Nichiren Shoshu of America Collection

NSA Quarterly · Summer 1973 · Nichiren Daishonin’s Gosho

On the Persecutions

NSA Quarterly, Summer 1973, pp. 95–105. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.

Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan

This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.

However, during these twenty-seven years, I, Nichiren, was exiled to the province of Izu on May 12 in the first year of Kocho, was wounded on the forehead, my left hand broken, on November 11 in the first year of Bun’ei, sentenced to execution but was spared and exiled to the province of Sado on September 12 in the eighth year of the same era, Bun’ei. In addition, there were innumerable persecutions—my disciples were killed, wounded, banished or forced to pay unreasonably heavy taxes. I do not know whether my persecutions are greater than those of the Buddha, but obviously those of Ryuju, Tenjin, T’ien-t’ai and Dengyo are not comparable to mine. Were it not for me, Nichiren, in Mappo, the Buddha would be a man of false words and Taho and all other Buddhas would be testifiers to untruth. For the 2,230 years or more after the Buddha’s death, I, Nichiren, am the only person in the whole world who ever fulfilled the Buddha’s prophecy.

Both in the past and at present, those governing and those governed who despise the devotee of the Lotus Sutra in Mappo seem to be free from punishment at first, but eventually they are all doomed to fall. This holds true with me, Nichiren. At first, there were no signs of punishment among the persecutors, but now, twenty-seven years after, the Buddhist gods such as Bonten, Taishaku, Nitten, Gatten, and the four great heavenly kings seem to be working earnestly, fearing that if they should not fulfill their oath, they will fall into the hell of incessant suffering. It must be the result of the punishment from the Lotus Sutra that Ota-no Chikamasa, Nagasaki Jiro Hyoe-no Tokitsuna and Daishinbo were thrown from their horses to their death. There are four kinds of punishment —general and individual, conspicuous and inconspicuous. It is general punishment that Japan suffers from the prevalence of epidemics, serious famine, insurrections and foreign invasions. Epidemics represent inconspicuous punishment. The deaths of Ota and the other persecutors are conspicuous and individual punishment.

Each of you should summon up the lion’s courage and never be cowed by any threat. The lion fears no other beast. Neither do its cubs. The slanderers are comparable to the barking of stray dogs, but Nichiren’s followers, to the lion’s roar. The late Tokiyori and the present regent Tokimune pardoned me, Nichiren, since they realized that I am free from any guilt and that others convicted me on false charges. Henceforth, the Regent has learned to doubt vile calumny without confirming its validity. They should know that even a person obsessed by a great demon cannot punish me, Nichiren, since Bonten, Taisaku, Nitten, Gatten, the four great heavenly kings and other Buddhist gods are my protectors. Deepen your faith day by day and month after month. Should you slacken even a bit in your faith, demons will possess you.

[Notes: 1. Ryuju—born a Brahmin seven centuries after Sakyamuni, he is noted for his efforts in propagating Mahayana Buddhism. 2. Tenjin—born to a Brahmin family about nine centuries after Sakyamuni, he achieved greatness for propagating Mahayana Buddhism throughout his life. 3. T’ien-t’ai—see footnote on page 89. 4. Dengyo—see footnote on page 89.]

[5. Taho Buddha—see footnote on page 68. 6. The Buddha’s prophecy —Sakyamuni predicted that after his death the Lotus Sutra would prevail throughout the world, and that the one who propagates it in Mappo would undoubtedly meet greater persecutions than he. 7. Devotee . . . in Mappo—Nichiren Daishonin, and at the same time, those who are practicing his true Buddhism. 8. Buddhist gods—forces in the universe that protect believers of true Buddhism. 9. Four great heavenly kings —same as footnote 8. 10. Ota-no Chikamasa, Nagasaki Jiro Hyoe-no Tokitsuna and Daishin-bo —ex-believers of true Buddhism who participated in plotting the Atsuhara persecution.]

[11. Foreign invasions — Mongolian invasions. 12. Tokiyori— 1227-1263, fifth regent of the Hojo regime. 13. Tokimune— 1251-1284, eighth regent and son of Tokiyori.]

Background: On the Persecutions Befalling the Buddha

Any discussion of the Shonin Gonanji must be prefaced by an account of the Atsuhara persecutions. This letter not only coincided in time with that event, but was addressed to all the believers living in Atsuhara.

By 1279, Nichiren Daishonin had already spent five years at his secluded retreat in Mt. Minobu. His closest disciple, Nikko Shonin, left his master periodically to initiate a Shakubuku movement in the Mt. Fuji region, a day’s journey away on horseback.

His efforts in the campaign to spread the Daishonin’s teachings affected a great many people, rich and poor, priest and layman. He converted several leading families in Yamanashi Prefecture to the north of Mt. Fuji. Then he converted several more families in a nearby coastal area. Among them were Nikke, Nissen, Nichiden and Nichimyo, who were later to become Nichiren Shoshu priests. In Shizuoka, the Nanjo and Matsuno families began practicing. At Jissoji Temple, of the Tien-t’ai sect, the same temple where Nikko Shonin entered the priesthood, he converted the chief priest, Chikuzenbo. Nichigen of Shijukuin Temple and Nisshu and Nichiben of Ryusenji all renounced their former faiths and accepted true Buddhism. And of course, the Atsuhara region, not far from the present Head Temple, was populated with many believers.

Atsuhara — faith under the height of oppression

Feelings against the swelling ranks of converts were running high. Gyochi of Ryusenji Temple was infuriated because three of his

[As predicted, the Mongolian fleet appeared off the coast of Japan on two dates, October, 1274 and May, 1281, throwing the country into confusion.]

own priests defected. That may have hurt his pride, but his greatest concern was loss of a sizable portion of his congregation. They were turning to true Buddhism because of Nikko Shonin’s influence. He plotted to put a stop to this trend once and for all.

Among the farmers who followed Nikko Shonin, Jinshiro, Yagoro and Yarokuro of the Atsuhara area had extremely strong faith. They were very united. Gyochi capitalized on the hatred of Jinshiro’s elder brother, Yatoji Nyudo. Two local ex-believers, Ota Chikamasa and Nagasaki Tokitsuna, were strongly opposed to the new movement. Two others, Daishimbo and Sanmibo, had also quit their practice of true Buddhism and were willing to conspire with Gyochi.

Together, these men organized something of an anti-Hokekyo league. Their first move occurred on April 8, 1279, during a traditional Yabusame — a tournament of mounted archers. They filtered through the large crowd watching the event and stabbed a believer named Shirobo. In August of the same year, the league killed a believer named Yashiro and then contrived to have Nisshu and Nichiben accused of the crime.

Then in September, Nisshu and numerous other believers were harvesting rice in fields around Atsuhara. Gyochi, several officials and soldiers charged the group on horseback. Twenty of them were captured by this armed force.

During the foray, Sanmibo, Daishimbo, Ota Chikamasa and Nagasaki Tokitsuna, the four men who originally plotted with Gyochi, were thrown from their horses and later died from their injuries. In his reference to this in the Gosho, Nichiren Daishonin termed their fate—conspicuous, individual punishment.

Gyochi then convinced another man, Yatoji, to file charges of theft against the 20 prisoners. The incident was immediately reported to the Daishonin, who then wrote a letter of appeal to the government. It was titled the Ryusenji Moshi Jyo. Nikko Shonin, together with Nisshu, took it to Kamakura and presented it to the court. It was a futile gesture, for Gyochi was a relative of Hei-no Saemon, the one person who unquestionably hated Nichiren Daishonin more than anyone in the government. Hei-no Saemon personally volunteered to judge the case of the 20 farmers.

The investigation was a farce. Instead of dealing with the accusations of theft or the evidence presented, Hei-no Saemon was more interested in forcing the prisoners to renounce their faith. The farmers were tied up and shot with blunt-tipped arrows, which though not fatal, were terrifying. Jinshiro, Yagoro and Yarokuro continued to chant Nam-myoho-renge-kyo during their torture. Their persistence must have been maddening to their captors. In April, 1280, six months after the arrest, these three were filed out before their fellow prisoners and beheaded. The other 17 were banished from the Atsuhara area and then released.

Fulfilling the purpose of the Daishonin’s advent

The arrest of 20 simple farmers indicated to Nichiren Daishonin that the time was right to inscribe the Dai-Gohonzon, thus fulfilling the purpose for his advent. The Shonin Gonanji was written on October 1, 1279, ten days before the Dai-Gohonzon was inscribed.

The portion of the Gosho presented here is the latter half. In the opening passages, Nichiren Daishonin explains the time and circumstances of Sakyamuni, Tien-t’ai and Dengyo reaching the purpose of their advent. He also recounts how, on April 28, 1253, he first chanted Nam-myoho-renge-kyo and how he reached the fulfillment of his mission 27 years later with the inscription of the Dai-Gohonzon. He quotes a passage from the 10th chapter of the Lotus Sutra which states that obstacles after the death of Sakyamuni will be greater in severity, Sakyamuni was faced with the so-called nine great persecutions. Ryuju (Nagarjuna in Sanskrit), T’ien-t’ai and Dengyo didn’t experience severe opposition. So, as it says in this letter, Were it not for me, Nichiren, in Mappo, the Buddha would be a man of false words...

He opens the latter segment of the letter by citing the events of his life during the 27-year period after he set out on his mission: ... was exiled to the province of Izu on May 12 in the first year of Kocho ... refers to his exile in 1261 ... was wounded on the forehead, my left hand broken on November 11 in the first year of Bun’ei . . . explains the injuries he sustained in the Komatsubara persecution in 1264 ... sentenced to execution but was spared and exiled ... recounts the events of the Tatsunokuchi persecution of September 12, 1271.

The firm resolution of his followers after the Atsuhara incident prompted the inscription of the Dai-Gohonzon. In contrast, the Tatsunokuchi persecution and subsequent exiles shook the foundations of belief in many. The Kamakura government was afraid that the believers were responsible for a rash of vandalism and crime and had name lists of the believers compiled. Several mysterious murders were committed by

[Mongolian envoy arrives at Kamakura in 1268.]

men who would shout out Nam-myoho-renge-kyo and then disappear. Unexplained fires broke out. Whether by plan or coincidence, the Daishonin’s followers were suspected for every mishap. Under the burden of government disapproval and public outrage, many of the strongest believers denied that they had any allegiance to Nichiren Daishonin. In some instances, former believers supplied false testimony for government prosecutors. The reaction of believers to the Atsuhara persecution was significantly different.

This Gosho states: The late Tokiyori and the present regent Tokimune, pardoned me, Nichiren, since they realized that I am free from any guilt and that others convicted me on false charges. Henceforth, the Regent has learned to doubt vile calumny without confirming its validity. By 1279, the Kamakura Regime saw little purpose in pressing any case against the Daishonin. The majority of confrontations in earlier years was instigated by groundless rumors and the spite of minor officials or jealous priests with significant influence among the ruling class. But the government had repeatedly been a pawn and grew tired of being the instrument of personal vendettas against a simple priest who could never be proven guilty of purported crimes. Seen in this light, the government was less sinister in its motives than most people imagine.

In the case of the Atsuhara incident, several backsliding believers were involved. Daishimbo was formerly a senior priest, who, together with Nissho, practiced while the Daishonin was in exile. Later, he assisted Nikko Shonin in the propagation effort around Fuji, but could not carry through. As stated earlier, there were several who had forsaken their faith and who were belligerent towards Nichiren Shoshu.

Two differences are noteworthy. In earlier years, it was the government that persecuted Nichiren Daishonin. Taiten believers were behind the events at Atsuhara. Secondly, the earlier persecutions were invariably directed at Nichiren Daishonin himself. Atsuhara was

[Grave of Atsuhara martyrs]

a vindictive move against the believers. The government had previously acted upon rash accusations, and had so often been proven wrong, that they were careful about launching attacks that might again turn out groundless. Only a few individuals, primarily Hei-no Saemon and priests of rival sects bore any hatred for Nichiren Daishonin. Clearly, the times had changed.

This Gosho states, At first there were no signs of punishment among the persecutors, but now, twenty-seven years later, the Buddhist gods such as Bonten, Taishaku, Nitten, Gatten, and the four great heavenly kings seem to be working earnestly, fearing that if they should not fulfill their oath, they will fall into the hell of incessant suffering.

This key phrase explains the state of affairs of the entire nation (see following chart) as well as the ends met by the individual who slandered the law of the universe. Four taiten believers involved in the arrest of farmers harvesting crops were thrown from their horses and killed.

The fate of Hei-no Saemon, an insidious figure in Buddhist history, was not sealed until years later. Exactly 14 years after Atsuhara, the young Shogunate who succeeded the Regent’s death learned that Hei-no Saemon, his own chief of military forces, had stirred up revolt against him. He summoned all of his troops and had them surround the lands on which Hei-no Saemon lived. They killed the entire family. The eldest son, Munetsuna, was exiled to Sado Island. Hei-no Saemon and his favorite son, Iinuma Hangan, were summarily beheaded on the same spot used for the execution of three simple farmers 14 years before.

Each day one’s searching mind molds his future

Throughout all of this turmoil, the growing ranks of believers held fast to their faith. It was this determination that demonstrated the quest of common people for the true philosophy of life. Therefore, on October 12, 1279, Nichiren Daishonin inscribed the Dai-Gohonzon and dedicated it to all mankind.

This Gosho was presented to Shijo Kingo and later circulated amongst the believers in Atsuhara to encourage them to be steadfast in their practice and to assure them the protection of the forces of the universe. The closing words still express the spirit of victory in life today: Deepen your faith day by day and month after month. Should you slacken even a bit in your faith, demons will possess you. President Ikeda once lectured on this Gosho and explained the meaning of this phrase. He said that we should always strive to make our faith stronger. When a person slips backward, he creates a void into which demons can creep. Worst of all is the King Devil of the Sixth Heaven (Dairokuten-no Mao) which will make a person forsake the Gohonzon. In practical terms, demons indicate the lack of vitality, the loneliness, the feeling of being left behind and the doubt which takes over when a person does not have a seeking mind during a meeting, or when he feels uninspired during a moving talk by another member. Thus demons are a counterpart to the positive direction that a seeking mind yields.

Perils and Disasters of 13th-century Japan

The chronological table below itemizes major disasters during the period between the birth of Nichiren Daishonin and the presentation of his thesis of remonstration to the government some 30 years later. In the Rissho Ankokuron, which he addressed to the Kamakura government, and in many other writings, he refers to calamities and suffering which 13th-century Japan had endured.

To a country almost totally subsisting on agriculture, storms, drought or unseasonal weather have a particularly damaging and long-range effect. Almost exclusive use of wood in constructing cities made them virtual fire traps. Disease was particularly crippling because the feudal system clustered the houses of cities close to the local ruling lord. The population density, poor sanitation and ignorance of hygiene all took their toll.

1224 December — Nationwide epidemics
1225 Spring — Nationwide epidemics
1226 August — Major earthquake hits Kamakura
1227 January — Typhoon hits Kyoto
1227 April — A rash of unexplained deaths nationwide
1227 November — Unseasonal weather and sporadic outbreaks of smallpox
1228 July — Storms and flooding in Kyoto
1229 December — Major fire in Kamakura
1230 January — Nationwide famine, major earthquake hits Kamakura
1231 July — Severe famine throughout nation
1232 June — Unusually long rain spell in Kyoto
1233 February — Epidemic in Kyoto
1233 May — Kamo river floods Kyoto
1234 — Major fire in Kyoto
1235 April — Thunderstorms and hail storm devastate Kyoto
1236 March — Floods hit Kamakura
1238 — Chaotic weather conditions throughout the year; spectacular meteor showers (considered a bad omen by ancients)
1239 — Nightly atmospheric phenomenon (not clearly reported)
1240 February — Major earthquake in Kamakura. Hachiman shrine leveled
1241 February — Major earthquake and tidal wave in Kamakura
1243 May — Typhoon in Kyoto
1243 June — Extensive flooding in Kyoto
1244 November — Deluge and flooding in Kamakura
1245 March — Apparent change of sun’s color
1245 July — Two suns visible in Kyoto
1245 July — Severe quake in Kyoto
1245 November — Sky remains dark in daylight hours
1246 December — Severe quake in Kyoto
1247 March — Butterflies swarm in Kamakura (considered bad omen)
1247 September — Storms batter Kamakura
1247 November — Severe quake hits Kamakura
1248 September — Heavy rains and flooding in Western Japan
1249 March — Fire devastates much of Kyoto
1250 February — Mimosuso river turns red
1251 February — Fire in Kamakura
1251 April — Heavy rains in Kamakura
1251 June — Freak cold snap. Major rivers freeze
1251 July-Aug. — Snows in Kamakura
1251 August — Heavy thunderstorm in Kamakura
1252 February — Extensive damage from fire in Kamakura
1253 February — Heavy storms and earthquake in Kamakura
1253 June — Major earthquake in Kamakura
1253 December — Major fire in Kamakura
1254 January — Major fire with high death toll in Kamakura followed by earthquake in Kyoto
1254 July — Typhoon levels much of Kamakura
1255 June — Meteor showers visible in Kyoto
1255 December — Earthquake hits Kyoto
1256 August — Extensive flooding in Kamakura with heavy loss of life
1256 September — Widespread outbreak of smallpox
1257 March — Rain of ashes falls on Kyoto
1257 May — Storms buffet Kyoto
1257 June — Severe drought
1257 August — Major earthquake in Kamakura
1258 August — Heavy storms in Kyoto and Kamakura
1258 October — Rains and flooding in Kamakura with heavy death toll
1259 Spring — Nationwide epidemics and famine continue throughout year
1260 April — Large fire in Kamakura
1260 June — Storms and flooding in Kamakura
1260 August — Nationwide storms and epidemics continue throughout year

[Map: Japan of the Daishonin’s Lifetime]