Q&A with President Ikeda
NSA Quarterly, Fall 1973 (Vol. I, No. 3), pp. 126–129. World Tribune Press, Santa Monica.
Contents of this issue · All issues · View the original scan
This text has been checked and corrected against the printed magazine. The Japanese-language sections of each issue are not included.
Buddhism. Related to Gods
QUESTION: It’s been said that all the gods worshipped in the world are depicted on the Gohonzon. Does this mean that all of the socalled Western gods stem from Buddhism? ANSWER: There is an essential difference between Buddhism and those religions which regard a god as an object of worship. If the core of their philosophy is probed into, then gods, as they define them, can be said to be part of Buddhism as well.
At the outset, I would like to clarify the concept of what a god is. Firstly, there is the so-called omnipotent God of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Then, there are those gods which personify the many forces of nature and the universe.
The omnipotent God is said to have created everything in the universe, animate or inanimate, including man himself. This monotheistic God is worshipped to the exclusion of the possible existence of any other god.
Gods which personify forces of nature or the universe are referred to variously as the “Sun God” or the gods of thunder, lightning, wind, the seas, earth and so on. The “Sun God” was worshipped nearly universally. In Egypt, it was known as Ra; in Japan, as Tensho Daijin; in the ancient Incas, as the god Inti. The gods of thunder and lightning were worshipped as Zeus in ancient Greece, Jupiter in Rome and Odin in Teutonic Germany.
In the third category, gods are either ancestors or dead heroes. The Nikko Shrine in Japan deifies the image of Tokugawa Ieyasu, founder of the Tokugawa Shogunate in the seventeenth century. The Nogi, Togo and Yasukuni Shrines were built for the same purpose. In China, Komei and Kanu-u of the Sangaku Era in the second and third centuries were sanctified. In Europe, Joan of Arc is revered almost as a god herself.
On the contrary, Buddhism explains that the Buddha is a person who is enlightened to the essential laws of life and the universe. These are the fundamental laws which pervade and embody all dynamic and natural phenomena. The Buddha is neither a hero nor an extraordinary man; his nobility derives from the wisdom and the law to which he is enlightened.
In other words, the Buddha is not a person of special quality, but the most integral and ordinary of men. However, because he is enlightened to the essential law of life and the universe, he functions in rhythm with that law and can draw from a limitless source, experiencing a magnificent life force based within himself.
Herein lies the prime distinction between the worship of a god based upon power, and the teaching of Buddhism which is based upon law. Since the power of a god is peculiar only to that particular deity, it is lost at the time of the deified person’s death. Because the law of the Buddha originally permeates the universe, it exists independently of the life or death of the Buddha.
Further, the power of a god is instilled in that one particular deity. An ordinary man could never hope to emulate it. On the contrary, the philosophy of Buddhism allows for anyone and everyone to master the law of the Buddha.
The comparative relationship between Buddhism and god is the next consideration. This can be observed in light of what has already been established up until now.
From an overall universal standpoint, the forces of nature are partial functions of the universe. In other words. the previously mentioned gods are included in Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, the law of the universe.
The monotheistic God of the Judeo-Christian tradition, who is assumed to have created the universe, is no exception to this argument. Matter, once floating in space, condensed because of gravitational forces, thus forming stars and nebulae. Then life came into existence and organisms began to evolve. This indicates that life was manifested by the law which pervades the entire universe. It is therefore conceivable that the so-called omnipotent God can be a personification of this law.
The gods that are worshipped as dead heroes and ancestors were men of extraordinary strength and wisdom. They possessed unusual powers in one way or another. However, they failed to comprehend the very law of life itself; though they were gods they committed errors, fought each other or ended their lives in misery. They were only partially cognizant of the universal law.
If we view what a god and Buddha are from this standpoint, their relationship can be made clear.
Love or Mercy
QUESTION: It has been argued that the mercy of Buddhism is needed in lieu of Christian love in order to rejuvenate modern civilization. Can this induce a great reformation that will touch the foundation of Western civilization?
ANSWER: Both Christian love and Buddhist mercy are ideologically compatible in that they aspire toward the same goal. Yet they are different in depth and impact
Buddhist mercy, Jihi, is defined as “to relieve suffering and give contentment.” There is no qualitative definition of love. There is no distinction in Christianity between love for God, for parents or love between a man and woman.
Love suggests the potential of relieving suffering and giving contentment just as mercy does, but the true nature of love is not clearly defined. It seems that Buddhist mercy, which can be seen and is clearly defined, clarifies the ambiguous concept of love which has been the ideal of Christianity. Buddhist mercy actualizes the ideals of Christian love.
Buddhist mercy naturally encompasses relieving suffering and giving contentment. [hat is its basic meaning. Behind, or perhaps within Buddhist mercy is a philosophy of daily living which points the way to reform people’s lives and manifests mercy. In other words, Buddhist mercy is not just acting upon a belief or thought. Instead, it is shown in a person’s behavior through the process of fundamental revolution of his life.
How can we accomplish an actual reformation of our lives? By drawing out the life of Buddhahood, which is in turn attributed to the power of the Gohonzon. Therefore, when we say that Buddhist mercy supplants the concept of Christian love, we do not just mean switching the two, replacing one with the other. Essentially it is not just a question between two terms or concepts. We are questioning an essence of faith.
If Christian love had been carried out as it was preached, Europe would now have quite a different history. It is apparent that Christian love has, in fact, repeated every kind of atrocity and has not built the ideal society which Christ prophesied.
It is within reason to assert that the history of the Christian world has been a succession of misery and bloodshed. It started with their own persecution. It included the holy wars and witch trials in the middle ages, the religious revolutions and so on up to the present day.
One philosopher pointed out that the underlying cause of this misery has been the uncompromising character of Judaism, the root of Christianity. Other scholars feel that it necessarily originates in the object of Christian faith — the crucifix.
Their argument asserts, that, because a person worships the image of his master’s torturous death, he will not only have hatred toward the enemies who executed Jesus Christ, but will also detest those who are non-Christians.
It seems that the impulse arising from a sort of hatred and hostility because of worshipping the crucifix is more dominant than the concept of love explained in the Bible. These dark emotions have not yet lost their devilish influence upon Westerners or humanity as a whole.
A capitalist may regard Marxism as “heretical,” declaring that it should be destroyed — a Marxist feels just the opposite. Even within the Communist world, there is a serious conflict between China and the Soviet Union. Each country thinks it is right.
The potential crisis which veils the current world finds its substance in hatred amongst men. In America, young people have been crying out for the abolishment of war and for a return to love. We do not in the least deny the love they seek. We simply proclaim that the only way to realize this love is through the religious movement of true Buddhism.
Breakdown of Matter
QUESTION: In modern science, the elementary particle has been defined as the smallest unit of matter. There are two major streams of thought on this issue: One is that the elementary particle is a state of matter in which there can be no further division; the other is that there is no final basic unit, in a way resembling Mao Tse-tung’s statement that everything is divisible. This whole issue seems to fall more into the domain of philosophy than science. Please give us your views as to which idea is correct. Is there any other way to interpret this situation?
ANSWER: The issue of the origin of matter has been discussed ever since the time of Thales in ancient Greece. The atom has now been explored by modern physics. However the existence of the atom was assumed philosophically by Democritus, the Greek philosopher of the late fifth and early fourth centuries B.C.
Modern science has progressed according to the laws of hypothesis and experimentation. At one time, the molecule was considered to be the smallest structure of matter. Probing more deeply into this unit revealed the existence of a still smaller object. This was named the atom and was assumed to be as small a bit of matter as one could obtain.
However, subsequent research revealed that even the atom is not the ultimate component of matter. It is apparently comprised of even smaller constituents — elementary particles. The atom is generally believed to consist of a densely packed nucleus surrounded by a cloud of electrons, the former being composed of protons, neutrons, mesons and other particles. Scientists have so far identified over 300 kinds of elementary particles. They now imply that they may be able to divide each of these particles into still smaller bits of matter.
Of course, at this stage of the game we are still unable to prove this assertion. That is why it belongs within the arena of philosophy rather than science. I feel that the ultimate unit of matter, after all is said and done, will not be discovered. In ancient Greek philosophy, there were two lines of thought. One was the idea of Democritus that all matter can be analyzed according to the basic unit of the atom. The other, expounded by Heraclitus, was that “all things are flowing.” Science has progressed according to Democritus’ way of thinking, temporarily defining a basic unit. This has been a necessity, at least in terms of methodology.
Still, a question arises. Is the true basic unit definable philosophically? It appears as though it will never become stable or comprehensible within the range of man’s thinking and reasoning facilities. Buddhism expounded it as Nam-myoho-renge-kyo. Myo implies mystic, while mystic suggests the inconceivable with regard to only the faculty of thought.
It seems just as impossible to determine a stable size for the smallest unit of matter as it does to determine the size of the entire universe. Be it micro or macro, a substance which extends infinitely cannot be absolutely grasped through an analytical and stationary frame of thought.
One can grasp only partial aspects of a given substance through scientific logic. The moment it appears to have been understood, it already has changed and acquired additional elements. Philosophical examination can cope with the totality of a constantly changing and flowing object, necessitating understanding through synthesis rather than analysis.
