share about America, and the kind of enthusiasm they had about writing, as well as simply taking their words and condensing them into a O & A. It turned out to be a much longer piece, of course, but it took a natural form.

Quarterly

Diehl

I don’t know much about the Q and A Form.

I think Playboy was the only place where they were appearing with any real length or success before my QO & A series. The technique has been used off and on. It’s been considered the lazy newspaperman’s trick because he doesn’t edit it at all; he just takes an actual transcription and — bang — that’s it. It can be a very shoddy way of doing things. An actual direct transcription of any conversation or interview is a bore. Nobody talks in perfect sentences. About the most interesting precedent of the Q & A was the Paris Review interviews. Since 1954, I think, the Paris Review has been doing interviews of this sort with authors and poets. As the joke goes in literary circles, some of those guys do their best writing in their Paris Review interviews, because in each case the author being interviewed was allowed to rewrite his answers. And, of course, they came off with a literary polish and style that’s just not true of the person talking. I think that an inerviewer ought to try and capture more of that, and not the kind of classical perfection of the Paris Review stuff.

Quarterly Whom did you most look forward to interviewing?

Diehl I guess I’d have to say that I looked forward to the Charles Eames interview as much as any, simply because it was the culmination of seven years’ pursuit. He is an extremely reticent person. He works seven days a week; buries himself in his work. Probably he’s better known outside this country than here. But, as I point out in the book, he permeates American culture. He has worked on exhibits that Americans have had at almost every World’s Fair. He’s done lots of work for big companies like IBM and Xerox. He’s worked on the National Aquarium. Everywhere you look you see Charles Eames chairs. It’s just astonishing. Eames seems to me to be one of the most important successors to the Frank Lloyd Wright school of design.

I had first wanted to do a story about Charles Eames in 1965, and I got an introduction to his secretary. She arranged for me to go down and at least look at the place where Eames was working. I met him very briefly, at which point he dismissed the notion of an article or an interview. After another couple of years I came back to the workshop and had a long talk with Eames, and again, he refused to do an interview. We would periodically talk on the phone and go back and forth on this. It was just one of those things that you kept in your mind as you went along.

So finally, in 1972, I was doing the Q & A’s. I had made a point of calling him up periodically. He was impressed by the way I handled the Q & A’s and the people in them. Finally one time he relented. He said, “OK, we'll try it,” with not much optimism. I got there, and indeed, he wasn’t easy to draw out. But at the end of it, I think the interview that I got was very worthwhile and I think his expression of ideas about design and architecture are terrific.

Quarterly

Diehl When you’re with someone who’s hard to draw out, what techniques do you have to start?

There are a lot of different ways you can use. If it didn’t seem to be working out, I would try and switch the conversation around or work it around almost to the point where I am asking what they want to talk about. I’ve done that particularly with people who simply wanted to get across a diatribe or a single message. I let them give their speech. Sometimes that’s the exact way to get them talking. Sometimes their topic turns out to be interesting and worthwhile, but more often it’s a way of warming them up for more general conversation and a more general realm of ideas. To a large extent, I succeeded with Joan Baez in that way.

Joan Baez makes no bones about it. She wants to talk about pacifism; she wanted to talk about the war in Vietnam at the time I interviewed her. She feels very strongly about these things. I think she’s one of the most dedicated, sincere people that I have dealt with on any subject like that, but I also wanted to find out about her as a person and about her own experience as a songwriter and an artist. At first she didn’t want to have anything to do with that, she wanted to lay her whole anti-war trip on me. Which was fine. When we got through that, we went on and had an interesting conversation about her life as a Mexican-American, daughter of Quakers, and all kinds of fascinating things that led up to the protestor that she is today.

Quarterly

Diehl

Is there any difference between an article and a Q & A?

If I were to write articles about these people, in each case it would be very different than what the Q & A turned out to be. In each case I tried to remove myself as much as possible from the picture and not use my mind or my writing as a filter. I disagree with a lot of things that are said in my book. Right off the top of my head I can’t think of anybody that I agreed with totally. But as a writer I felt what I was trying to do was get expressions of their ideas as purely as I could. In that sense, it’s about as objective as I could make it. There’s still a degree of selectivity there. I selected the material. But it is their words, hopefully in their own manner of speech, and it’s as expressive of their ideas as I could make it. If I were writing an article, let’s say about Hugh Hefner, I would feel obliged as a writer to enter into it much more subjectively. I would like to counter a lot of things and at least present other points of view to kind of round out the story.

Al Albergate, news reporter for the L.A. Herald-Examiner, interviewed William T. Farr at the Criminal Courts Building in Los Angeles. Albergate is a member of NSA’s Beverly Hills Chapter.

T 39 years of age, Bill Farr has been a newspaper A reporter for 23 years in California. He covers the criminal courts in downtown Los Angeles for the L.A. Times. Farr is a prize-winning reporter within the state, but gained national attention in late 1972 when he spent 46 days in the County Jail after Superior Court Judge Charles Older held him in contempt for refusing to reveal the sources of his information for a story concerning the Charles Manson “family” trial (for the Tate-La Bianca slayings). The information had been supplied by attorneys in the case who were under a court publicity order. Farr still faces five more days in jail if current appeals fail.

He has won awards from the State Bar Association, the Orange County Press Club and the State Legislature for a series of articles on corruption in the Orange County Public Administrator’s Office. These stories were written during his 12-year career with the Santa Ana Register.

The following is an interview about an interview he says was his most memorable. It took place in San Quentin Prison in 1960 with Caryl Chessman, the man who spent 12 years on death row while appealing his conviction for kidnapping.

Quarterly Bill, you were speaking about your interview many years ago with Caryl Chessman. Could you start out by giving us a little background about how that interview came about and what your feelings were going into it?

The interview in fact occurred about 40 hours before he was executed. The reason that I was doing the interview was that at that point there was a great focus and attention the world over on Chessman’s imminent execution, and some agreement had been worked out by prison authorities and Chessman that he would grant interviews if a written request were put in and he approved of the premise. I felt that anyone and everyone was going to interview him on things generally, and because I worked for the Santa Ana Register and covered Orange County, I wrote him an outline saying I wanted to talk to him about the six guys from Orange County that had been on death row during the twelve years that he had been there. Much to my surprise, because I was a relatively new reporter, I got a reply back that I could have the interview and so I went to San Quentin.

Quarterly

Farr

What was your real personal interest in the interview?

I had had a considerable interest in the death penalty for one thing, and also in getting what I felt was a very dramatic story, both in regard to Chessman and to almost all of these six persons on death row from Orange County.

Actually, I was sort of prepared to dislike Chessman. I had seen him in court one time. Frankly, I thought he was obnoxious. It had to do with the manner in which he cross-examined some witnesses who had been jurors in his trial. I saw him when he had an extraordinary special hearing. . . where he was allowed to question jurors about their recollection of what the record was (from the trial) and I thought, frankly, that he came on too strong — that he may have hurt himself. It always seemed to me that Chessman, from pictures I had seen of him, had almost a sneering attitude, and I was very pleasantly surprised by my experience in interviewing him. I think I said to you before, Here was a guy who knew that he had come to the end of his string with only about 40 hours to live and because of the compassion he showed for these other death row inmates and his insight into them, I was very impressed. He was a very intense guy. The way the interview was set up, there I was almost nose to nose with the man; whether that’s true for all prisoners I don’t know, because I’ve never talked to another prisoner.

It was at San Quentin in a special, very small cell. I think it was a holding cell for maximum security prisoners, where they would be put prior to going somewhere else. It was pretty close quarters, sitting at a table, no screen, there was a petition maybe three inches high between us. He had some very specific recollections and good insights from a newsman’s point of view on all six of these guys who had served with him. He started out by saying, “Listen — regardless of what you think of me, I can take care of myself. I’m a bright guy and I am able to fight the system. All six of these guys that you want to talk to me about are the best arguments you can think of against capital punishment because they were mentally deficient, each and every one of them. They were like this when they got there, and some of them went terribly down hill almost to vegetable status.” And his argument was that it is inhuman for this to happen.

Quarterly

Did this surprise you?

I have to admit that. It was a favorable impression of Chessman. I don’t think I expected him to be a terrible ogre. One thing I learned even before that time is that you may get a certain image of a person, sometimes the news media is responsible for creating that image, but you find face to face that there’s a difference. I’ve never met anyone I really regarded as evil, not even Charlie

Manson.

Quarterly

Farr

You did meet him?

Yes, but only briefly.

My point being that they seem just like you or me and under those circumstances, regardless of what they supposedly or in fact have done. I was impressed by the fact that the guy (Chessman) had a sense of humor on several things. I wanted to ask him a question about whether he’d written the legal appeals for a killer named Billy Rupp, a very sensational case. A friend of mine in the Attorney General’s Office had said to me “Gee, I don’t think he’ll answer that ’cause it is illegal for one felony convict to aid another felony convict in a legal matter.” Finally, I asked him and Chessman thought that was hilarious, because he said, “Tell him I'll plead guilty to that misdemeanor because it carries a six months’ sentence and right now I'd like to buy the six months.” And the fact that he would even joke about it!

But what I was most impressed about was his understanding and concern for the plight of other human beings.

Quarterly

Farr

Do you mean as evidenced through his talking about these six guys?

Right. Four of the six were already dead and two were still on death row. One had killed himself on death row. Chessman was a very articulate guy, very articulate. People regarded him as a criminal and legal genius, but I think that’s overstated. I think he was very bright. His IQ had not been completely falsified; but when he was at Chino he was a trustee and I have heard two versions of how this happened. One was that he just faked his records and marked up his IQ by 25 points. And the other, which I believe to be true, was that he had access to the IQ tests so he could get a copy of it and study it for a prolonged time before he took the IQ tests. But you know: he was kind of a dumb criminal, in fact he had a lot of convictions before the so-called “red light bandit” case, and aside from that, one count which was a kidnap with force and bodily harm. He had eighteen other five to life convictions, mainly for armed robbery which carried the death penalty and I think that there was no question that he had been a sociopath. Maybe Chessman is a prime example that adversity can be put to very good uses because unquestionably he grew a great deal while trying to save his life.

Quarterly

Farr

How old was Chessman when he was finally executed?

Forty. At least that’s my best recollection. He had been on death row for 12 years. And of course everybody points to how he was able to keep himself alive. Well, he certainly did some work on his own case, but he had a lot of help. I mean he had attorneys like Rosalie Asher and George T. Davis and a guy named A. J. Zirpoli, who is now a federal district judge in San Francisco, so he had a lot of help in addition to his own talent. And I would submit that really you or I and anyone with an IQ over 115, if you were on death row and had the time to study and your narrow interest in law was that of criminal law, that we could all do a pretty good job in our own appeals. You have a vivid, vivid stimulation to do that when your own life is at stake.

Quarterly

Farr

Going back to the interview, and that day, how old were you?

Quarterly

Farr

How long had you been a reporter?

I had been a reporter in news reporting for about four years. I'd been a sportswriter for almost 312 years before that. And I’d had some varied experience, but really of all the interviews and over the years I’ve had the good fortune to interview some fairly famous people — the one that is most memorable to me is that interview with Chessman.

Quarterly

Farr How did he come on to you when you walked into the room? You must have been expecting some man to be sweating in his boots.

Well, one of the first things I noticed was that he didn’t seem to be sweating his plight. My first impression was that he was an immaculately neat and well-washed guy. He was in prison blues and right at the beginning he said, “I’d like to shake hands with you, but we can’t” and he laughed about it.

I felt some rapport right away and it was a favorable one. You have to realize that I was then, and to a lesser degree am now, pro-capital punishment. But I will say this, that I feel that I would accept Chessman’s viewpoint about the inhumanity of the death penalty system. It’s not that we simply put people to death, but we have a system of appeals which I would not want to do away with. He told me about experiences of a guy named Henry Ford McCracken who had killed a nine-year-old girl. Twice McCracken got so close that he was once in the chamber and in one other instance actually strapped in when the stay of execution came.

Quarterly

My God!

And that second time, it did him in. He was just like an animal, according to Chessman. Chessman had to drag him back to his cell and he was just making little animal noises, going “ecko, ecko, ecko.” And he went on for a day and a half that way. Something is barbaric about that. But, at the same time, you can’t do away with appeals because a man’s life is at stake.

Starting with my conversation with Chessman, fourteen years ago, I’ve become less and less sure that capital punishment accomplishes anything and have gained more and more of a feeling that it’s inhumane and that it should be outlawed.

Quarterly Do you think that was part of the basis of your rapport with Chessman, something you felt mutually, although coming from opposing viewpoints?

I think so, And I think there was an honest exchange of ideas. I felt it was instructive and I think that one thing about interviews with not just famous people, but people who have some distinguishing quality, a reporter can enable that insight to reach broader spectrum of people than almost anybody else in life. If you think about it, there are $50,000-lawyers or $100,000-a- -year lawyers who do not meet as many people as you and I do, of such varied type or having such varied backgrounds. I think that’s part of the valuable experience of being a reporter and, hopefully, that one builds over the years from that valuable experience so that you share it with readers or with viewers. That comes with experience, although some guys never attain it, I think there are some guys who get hardened by our business. I have never known a good reporter who lost interest in other people and who didn’t really vividly care about telling a story to people. You and I write fifteen stories a week where this doesn’t apply, but there are special stories you work on where you really care how it is written, how it is presented and hopefully about the purpose behind the story.

And I really cared in this instance with Chessman about putting forth his ideas, even though I didn’t tot: lly agree. I felt it was a valuable thing to me personally and that it was an experience that was my obligation to share and try to put forth in a very vivid way to readers.

Quarterly

Farr What was valuable about this interview? I would think that most readers would have been glad to see him go to the gas chamber.

Maybe so. And that probably was more so then, and since I worked in Orange County, the presumption might be that the general readership would have been leaning against him. But I personally feel that in a democr: icy OF any society, the more that there is a sharing of experience, the better society is going to be and I think that’s part of what our job is.

I know that that’s my own personal feeling in response to talking to people, sometimes in line with work and sometimes just in conversation. That sharing of the collective knowledge and experience in society allows society to learn from that experience. And I thought that Chessman put forth a very solid, articulate argument on the other side.

I am still of the feeling that society is made up by a majority of reasonable people. There are things that shake that faith every once in a while. And I think that part of the job of a reporter is to put forth ideas so that the reasonable segment of society can learn and act accordingly. That’s why I really regard reporting as a high calling, not in any of the ways that one sees in the movies and so forth.

But you have a considerable obligation and a tremendous opportunity to put forth ideas from very fine lines and also by observation of all the drama and travail that human beings go through. We see it everyday, sometimes in defendants we would never write on because they are non-descript, but in this building (Criminal Courts Building in downtown L.A.) we see all the joy and sorrow and really trauma in people’s life. I have never gotten over, in all the years I’ve covered the courts, never gotten immune to that, which in some ways is a good thing. But it still depresses me to see even a bad guy, a guy who has done some bad things, to see the guy’s whole life destroyed is not a pretty thing. Anybody who really gets joy out of that I regard as partially demented or extremely shallow as a human being.

Quarterly

Farr In connection with that emotion or feeling, how long was your interview with Chessman and at the end of it did you have a change of heart about whether you would like to see this human being put to death?

He was allowing interviews in half-hour segments and I got to talk to him for two of those segments because some guy from the London Observer didn’t show up for his appointment.

It didn’t really change my point of view. I still felt it was justifiable to execute Chessman. In fact, during our conversation we discussed that. I told him and he said “Well, I appreciate your being frank about that. The way things are coming down now so close to the wire, I don’t want to be engaging in games with you or anyone else.” But this is another thing I’d like to bring up. It was the one thing that I didn’t bring up then. I think it was a lack of courage. I can’t quite remember. But I would certainly bring it up to him now, and I didn’t then. There was worldwide sympathy, certainly among those who believed in abolishing capital punishment, that Chessman was an extraordinary fellow. The feeling was that it was a waste to kill him.

Quarterly

Do you mean because of his struggle to stay alive?

Farr Right, which had been more prolonged than most. He was an extraordinary man, a very bright guy who had even written a very good book about death row. To this day what bothers me is that you don’t have a concomitant sympathy for the victim. Now Mary Alice Meza, who was Chessman’s victim in the crime which sent him to his death, is still a mental patient. Defense attorneys argued that she was somewhat unbalanced to begin with, but who has the right to push someone over the brink?

I would like to have said, or if I could talk to him today, I would like to have asked Chessman about the victim aspect. I probably felt it was improper. It was probably a little lack of courage on my part. He was still appealing. He had never conceded he had committed this crime.

Quarterly

Farr

Did you ask him outright?

I did not. But I think that I would do a little better job of interviewing now, than at that time.

But I think that the experience of interviewing or interaction that reporters have is that it provides some insight to the human experience which hopefully you get to share with the readers.

I had intended to go into the field of law but I had to quit school because my dad was seriously ill, but as things have come down in more recent times I don’t really regret that. What I regret is not making as much money as lawyers so I could live more comfortably. I don’t mean to be wealthy. One of the things I don’t enjoy about life is worrying about money.

Neither you nor I are nationally famous reporters and the vast majority of reporters do not cover big, national stories, but I would say that, really, the scope of experience we get in this building, and it’s probably more true with general assignment reporters, is one that the highest-priced lawyer in Los Angeles does not get. I can’t think of any job that allows you to meet so many different kinds of people, good, bad and all those in between. And that’s why I really wouldn’t want to do anything else.

Quarterly

Farr You mentioned one instance where Chessman displayed a sense of humor, do you recall any others?

No. Outside of the opening where he kind of chuckled over the fact that shaking hands was not permissible. It seemed to me that he smiled frequently and seemed, while very intense, very much at ease and hardly like a guy that was probably going to die the next day. There was some feeling that he could still get a stay. But he Said to me, “I think I’ve come to the point where I’ve run out of time.” In his own mind he didn’t think he was going to make it. His attorneys expressed some optimism. It gives you a grim feeling when a guy says he thinks he’s not going to make it and you realize that by the night of the next day the guy probably is going to be dead.

Quarterly You mean when you learned of his execution? Farr Yes. It was a funny thing too. It had an emotional impact on me when I learned that he had been executed. I really felt depressed. Quarterly Do you feel this meeting with Chessman had some kind of impact on your life and your career in a meaningful way, maybe in the way you looked at things? Farr I wouldn’t want to say that it caused a dramatic turn. But over the years I’ve developed a greater compassion for fellow human beings and certainly that was a key ingredient. It’s hard for me to put into words, Al. Your life is an amalgam of things and very seldom for any of us is an event so dramatic that it turns your life around. But certainly I think that added a considerable degree of compassion. Because my feeling was that here is just another human being who probably did something horrendously wrong, which I regard as wrong and which I would like to think I would not do. But I have seldom read or heard about anything that I felt was totally beyond my capability of doing or the capability of almost anybody. We tend to be very harsh in our judgment of others sometimes without knowing all the ingredients that go into why a person turns out a given way.

Captions and notes

Press as a summer replacement trainee, I was sent to inter-

s an earnest young man, Digby

WILLIAM T. FARR